Toppers Pizza

Hmm, so I had no idea this place was a chain until after I had committed to giving it a try. Interestingly the locals from my workshop seemed to down on the place while I find it to be one of the better chain pizza delivery places I’ve had. I tried the macaroni and cheese pizza based on the recommendation of the person at the counter. Overall the pizza is a four and a large pizza could easily likely feed three people (it was my dinner and then breakfast for the next three days).
I took off a star for a combination of the price and since the counter clerk failed to inform me of the specials. Since I was buying a large pizza at regular menu price there was a coupon for free breadsticks on the back of the flyer sitting right in front of me. Perhaps I should have known that there was some special somewhere (most chain pizza places always have some special going on) but since the counter person knew I was from out of town (we talked about it) I was pretty disappointed in that lack of customer service. $ 20 for a pizza is a little pricey, but for pizza and bread sticks I would have been happier with the price.
Pro tip for the locals… Check online, as I said, seems that there is always some sort of special going.

We got delivery. Pizza and wings. The online ordering process was a little confusing why we would pay more for the wings when I realized we got two sauces instead of one.
Pizza was good. Chicken wings were good. Delivery was super fast.

Tried this place after a concert downtown Indy. We called in a pizza order. We arrived and after checking out we discovered we had a box of topperstix. We explained the confusion and they offered us a free pizza in 10minutes. I appreciate the customer service and the food was good too! This is definitely a place to consider if you need some late night food!

Just got delivery from here super late, like 2:30am. Whoever took my order over the phone was super nice and patient and the delivery guy was great as well. And the food is wonderful. Toppers should definitely be your late night choice, or anytime choice.

My first experience with Toppers was on 12/​11/​2015. I just returned to Indy from Ohio. I’m a truck driver, and hungry as ever. I pass the Toppers every morning and decided to give them a try. I ordered the Maui pizza, it was absolutely amazing. Matt was awesome, the young lady that delivered my pizza was as well. I definitely love your pizza and will be a returning customer. Thanks for the awesome service. Sincerely, Scott Stratton

Disrespectful and rude man on the phone. Called at 1:30.waited for 16 mins to be told that delivery would be 1 hr and 30 mins to 2 hrs… are you ok with that? Waited for no response then hung up. Wow mgmt

SOoooooooooooooooooooo delicious. Best pizza in town. Eat all of the pizzas NOM

This place is absolutely fantastic. No more traditional pepperoni pizzas! The tater tot pizza is my favorite. Nacho cheese, mozzarella, bacon bits, tater tots. What’s better all at once? Also, I had it delivered to my apartment and I can honestly say it was the first delivery guy I’ve ever seen be happy and act appreciative for my business. The price is a little higher than the other chain places, but you get such a great tasting, non traditional pizza that it’s really worth it!

Ordered the Bacon Sticks, and they were absolutely delicious. We asked that they make the sticks with extra love in the special instructions box, and they went above and beyond our expectations. Thanks Toppers!

I placed an order around 7pm and the guy told me he would have my pizza and wings there in 25 minutes. «Yeah right» I thought and he was wrong, it got here in 23. Holy cow, and on a Friday night! The pizza was delicious, hot and fresh, boneless wings were good too. I am sure there may have been issues with long waits for delivery in the past, but not anymore. I will be ordering from here again very soon and recommend you give it a try as well.

We ordered 11 pizzas for work one Friday and they all were delicious! The tater tot pizza is very good! The thin crust was very good — our favorite for sure. Service was quick and pizza was hot and fresh. Give it a shot!

We will not return to this establishment. Below you will see an email from the store manager asking for my phone number and for my credit card number so she could refund our money for the bad experience. 2 emails and half a dozen phone calls later she has not replied, called or refunded our money as promised. I even went so far as to call the corporate offices in Wisconsin and they were going to reach out to her and that has not happened either. You see what true management is when things go bad by how they react and what action they take. She sent a really impressive email but then totally dropped the ball and showed her true «I don’t give a crap attitude. Toppers is not the only good pizza in Indy and we do not have to drive a half hour to be disrespected. I will now dispute the charges with my credit card company.
Good Evening John,
Today, I received the comment you left on our website about your experience at the Toppers Pizza in Downtown Indianapolis. Firstly, I want to thank you for your feedback on your experience last night. It is always greatly appreciated so we can continually learn, improve, and grow as pizza heroes and as a company. I also want to thank you for your first review of us from your experience on January 31^st. That was quite the killer review you originally gave us and made me feel really great about my team. I am so sorry that the second review couldn’t be as great.
I am sincerely sorry for the service and unsatisfactory food you received last night. This is completely unacceptable. I fully understand why you would be so upset and I agree that you should be. You were 100 percent correct in thinking that you could come in and order the BOGO in shop and not over that internet. I can assure you that the reason that it says «online only» in the menus is to drive pizza lovers to our website, which keeps getting better and better. It is not meant to limit that offer to online ordering only. I am so sorry for not effectively communicating this to my team. Please trust that I am personally speaking to each team member about these deals so it never happens again.
I also want to apologize for the incorrect and unsatisfactory food quality. These are never things that I want to hear about our product and personally, do not tolerate. I too believe that Toppers Pizza is some of the best pizza I have ever eaten and want the entire world to think as well. I want to refund your credit card the $ 39.21 for your order last night. In addition, if it would be alright with you, I want to send you some coupons to make it up to you. You can use them at your leisure or whenever you feel ready to, if you ever feel ready to; they will not have an expiration date. I very much want you to be able to try the wings again, more of our crazy toppings, and delicious Topperstix.
It really means a lot to me on a personal level that someone would take the time and money to drive as far as you do to come to our store and to choose us over every other place out there. It also means a lot that you take the time to be so detailed in how your experience was. I hope that you will accept the coupons and give us another chance. John, you honestly do mean a great deal to us.
I was hoping that you left your phone number with the comment so I could talk to you personally. If you would be willing to give me it, I can contact you about getting your card refunded. All I need to do is get the card number from you since we do not keep any records of those for security reasons. I also would love to verify that the address you provide is the address to send the coupons to.
Please feel free to email, call, or even stop into Toppers so we can take care of this. I will be here everyday the rest of this week, Thursday 10:30 am-10:00 pm, Friday 10:30 am-8:00 pm, Saturday 5:00 pm-​close, and Sunday 5:00 pm-10:00 pm.
Thank you again and my sincerest apologies,
Sara Shaffer, General Manager Toppers Pizza IUPUI
T.P. of Champaign, Inc. | d/​b/​a Toppers Pizza · Never Settle
910 W. 10^th St., Suite 12 · Indianapolis, IN 46 202

