Oak St Pie Co

I have a shameless pie addict at home. We’ve tried every pie made at this little shop. NO misses! My kid even had a birthday pie at her party instead of cake. Her friends said, «Wha???» But then gobbled up a whole chocolate pie with whipped cream. No leftovers! Great divinity as well.

Great looking key lime pie. The only thing better was the wonderful taste. I will go back the next time I need a pie.

Best fudge in town… And the pies aren’t half bad either! The staff is so friendly and extremely patient when we are in there trying to make our decisions on what to buy next. Please make an effort to visit this small town business and enjoy the richness of every bite! My personal fave… the peanut butter fudge!

Step back in time with a generous slice of pie. The blueberry pie is second only to Mom’s. Loved the experience with the music and friendly service.

There is a reason this place was ranked as one of the best places for pie by D Magazine! Best pie crust anywhere. I routinely order pies in advance when we have family and friends visiting. You do need to order in advance. Really great pie!

I stopped in this afternoon with my mom and daughter for pie, and it was amazing as always! We had coconut merengue, blackberry cobbler, and raspberry rhubarb. The pie was fresh & delicious!

Cute little pie shop in Roanoke! My husband loves blackberry cobbler and I’ve had a difficult time finding a bakery that sells it and when I found this place I had to take him here. He’s very picky and claims his mom makes the best cobbler but after having the cobbler here he claimed that his mom has some competition!
Best place for pie!

Been here several times with a few family members. Everyone always gets something different and it’s always amazing. Love that they have coffee and serve you at the tables.

We had the lemon meringue pie last night (my wife’s favorite kind of pie). I have had great pies before but this one was tops. Normally the crust is just a crust but theirs is incredible. You can taste the crust and it’s even firm at the bottom. I can’t wait to try other varieties.

This past weekend my husband and I went for the first time. We recently relocated to DFW and have heard rave reviews about this little shop. Quaint spot with superb sweets! I had the Raspberry Lemon pie which was the best I’ve ever had! Not too tart or overly sweet. My husband had the Maple Walnut fudge. It was so fresh and creamy; nothing like we’ve had before! Will be going back often!

Love this place! I checked in and got a free cookie. Had a hard time choosing just one thing, so I got a little of everything to share with my hubbs. Mint chocolate fudge, amaretto fudge, key lime pie, raspberry lemon pie. OMG!

Today would have been my first visit. Drove from Denton. Stood outside waiting for them to open at 11 as those were the hours posted on the website and the door. When the doors did not open at 11 and eye contact had been made with someone inside with no acknowledgement I knocked on the window. Finally someone came to the door and said sorry we are closed to work on our Christmas orders and promptly shut the door. There was no sign on the door stating they would be closed. Nothing on the website indicating they would be closed. I even called yesterday to ask about the buttermilk pie, which had just sold out, and no mention of being closed the next day. I had never heard of this pie shop prior to receiving an email from Unilocal just this week promoting oak st. I made a special trip and was completely dismissed by the employee at the shop. I was looking forward to giving them a try with my favorite pie for christmas. After this experience it is highly doubtful I will return or recommend.

Amazing pie and assorted sweets here! Always get some Pecan for the Holidays!

Best Pie shop in Texas. The coconut pie actually taste like coconut. The chocolate is actually rich chocolate flavor, the apple pie is better than grandma’s apple pie, German Chocolate pie taste like the cake in pie form. She also has peanut butter fudge that melts in your mouth, and cowboy cookies that have everything you want in a cookie. Highly recommend this pie shop to anyone passing down Hwy. 377 through Roanoke.

Just called to place a Thanksgiving order. The girl who answered was very unpleasant on the phone. Also their website has a list of pies available year round, I asked for a banana cream pie and she said they are not making them for Thanksgiving. WHO DOESN’T MAKE BANANA CREAM ON THANKKSGIVING. Plus it wasn’t the fact they didn’t have banana cream it was her abruptness and rudeness over the phone. These may be the best pies in Texas (wouldn’t know) but their lack of friendly service will never get my business.

