Off The Wall Frozen Yogurt

I’ve been here a couple of times and have never been disappointed by the flavors; however, I wouldn’t say that it stands out from other yogurt places.

Hands down the best frozen yogurt I’ve had in the city. Huge selection of both frozen yogurt and toppings. The froyo itself isn’t watered down or icy like most froyo. It’s hardy and will definitely satisfy your sweet tooth.

Pretty good selection of flavors and toppings! The watermelon sorbet was particularly delicious, and there were lots of fresh fruit options available. The euro tart wasn’t what I was in the mood for, but if you’re looking for actual yogurt taste and texture (as opposed to overly tart or sweet options) it’s probably the best plain yogurt flavor I’ve had anywhere.
The staff is very nice and the place is cute and clean inside. Definitely would come back if I were in the area.

Cookies and Crème the best! I tried pumpkin pie but I did not like it because it was too sweet. I mixed with a bunch of flavors and added granola. I loveeee granola!
Very nice interior deign and spacious seating. You can tell the owners really put a lot of effort into this.

Came here on a quiet rainy afternoon with my mom who’s a huge fan of froyo. The selection was great. The flavor we wanted ran out, but the girl working the cash register was more than happy to refill the machine for us. The toppings were fresh and delicious! The tables, bathroom, and floors were very clean as well. Would definitely come here again.

Lots of choices !

After the nearby 16 Handles and Flavaboom closed, I scrambled to find my new froyo go-​to. Off the Wall is it by default now, but I’m upset that it’s not quite as healthy as the other two were.
I’m ecstatic there’s still froyo around so I don’t cave for ice cream, but there are a few downfalls compared to the other chains:
— No hot fudge
— The peanut butter isn’t real peanut butter. It’s «Reeses special sauce,» i.e. chemicals
— The granola seems more like a sugary cereal than real granola
The good thing is that you serve yourself. Telling your Pinkberry server «yes, MORE mochi» sure gets annoying quick, so this is a relief.

Was in the mood for ice cream while on the highline and this was the closest thing we could find. Loved my yogurt! I got a cup of the crème brûlée, the orange, and the strawbana. Yeah, that’s right. I mixed them all. With some kiwi, mochi, cookie dough, and reese’s mini-​cups, too. And it was deeeelish!
I dropped in my business card for a chance to win free froyo and I hope I win! I just wish we were able to get our own samples, but that’s my own tiny complaint.

I wouldn’t go out of my way for this froyo but if I was in the area I would most likely drop in. This place is enormous! There seems to be quite few seating for an establishment so large but this would only matter if a huge crowd piled in.
The flavors were a little different than most froyo places but not by much. I went with the mango and the green apple. I will say that they have a clean counter will a clean toppings area. Some froyos counter tops are a little questionable with everyone digging for the best pieces of mango but this place had everything neatly placed.
The thing that stood out to me was the funfetti cake topping and the cookies and cream crunch bits. The huge cereal dispensers were a nice touch and definitely helpful.
If Sixteen candles or pink berry are too far out of your walking range when you’re in this area, I would stop in here for decent, do it yourself, cup of for frozen yogurt.
Oh forgot to mention, they have a bathroom too

the best thing about this place is their sorbets. They have more than one unlike some other places, and the 30% off for happy hours makes it even more likable. Sitting in a booth, eating a frozen yummy treat, at a cheap price, while people watching makes me happy. Did I mention their sorbets are awesome?

Yes, there are way too many fro-​yo places in the city now. It’s starting to become redundant and still when I am drunk, I can’t help myself. But there aren’t many fro-​yo places that have cereal dispensers hanging from their walls. Additionally, they had as a topping chunks of birthday cake to just throw in there. This may have been one of the more exciting moments of my life lately. I can’t even remember the flavor of fro yo that I choose. This was weeks ago. I imagine peanut butter because its tasty and that sounds familiar. BUT FREAKING RAINBOW SPRINKLED BIRTHDAY CAKE! They have millions of flavors that will make you indecisive as hell. They also have crushed fruity pebbles, captain crunch, cocoa pebbles ‘off the wall’. They have their own schtick and they do it pretty well.

This place is HUGE! It should be a bar, not a froyo place, for real, this is too of a big space for froyo (but who cares lol).
Off the wall has very high quality frozen yogurt. I have a love for a competitor chain (it’s a very serious relationship) but this place definitely has much much better froyo. The flavors are great, delicate and on spot, you can mix 2 adjacent flavors at the same time in the twirl, unlike a lot of places where you have to do one by one. That’s awesome. The only downside of this place are the toppings. Apart from the fruits, they mostly suck. There aren’t many and given the size of the place, they should have a longer topping bar… that’s all I am saying… haha.

