Monte Di Procida Ristorante & Pizzeria

Went last night I had the lamb chops which were delicious. My husband had the spaghetti puttanesca both tasted like we were back in Italy so good. We will absolutely be back!

Horrible service and things are dirty and the owner is not only a waitress but doesn’t know how to run a resturaunt … Disrespectful and not professional in any way I wouldn’t recommend this place to my worst enemy. Dirty bathrooms and not healthy for any type of person including and especially a person who is expecting …

Had a terrible experience here!!! The owner was so rude to my sister (who is pregnant). She ordered a tortellini dinner, but when it came it was meat tortellini. We explained to the waitress that the menu didn’t state whether it was meat or cheese, and in our experience if it doesn’t specify either way it’s usually cheese tortellini. Anyway, the waitress was very abrupt and just exclaimed, «It wasn’t my mistake, so I’ll have to charge you anyway!» I asked to speak to the owner, and she said she was the owner. As if it wasn’t bad enough already, this extremely inconsiderate, poor business-​minded person owned the place? I was in complete awe! Who denies a pregnant woman food? I’ve never seen anything like it!!! Needless to say we will never go back, and I suggest you don’t either!

Okay. So, I grew up in Brooklyn. Moved out here to Long Island and really miss NY/​Brooklyn pizza.
This place has it.
More expensive than I’m used to but it’s really good pizza.
It’s got to be something with the water and the crust out here. Not doughy, give ‘em a try and see for yourself.

I had a coupon with a great deal so I thought I’d try this place out. We got one pie, a dozen wings, and 6 garlic knots. They were all delicious. Their wings are breaded, which I normally don’t like, but they were good, not the best, but the best in town that I’ve tried so far. I also loved that I didn’t remember to ask for blue cheese but it was included. The knots were done perfectly not too doughy or over cooked. Pizza was cooked perfectly and was as delicious as you expect.
We look forward to going back to try the gramma pie and hero’s.

I found a new 5 star.
Located in a location that seems to fail no matter what might open there… You know in your heart you cheer and hope it survives and breaks the trend that many small business fall in.
Well with pizza like this its to great to fail. Meatball&Onion Sicilian pie was 24 bucks. How can you go wrong with that. Unbelievable top to bottom in taste. Cheese not oily, toppings pretty fresh and nice… crispy as hell crust and the sauce… omfg.
I got a potato croquet that was menza Menzzz but whatever its about pizza.
The place itself is very cute, quite, small and when its warm out the hole front opens up which is pretty sweet.

Went there for the first time recently and they really have great food. The pizza is outstanding. Have been back a few times and had the chicken and shrimp parm, both excellent. He bakes fresh rolls and gives them with all orders and they are delicious. I would highly recommend this place to either sit down or take out. There are alot of pizza/​italian places in town and this one is better than alot of them.