I can’t really give a review because every time I come here, they’re sold out of everything! Must be good so I’ll give it 3 stars pending an actual tasting, make more product people!!!

Neat little pie shop next to babes. Has a selection of about 6 pies at a time but once your flavor is gone they are out. They also have cookies and maybe 6 types of fudge. Small seating area but friendly staff. Pies were good and the fudge is good. Cookies we had were a bit dry and they had peanut butter and then two other types like an oatmeal kind and something I’m not sure what it was. No chocolate chip so a bit saddened by that.
I recommend giving it a try it’s a nice change of pace and the key lime was pretty tasty as was the pumpkin. But no whip cream for the pumpkin :(

Very nice local shop. Awesome pies fudged and cookies. Loved the coconut pie. It is in the town of Roanoke where you find a beautiful town. The pies where hot when I bought them. Small but nice relaxing area for you to sit down and enjoy. Seems like lots of people buy full pie take outs here.

This place has the BEST homemade chocolate pies and their fudge is divine! The people that own the place and work here are super nice too. …small town feel. Authentic.

Ordered 3 pies from them they looked amazing. I got a Key Lime Pie, Strawberry Rhubarb pie and
A German chocolate pie. All the pies looked and tasted terrific. My favorite is the Strawberry rhubarb it was outstanding !!!

Phenomenal fudge and I am not a huge fudge fan unless it comes from here! The pies are to die for highly recommend them!

Best pies in Texas! Coconut meringue is my favorite! She’s really nice and friendly at the counter.
The key lime is also delicious. As is the banana cream pie (although my favorite banana cream pie comes from Leoda’s on Maui)
Yum!

Bought my son a cherry pie for his birthday. I’m usually not a fan of cherry but this was fantastic. I can’t wait to go back and try the other varieties. We also bought a few pieces of fudge and they were yummy too!

Bought a Key Lime pie to bring to a party. It was excellent. Tried to order a Raspberry Rhubarb pie around close to last Christmas Eve but got turned down because they were too busy. I’ll have to try again sometime.

We routinely visit and take home fudge and other delights. The plain fudge is so tasty and smooth. We’re also fond of the key lime pies. Plus, each time we’ve been here, we’ve seen the owner hard at work, baking. She’s really nice. It smells wonderful inside, and we love taking home a pie after we’ve filled our bellies at a nearby restaurant.

Small bakery with a cute patio offering up traditional pies and cookies either whole or by the slice. Enjoyable place for a sweet bite.

Great little pie and candy shop in a perfect location on Oak Street. I say perfect because the immensely popular neighboring Babe’s Chicken Dinner House does not serve dessert. So you can walk a few paces to Oak St. Pie and grab a slice. The shop is small, but does have some seating available to enjoy your treats there. There’s a good-​sized fudge counter with 8 – 10 different varieties to choose from. We went with the coconut almond fudge and it was delicious. I believe all fudges are priced around $ 13 per pound. There’s also a very small candy selection, mostly throwback stuff. You can walk a bit farther down Oak and visit Hey Sugar for a really awesome selection of individual and bulk candies. But that’s not why you come to Oak St Pie– right?
When I visited, there were not many pies to choose from as options for single slices. I saw peanut butter, pecan, key lime, chocolate crème, and a couple others. The apple, coconut crème and banana crème were all gone. I wish there would have been a better selection but to be fair we were stopping by about an hour after they opened. It’s likely they were baking fresh pies in the back for the day. We went with a slice of pecan and a slice of peanut butter for take home. The girl who helped us was super friendly and offered samples of the fudge.
The pies were delicious. The pecan was excellent, the flaky crust was to die for. It was just the right amount of sweet with loads of crunchy whole pecans on top. I would highly recommend the pecan pie. The peanut butter wasn’t my thing, but the wife loved it. It wasn’t overly peanut buttery, which was nice. It had sort of an oreo cookie crust, which I felt like would have worked better with a regular graham cracker crust. And I would have liked melted peanut butter drizzled over the top!
We’ll be back!

