Farrago Market Cafe

Great smiling waitresses. Good pizza. Prompt and continual good service. Love the menu. Choices forever the pickiest eater. Huge salads. Loved my mountain man pizza.

Love the fresh lamb gyros. The staff Cleaned our outside table with a friendly smile. Family and dog friendly place. Will eat there again

Just ate a Mountain Man pizza. It was great. Service was very good. Highly recommend. House salad will easily feed four.

Oh man so good! We got their twist on a Hawaiian pizza. It sounded funky on the menu but was SO GOOD! We went back the next day and got another. Super friendly and welcoming staff. Pizza seriously weighed 3 pounds. Amazing!

The only dog friendly patio in old town Pagosa Springs. Great food, vegetarian options (extremely rare in cattle country) and a very nice shaded, large outdoor space that is super dog friendly.
The friendly staff is always smiling and the menu choices have something for everyone.

Farragos is the best! I highly recommend visiting this place if you’re in Pagosa. I could eat there at least twice a week. I highly recommend the fish and chips and the gyro. The food comes out fairly quick and is always fresh. If you come at night, it can be a little packed, but they have a great patio for outdoor seating.

I’ve sat down/​ordered take out from this place 7 – 8 times. I would say that it’s been a pretty sub-​par and inconsistent experience. We took a group of 10 here, 50 minutes after placing our order, our waitress announced that she had lost our ticket and that «these things happen». An apology was not included, she insisted on that this was a perfectly normal experience/​mistake. After we made a little bit of a stink about it, they gave us a couple of free cookies for our $ 100+ bill and basically told us to get lost. To summarize this place, the food is good– but don’t expect any sort of «WOW» customer service. I really think I would come here a lot if it hadn’t been for the repeat-​disaster experiences… Maybe I’m just the lucky one?

Stopped here on a recommendation from someone local. Interesting little place. They have pre-​made salads and we tried the green chile chicken pasta salad. That was delish! The salmon tacos were also very good. I only gave 4 stars cause it didn’t knock my socks off. I would go back though and try other stuff. Cute little outdoor seating too!

There are certain things you should just make, serve, and move on. If you like lamb gyros dont order the lamb gyros here, nasty lamb, and non-​traditional sauce equals nothing good. There are better options in town.

We ordered via a delivery service while staying at a cabin in PS. The food was pretty good. We ordered quesadillas which weren’t what we expected (there wasn’t a description on the delivery menu) — we aren’t really sure what was in them. Maybe artichoke hearts? Goat cheese? We weren’t fans. We were expecting traditional-​type of quesadillas. My husband got the salmon and chips and said it was really good. My son and I ordered the ham and swiss panini with sweet potato fries — we both really enjoyed it. The portions were really big and it was great to have it delivered to our cabin door!

Lamb was very gamey, salsa was tasty. Kids pizza was burnt and plain. Great garden for outdoor seating.

Such a cute little café hidden away in Pagosa!
I had the lamb gyro for lunch and shared a greek salad with my mom. The gyro was HUGE, way bigger than I expected but super tasty. I was sad I didn’t realize the gyro came with olives, because I hate them and would have asked for them to be removed, but oh well you live and learn. The tzatziki sauce tasted different than normal but the ingredients in the sandwich were fresh and there was a good amount of meat.
The salad was delicious as well; I really enjoyed the dressing which was light and tasty. Since the weather was nice we were able to sit outside and enjoy the sunshine :) This is a great lunchtime spot and I’ll definitely be back when I’m in Pagosa!

I have two words for you: Salmon Tacos. So good!

This five star review is mainly based on the salmon tacos which were so incredibly wonderful that a week later I am still thinking about them! Well cooked salmon (ok. it could have been a tad less done – but minor quibble) wrapped in a tortilla with napa cabbage and some delicious sauce. One order gets you two of these substantial beauties.
We also had the Greek salad, that, while not spectacular, was good. The ham and cheese panini gets a C+.
I don’t know why they serve on disposable plates and have plastic cutlery, but there’s probably a reason.
Will most definitely return if I’m ever back/​near Pagosa Springs. And, it’ll definitely be for those tacos!

Saturday night and the place is almost empty, not a real beginning. Waitress took our order and didn’t write anything down. Only two of us eating and we ordered one appetizer and two entrees. She forgot about our appetizer, but brought it out promptly when we went to the back to ask about it.
Our food arrived a few minutes later, so not a lot of time to eat the appetizer. I ordered a burger med rare, but it came well done. Wife order a sausage and mushroom, but a pepperoni and mushroom came.
All the food was mediocre, and the service was so lousy I cannot give this place more than 2 stars.

The food here is delicious and reasonably priced. The service was great and the outdoor patio was really nice.
Located downtown and has easy access, a great place to stop for lunch.

We actually headed to pagosa after getting engaged earlier in the day and had been recommended this place so we gave it a try. Both my partner and i are cows milk intolerant but they have other cheese which we had on the pizzas (manchego and goats). The waitress was so lovely and accommodating and the pizzas were really fabulous!
I really enjoyed it, great food, great service, wine bar adjacent so can have a nice glass with dinner and outdoor seating-​i had a great night :-)

The pizzas here are big and filling! There are lots of toppings to choose from including my favorite, roasted garlic.
The Cajun wings are fried, rubbed with Cajun seasoning, and served with ranch on the side. Simple but good.

Five star service! The lamb is phenomenal! I like game meat that taste like game, a great smokey hint. Rest of the family for pizza everyone was very satisfied! We even talked about having a second meal here later in the trip.

I drove through here on a road trip across country and made it my pit stop because there’s hot springs near by. Who doesn’t want a nice soak after a log drive.
I walked around the neighborhood and there wasn’t much for options for a budget conscience person. This was the only place that looked decent enough that was still open at 8pm.
Food: I ordered a Ham and Swiss Panini with a side of shoestring fries. Ham and swiss panini was awesome. Satisfied my stomach, very edible. Shoestring fries on the other hand, I would not order again. I thought shoestring would be the skinny crunchy type of fries. They turned out to be the thicker straight fries. Lacked flavor and seasoning. If I wanted thick cut fries, I would have ordered KFC. But these were the frozen kind.
As the other reviewer said regarding the atmosphere, you can see the «kitchen» area and the fridge. There is a pizza turn table as well. It was not as asthetically pleasing. However, you can just take a few steps out the door and sit outside. They have fire pits where you can relax.
Surprisingly, they also have siracha for some reason. Interesting for a pizza, panini place.
Must get Durango soda pops. Yum! I got the grape, root beer, and ginger. I couldn’t help myself for microbrews of soda from the same state I’m in. I did not drink them all in one night, but they were both good.
Definitely a good place to go for food. There was definitely a wait as well even though there were not that many people dining.