Honest John’s Whiskey and Provisions

Service okay, but not great. The hostess seems very disinterested in the customers or even being there. The atmosphere would be great if was not so loud from the bar and the bar entertainment.
Had chicken and biscuit twice, the chicken was okay on the first try, but dry the second time and the biscuit was no good either time
Had a steak sandwich last and I will never make that mistake again. The fries were the best part. They have much better steak sandwiches at the sub shop in Lady Lake.
It was small for the price and who puts cheese sauce on a steak sandwich??? Cheese sauce. really???
3 stars is a bit generous.

Went there twice… hands down the worst food in The Villages. My husband and I were both shocked McDonald’s has better food (not kdding.)

First, our hostess was very professional, courteous, and knowledgeable. I think she was fairly new there. Her name is Cassidy and she had exceptional manners. Skye was our sever. He was completely knowledgeable about the menu and drinks. When I could not think of a drink to get for my g/​f he immediately had an idea and she loved it. It was a whiskey sour with mixed fruits. Skye was attentive, prompt, and pleasant. As a team Cassidy and Skye were first-​rate.
The food was delicious. I had the Grilled Scottish Salmon with mashed potatoes and asparagus. My date had the 8oz Filet with mashed potatoes and asparagus. Both were remarkable. Salmon cooked perfectly with caramelized glaze and Filet tender and juicy! The mashed potatoes were so delightful that it was difficult not to ask for more. For desert we had the Slow Churned Vanilla Ice Cream with Chocolate Shell Drizzle, Almond Nut Crumble, and Blueberry Caviar and a Chocolate Cabernet Flour-​less Tort. Oh my.
This was a very satisfying dining evening. Thank you, Honest John’s.

I think this place is way better than some of the reviews suggest. We took our family here for an early dinner and they had our table ready. We ordered several items and the portions where huge! Burger, fish and chips, salad, and their version of a cheese steak were all very good. The service was good and waiter was attentive. I didn’t think we had was way over priced, but I did want a steak when I got there but ruled it out because it was a bit expensive for not being a $$$ or $$$$ place.

Great food. Wanted a larger Whiskey selection but the Chicken Avocado was absolutely amazing!

Back and forth back and forth. 1 star…5 stars. Food was great. Seating area clean. So 5 stars? When we got there the place had 3 tables worth of guest in a place with 30 tables. We had a party of 9. Push 3 tables together and go? Apparently not. We waited for 15 – 20 min while our hostess walked around. Talked to some staff. Came back to the hostess station. Walked around. Talked to staff. Finally pushed 2 tables together then got annoyed when we said we wouldn’t fit at 2 tables. This place has great food and awesome design. My parents stopped eating here because they said this happens all the time even when just 2 people want to eat. Not sure what the hostess does other then seat people but she can’t seem to get that right. I would avoid this place if you have any other options.

Was down here for Leesburg bikefest 2016. Decided to ride out to Lake sumter landing. We started off with the artichoke dip which was amazing. One of the freshest tasting dips I’ve had.
I can’t comment on alcohol because I did not have any due to being on the motor.
For entrée I had the angel hair shrimp, very good tasting cream sauce not to much, but also enough for the pasta, the shrimp tasted deliciously fresh. My buddy, whom has a gluten allergy, ordered the filet mignon steak, his risotto was actually gluten free so he was able to enjoy his meal. According to my buddy, the steak was properly cooked, well seasoned, and tender.
When we asked the waitress about gluten free options, she immediately went and sought out an answer for dinning options. Definitely will go back when I’m back in the area.

Have you ever had Poutine? It is considered a Canadian treat, but you can get it here and it is scrumptious. I am not going to describe it to you so you can get a pleasant surprise yourself (it alone was worth the visit). After we split the Poutine I got the bratwurst and it was very good. Our friends both had the cheese burgers and said they were great. The highlight was my wife’s Croque Monsieur. she said it was the best sandwich she has ever had — hard to believe, but it changed my rating from a 3 to a 4. If you go there and order the Poutine and the Croque Monsieur let me know, since the combo should be a 5 star. Sara L. was our server and she was perfect.
We will be back.