Oak St Pie & Candy Co is a charming pie shop in downtown Roanoke that specializes in fresh baked pies, cookies, fudge, and other tasty sweets. It is a must visit destination if you are ever in the Roanoke area.
My Overall Rating — 3 ½ Stars (Atmosphere, Service, Food, Return)
Atmosphere — Oak St Pie & Candy Co. is located in a small and very charming space along downtown Roanoke. It looks like a small house, with plenty of shaded outdoor seating. Inside you’ll find more seating, and a dessert case stocked with assorted fudge, brittle, candy, etc. The best part? The smell of the fresh baked pies is so amazing you can almost taste the flavors. 1 Star.
Service — The folks at Oak St Pie were a little short staffed on our visit, but they made the most of it. It wasn’t that they were too busy or not nice, the short staff resorted in a very limited number of pies and treats available. Unilocal Check-​In is supposed to give you a free cookie, but they had none. No worries, the important part is they were nice (although they seemed a little over worked). ½ Star.
Food — We were only limited to two pies and cobblers. We ordered a slice of both pies (lemon & key lime) along with a black berry cobbler. The cobbler was the star here. It was freshly baked, we received a generous portion, and the blackberry filling was delicious. The fruit was large, plump, and the cobbler portion was buttery & flakey. When the two were combined in the same bite, I danced a little. The portion was also so generous I split it into two servings. We gave the lemon pie to a friend, and the key lime pie was great too. The Key Lime pie wasn’t as tart as some other key lime pies that I’ve had, and the generous whipped cream topping also created a more mild bite. The crust was as delicious as the flakey cobbler too. I enjoyed it, but if you like a key lime pie with more lime, you may not like it as much. My only knock on Oak St Pie & Candy Co is that they were so limited. I honestly wanted more selection. Emporium Pies sets the standard, and while Oak St. has the potential based on what I had, they didn’t have the selection. 1 Star.
Will I Return? — No question. If I’m anywhere within a 5 mile radius of Roanoke I’m hitting up Oak St Pie & Candy Co. I’m hoping their supply meets the demand. It’s obvious they have incredible products, so when you leave me wanting more it’s a great thing. 1 Star.
My Unilocal Rating Scale (Sum of all parts):
1 Star — Atmosphere — Is it a cool dive? Perhaps an upscale place? No matter the type, atmosphere plays a big part and I’ll give a star if I like it or thinks it has great charm.
1 Star — Service — You can have a great meal with bad service. But that’s also what can make a five star joint drop to four. It’s important to the dining experience that service is great and on point.
2 Stars — Food — I’ll award up to two stars for the food, since this is the main reason we dine out. Sometimes the extra star is given for value, but it’s really all about the food.
1 Star — Will I come back? — If I know for a fact I’ll return, I’ll give this a star. A place has to make an impression for me to return.
Each Category can be given up to 1 star except food (2 stars) because I consider all these categories important to the overall dining experience. I will sum them up to provide my final Unilocal score.

MMM key lime pie. Their key lime pie is delicious. My slice melted on the way home so I threw it into freezer and it still tasted great. The pricing is reasonable especially if you suck at making them.
This is a must go if you’re in the area — and especially if you just finished eating at Babe’s.
The reason why I’m not giving this a 5 star rating is because I haven’t tried everything and the other item I did try was just ok (pass on the cowboy cookie).

Unfortunately they only had a couple of kinds of pie when I came in (banana cream and I think pecan) but they also had berry cobbler, which I had. Holy smokes. This thing was warm and delicious and had that homemade taste that sometimes I’m too lazy or impatient to wait around for in my own kitchen. I’m not a huge fudge person, but they had lots of flavors of that as well. Tiny, friendly little place. (If they just had coffee, it’d be perfect…)

To date I have had Carol’s fudge (peanut butter, snicker, chocolate), oatmeal raisin and chocolate chip cookies, lemon bars, blackberry cobbler, peach cobbler, apple pie, buttermilk pie, a strawberry rhubarb and a key lime pie! I have def put on a couple lbs, but it’s well worth it for these quality goodies all made from scratch! My favorites are her lemon bars and buttermilk pie.