too many flavors. is that a problem? not for many, but for me… TOO many choices for frozen yogurt as a base is problematic for me. especially when only 3 – 4 of them tastes good. i like the concept, but this has all been done before.
besides that, the topping choices are endless. i actually liked that. from different cereals to cookies, syrups and fruits. but NO MOCHI. listen, i know this isn’t Red Mango or Pinkberry… but waaaaaaaaaaaaaah! i want it all.
the space is weird. like it’s too big of a place to have for a frozen yogurt spot that ONLY does frozen yogurts. they should add more food to the menu or shakes or smoothies or something. the seating is cool but still weirdly placed. i wish i knew the owner/​creator of this place and give them some advice. =P

Open for 4 hours Wednesdays, closed Thursdays and Fridays? How awkward. Haven’t confirmed Th/​F but their site lists no hours and I got snapped at when verifying she said 3pm on a Wednesday…
They had just opened and a friendly guy welcomed me and was eager to provide samples. Tried the salted caramel popcorn (had another flavor aspect that seemed to not be part of the name), and the egg nog (which didn’t wow). I’d come for the angel food cake, which was a flavor of the month and had since been discontinued. Because I wasn’t wow’d by those or the remaining pedestrian flavors, I left without redeeming the 30% Google Offer despite its approaching expiration. (DQ opens down the block soon)
Came back to redeem my birthday freebie here — their open-​ended email and generous staff makes for a nice indulgence.

My friend and I randomly stopped by while walking somewhere on the fourth of July. Maybe it was relatively new then, but it was pretty empty for a big store. The froyo wasn’t so bad (if i’m remembering it properly which is the major reason that it’s only getting 3 stars.) There’s nothing that stood out for me that sets it apart from the other places.

Off The Wall has A LOT of flavors – so many so that I wanted to taste a few before I made any rash decisions. I inquired about tasting cups and an employee walked around and came out from behind the counter. He explained that if I wanted to taste anything, he had to CHAPERONE ME?! What? I got so annoyed and self conscious that I simply forewent any initial tastings and resigned to stuffing my face with unnecessary amounts of myriad flavors. My life is hard, yo.
The yogurt was good – some of the best I’ve had recently. I particularly enjoyed the macadamia nut flavor and as always cake batter.
The venue is fresh and clean. The employees are not super friendly and are clearly uncomfortably suspicious.
Anyway, nothing gets between me and my froyo. Fin.

I attended a blogger/​networking event here last evening and was pretty impressed with what Off The Wall has to offer — 16 great flavors and 40 toppings! Nicely designed spot with a fun décor. Was able to sample many of the flavors with Macadamia Cookie, Peanut Butter, and Blueberry non-​fat low-​sugar frozen yogurts among my favs. As I am eating well and training hard right now the blueberry I mentioned along with a bunch of the fruit toppings were a perfect cold snack to help beat this dreadful summer heat and humidity.
Sure, in a crowded market that is saturated with froyo joints such as Pinkberry, Red Mango, and 16 Handles among others, they are all over the city but I feel that Off The Wall holds it’s own. Nice variety of rotating flavors and sorbets, decent selection of toppings and sauces, and there is even a wall of self serve dry cereal and candy toppings to add to your cup of frozen goodness. They also offer cold drinks and cakes too.
This place just opened in April and it’s clean, bright, and the prices are pretty reasonable. Definitely a good alternative to the other players in the NYC froyo game.

We are getting really close to hitting the saturation point with these self-​serve frozen yogurt places, but I’m glad to be seeing more and more Off The Walls adding to that mix.
I was on my way to the 16 Handles about a block away when I noticed this place just opened up recently. I’ve been to their other two NYC locations so I figured I’d give this one a shot.
Like the others, this one has the best Peanut Butter flavor out of all other chains and small places I’ve ever tried. It’s worth coming here just to get that flavor alone.
Like the others though, this one needs to step it up with the toppings. They don’t have nearly as many as their big competitor, 16 Handles.
Angel Food is also a really excellent flavor and better than the flavors at most other places too.
I might need to stick to the very close by 16 Handles for the majority of the time since they have a better variety of flavors and toppings, but I will definitely stop in here from time to time to get some of those few excellent flavors they have.

They had 16 different flavors including low-​fat, non-​fat, and sugar-​free varieties, and they are all certified kosher. I started off tasting my traditional favorites — the chocolate, peanut butter, cookies ‘n’ cream, etc., but the more I tasted the more I liked, and I figured I might as well try them all! I did that just for you so that I could give you the low down on every single flavor :).
To read the rest of my review, check out my blog — City Lights and Tasty Bites

Decided to stop by tonight for dessert during my walk home and I’m glad that I did!
Off the Wall is similar to 16 handles and has a ton of flavors. There weren’t a ton of other customers in the store, which was surprising given how many people are in 16 handles all the time.
I really enjoyed the peanut butter froyo (for peanut butter fans, there’s also peanut butter to top your froyo with) and the cookies and cream. I think that they have more sorbet options than its competitors, but I didn’t find one that I loved.
Overall, I think that I still like 16 handles better, but this isn’t a bad alternative!