Anthony’s Pizza is by far the best pizza in town. The dinner specials are delicious. Anthony and his staff are great. Very involved in the community. Whenever I go there I feel like I’m back in my moms kitchen, alway welcoming and inviting. I have had Anthony’s Pizza cater a few of my parties as well as lunch at my office. They are always accommodating in any special orders and always delivers consistently impressive Italian food. Whether it’s a quick slice or a family party, you gotta go to Anthony’s!
Rory B.
Classificação do local: 4 West Islip, NY
Very good pizza. The only problem I have is parking, if you don’t back in is hard to get out.
Joe J.
Classificação do local: 5 West Islip, NY
Been going here for years. Solid pizza and the entrees are really good as well. I really enjoy their chicken parm hero.
Matt D.
Classificação do local: 5 West Islip, NY
Anthony’s is a really great, local place to get a good slice. The owner is a great guy! His chicken roll is really flavorful
Rj S.
Classificação do local: 1 Bay Shore, NY
One of the worst pizzeria ive ever encountered. Ive eaten here a long time because of convenience. Its terrible
Chez T.
Classificação do local: 5 Brooklyn, NY
I have to say Anthony pizza is the best in west Islip ! I think all of Anthony’s food is good !
Nick C.
Classificação do local: 4 West Islip, NY
Upon further review and my first time returning to this location in about a half a decade. This place is awesome. seasme seed crust? I love You! Crispy, perfect and Beautiful. The sauce is great and total explosion of flavor. Im happy I have returned and the owner said to me…“weren’t you here yesterday?” YES I WAS… YES I WAS. The Sicilian can be passed up on but anything round here is a must. Best chicken parm slice and a tasty pinwheel. Not a clean place but they are in the midst of an overhaul.
Adam O.
Classificação do local: 2 West Islip, NY
My family has been getting pizza here for the last 20 years or so. We get it because we live nearby, and my parents seem to like it all right, but it’s my least favorite pizza place. The pizza is usually undercooked but somehow burnt on the bottom, and the cheese seems to all come off with the first bite no matter what. The garlic knots are usually a little too greasy and make my stomach hurt. Still, they say even bad pizza is still pretty good, so try it for yourself. Some people seem to like it.
Patty S.
Classificação do local: 4 Bethpage, NY
Great Pizza. they even do sesame seed crust which I love! Only problem is sometimes the girls at the counter answer the phones with attitude but hey the pizzas still great.
Jen F.
Classificação do local: 3 Indianapolis, IN
Anthony makes a pretty good pie. Their chicken wings are super good.