Mixed experience. Very rude hostess. Service at bar was great. Food was average. Might try again.

The burger was good, but not amazing (I had a much better burger at Bonefish, of all places). The fries were average to good. It seems the prices are a bit higher than most places in the area. The atmosphere is good, but they missed some important details in the decorating. It’s not the greatest local to watch a game, as the tv’s are limited. We had a good spot at he bar and it was acceptable, although the tv wasn’t large. The wait staff were not over friendly and the bartender didn’t seem to enjoy her job, which was noticed by almost everyone around us. I would go there again, but they need to make a few changes if they want to stay in business, because there is lots of competition.

Excellent service, great atmosphere, tasty food. Must try the poutine! Amazing! They serve complementary popcorn which is the best ever! Went for lunch and ate half sandwich and soup, perfect amount of food at a very good price!

Service was slow. Food was average. Price was high. Due to architecture; very loud.

I thought the food was fabulous. I went there with my wife, son and his girlfriend and the service was excellent. We did not call ahead so there was a line, but they were more than accommodating and seated pretty quickly. I liked that they gave us a snack of popcorn while we were waiting. I’m definitely coming back.

Amazing food, I loved every part! The menu prices are priced perfectly, with the most expensive being only $ 32 for the filet. There was a small line when arrived, but we were seated quickly, and given the best popcorn I’ve ever had. I had a burger and it was delicious! We also got the poutine and it is to die for! The service was spot on, and for the higher quality of service and food, this is priced perfectly. I live in Winter Park, and would go back and make the drive over just to eat there again!

This place was DELICIOUS! I adored my spicy margaritas, I’m difficult because I always want my margs nice and hot and that can be hard for certain a bars and restaurants. But this place did them just right! They were blazing hot and amazing. Both of our meals were outstanding and our waitress was so nice we came back the next day for lunch (and another marg). See you guys next time we’re in The Villages

We have eaten at Honest Johns now 4 times and it has gotten better each time! Tonight I had the chicken avocado entrée with a mild citrus sauce and that is by far my favorite entrée so far… Excellent! Each and every time the service had been excellent and tonight we had Sarah, and she was a delight… I was so happy that she suggested my entrée. I think it’s a great place within The Villages… Seeing that in general, I haven’t found anything to be great. Actually, in the land of mid priced mediocrity it’s a treasure! I don’t mean that in a snobby fashion, but it’s too much of everything fried! So this is great.

Went to Honest John’s for the first time tonight. Our waiter, Skye was great. Very knowledgable and on the ball. My husband and I both had steak. Excellent! Even the green beans were good as were the mashed potatoes and the fries. This is one of the best meals we have had in the villages and certainly the best steak. It might cost a bit more than the other places in town but worth it for quality and taste.
The only improvement would be the hostess. Not very friendly.

Great additon to LSL Town Square. Cool bar and expense did not stand in the way when it came to décor. Drink menu great choices of good drinking Whiskey of all types. Menu albiet pricey offers great choices. Try the Crab Devil Eggs or Steak Tar Tar both 10 out of 10. Steak were cook as ordered.
Excellent choice.

Went to check in out.
Poor service.
Wine list was $ 7 for 5oz and $ 11 for 6oz of the same wine. Asked the bartender, she told us that actually you only get 4oz for $ 7 not 5oz. When we ordered we received the smallest pour.

For a soft opening, not too bad. I had a$ 13 shrimp Po Boy sandwich and it was good. Wife had ok salad. Daughter had chicken wings — ok. Gdaughter had so so chicken fingers. Small menu. Interesting bar structure which included bench seats.
Steaks appear to be a specialty BUT, prices are high for a casual restaurant — $ 27 to about $ 40!
Right now it is a 3 for me. Some good some bad. Only the future will tell.