I just found one of my new favorite pizza places! I have to admit there is quite a wait picking up but it was worth it! I can see why they are busy, snow is here, people don’t want to cook so there is perhaps a demand for delivery? I mean i waited extra 10 – 12 mins for my pizza just because they messed up one of my orders, but the order the messed up they gave me the pizza which they accidentally made it maui Hawaiian instead of chicken BBQ. They were very nice about and apologized for messing up. I must admit it was hard to finish 3 mediums between 2 people, but I guess i have lunch and dinner for the next few days! Also, they have 4 TVs and a nice couch with a few tables you can perhaps sit down to enjoy your pizza. So its not to bad of a wait if your going inside to pick up, at least you have some entertainment while your waiting.

My friends introduced me to Toppers Pizza a few weeks ago with the tater tot pizza and buffalo chicken pizza — both were so unique and delicious. The tater tot pizza is pretty much my favorite, though, and since then I’ve ordered it twice for home delivery. If you like unique toppings on your pizza, this the way to go!

I waited 35 minutes for a personal pizza. Pizza was awesome but it was kind of really lame waiting here and reading all the jibberish on the walls. I think artsy pizza shops are now way too mainstream, how about a an old-​school pizza shop now for a change?

Definitely don’t ask for delivery unless you’re okay with a three hour wait.
Awful service, making the pizza seem very overpriced. How about you try Bazbeux? Or Papa Johns? All better options.

More like a 3.5 in my book but I’ll be generous and give it a 4.
This place is open until 3am on Saturdays, later than any of the other close by pizza places.
The employee that took our order on a Friday night was extremely nice. My friends and I were definitely not sober but the employee handled us really well, never acted like he was annoyed or that he didn’t want to deal with us.
The pizza itself was average for a pizza delivery place. I would probably choose this place over the Papa John’s diagonally across the street. There aren’t that many tables inside, though.

It makes me sad to see the bad reviews about Toppers because this was our first time trying it and they hit a home run with us!
We got the loaded tot-​zza, parmesan garlic boneless chicken and the chocolate bacon topper-​stix. Everything was hot, generously topped, delicious and only came up to $ 25. We got our order for carry out, it was ready in 15 min at 10:45 on a Friday night, and the guys working were super nice.
The fun, unique menu options are what drew us in and is what is gonna keep us coming back. I’d say to at least give it a try. We loved it :)

Toppers Pizza — not quite top notch.
I happened upon Toppers Pizza quite by accident. I was planning to visit another «newish» spot (
), but the line was snaking its way out the door. My companion and I decided to stroll across the street and ran right into Toppers.
The pizza was good. Nothing to celebrate with a parade in the street, but certainly worth a try. There are a variety of menu options and topping choices. The space is very small with only one 4-​person high top table, about 6 bar stools, and a couch/​conversation nook. I assume Toppers wants you to take your treats to-​go.
I would recommend Toppers if you just want something quick, easy, and relatively reasonably priced. But, don’t make a special trip. This is definitely a «because I was in the area and kind of wanted pizza» spot.

Went on a whim-​people from work had ordered for lunch, and the breadsticks on the menu looked delicious! How can anything covered in cheese not be wonderful? It is virtually impossible.
I got them, and they were amazing. I mean amazing. Slightly garlicky, cheesy, and greasy. I got rranch and marinara or some kind of tomato sauce. The ranch was the best pick. It isn’t homemade (comes in a pre-​packaged container, as did the red sauce), but it complimented the sticks well.
I tried a piece of pizza that I could not tell you the name of from my co-​workers lunch. It had bacon and cheese and was yummy. Next time I am at work and we order out, I am insisting on Toppers.