Nick’s is amazing. You cannot go wrong here, their pizza is amazing, their pasta is amazing, everything is amazing. The house salad is delicious, and surprised me. I really loved it. It had peppers, sun dried tomatoes, and delicious dressing. My boyfriend and I split a large pepperoni pizza this time around and devoured it. The crust is perfect. If you are in the neighborhood you need to check it out, Nick’s will not disappoint!
Ted C.
Classificação do local: 4 New York, NY
Great neighborhood pizza/Italian joint. Checks the pretense at the door and focuses on serving good, classically large American Italian portions, and amazing fresh mozzarella pizza.
Robert L.
Classificação do local: 5 Manhattan, NY
Best pizza in the neighborhood. Always very friendly staff.
Smita P.
Classificação do local: 5 New York, NY
Consistently great pizza, and fast delivery. Haven’t eaten at the restaurant, but it seems looks spacious and generally busy. The Margherita pizza is delicious!
Drew W.
Classificação do local: 5 Manhattan, NY
This is my favorite pizza and Italian food on the upper east side! The entrees ain’t too shabby either. The interior is nice enough for a family dinner. I usually do takeout, but my couple times sitting down were enjoyable. They have a small selection of beer and wine. But most of all the food, especially for the price point, is really fantastic. Little known secret: their subs(meatball, chicken parm) are amazing — the best I’ve ever had. They get the bread from Arthur Ave, and offer the subs until they run out of the bread for the day — usually by 3:00.
Divya K.
Classificação do local: 4 Manhattan, NY
Ordered a pizza for delivery which arrived quickly and was still hot. Their pizzas are brick oven thin crust for when you don’t feel like like real pizza vs dominos. It is pricey but very good! We had the large pie with sausage, mushrooms, onions and garlic. Very good!
Curt W.
Classificação do local: 3 Cranberry Township, PA
Nicks pizza is outstanding ! Flavor, doneness and everything. I will give the pizza five stars. A couple of things that keep me from rating it higher is no atmosphere, a not very friendly manager and wine poured in a small thick glass.
Dominique C.
Classificação do local: 4 Menifee, CA
This is a great corner spot– family friendly and the food is good. Service is ok… But a definite good little«go to» spot!
Allie S.
Classificação do local: 5 San Diego, CA
Yum! We finally got some pizza on our last night in NYC! We ended up in NYC an extra night on accident(missed the flight) and stayed pretty close to here… We’re glad we did! The service was awesome! Very friendly and quick! Tasty bread! Good beer options! We ordered pizza and picked our toppings… I was really hoping for fresh basil, but didn’t see it as a topping option, so we didn’t order it, but somehow they read my mind and brought it out on our pizza anyway! They’re magic and the pizza was wonderful! We highly recommend Nicks!
Mark B.
Classificação do local: 5 New York, NY
Went in craving meatballs. This place delivered! Fantastic balls of love! Also if you work FDNY you get 25% discount! Bonus!
Caryn D.
Classificação do local: 1 Buffalo, NY
I ordered a small pizza w 3 toppings which came to 25.00 — even by NYC standards I would say that’s a bit much. I’m willing to pay the price for good pizza though so that didn’t stop me. Unfortunately when I received the pizza it was anything but good. Half the toppings were in the box, not on the pizza and the other half fell off as soon as I picked up a slice. I had two slices and threw out the rest. My sister and roommate wouldn’t even have a slice — very, very disappointed. Too many pizza places in NYC to ever go here again.
Cheryl N.
Classificação do local: 4 Manhattan, NY
Ever get a pizza craving, but decide not to indulge because you fear disappointment that the pizza won’t live up to your expectations? I decided to take a chance and order from Nick’s. Delivery was quick for a Friday night. The pizza came nice and hot! As with all thin crust pizza, definitely eat it while it’s hot, not so good at room temp. I just got a basic large pie and added on garlic and Parmesan. I was not disappointed. Thanks Nick’s. $ 26 with tip so kinda pricey when you add toppings, but definitely worth a try.
R L.
Classificação do local: 4 HOWARD BEACH, NY
Good sit down pizzeria/restaurant on the upper east side. I was their with a group of friends. The service was great. Attentive and polite servers. The food was good. You have single servings or family size. I got the Manicotti in single serving. It was good but I personally like larger servings. The family size was probably too large for one person. We ordered a family size of the fried calamari and it was pretty good. Sauce was good too. Everyone’s food looked good. Calzone, House Salad, and Chicken Parm Dinner. I also noticed they had old school oven to make their pizzas. Nice. I’ll definitely be back to try their slices.
Dev T.
Classificação do local: 4 Brooklyn, NY
Wrote the wrong review. Thought it was Nick’s Pizza Bar
Nicky L.
Classificação do local: 5 Long Beach, CA
Delicious pizza! Great dough, love the mozzarella. Doesn’t seem too unhealthy. Delivery is usually very quick.
Sean B.
Classificação do local: 5 Long Island City, NY
It’s the best pie in the neighborhood. I challenge you to find a better one. Calamari is fresh… and the pile it deep and high. If you are in the neighborhood and you haven’t been here yet — get here.
Amanda W.
Classificação do local: 5 Upper East Side, Manhattan, NY
The mozzarella on top of the pizza deserves its own review/rating. Its definitely fresh and it makes the pizza(IMO). I like how they put fresh basil on top, unique touch. You can tell that they use fresh ingredients. You can taste it in the whole pizza, including toppings(pepperoni, etc). One of my favorite go-to pizza spots in the UES.
Nina L.
Classificação do local: 4 New York, NY
4 stars: – Fresh mozzarella on all their pies! Wow! – Crispy, thin crust. – The most efficient phone ordering I’ve ever experienced in my 8 or so years of calling in for delivery. The staff was clear, quick, and helpful. – Delivery was fast and the food came piping hot and fresh. There definitely was not a decrease in quality from their ordering at the restaurant. 3 stars: – Their sauce is thick/heavy and in my opinion, not sweet enough. This sort of throws off the balance of their margarita pie and made me favor their white slices. – Broccoli rabe was fresh but a bit on the bitter side. Overall, unique to the Upper East Side with their family-style offerings and dedication to higher end ingredients. Nice change of pace from your average hole in the wall pizzeria in the area.
Agustin K.
Classificação do local: 4 New York, NY
Great Italian family restaurant. It reminds me a bit of Patsy’s but with different menus. The dining area has a few big round tables conducive for large parties. I think they take reservation as well. We had the pizza which had a nice crust that held up to the two toppings we got. It was a good pizza but not the best I’ve had. Warm spinach salad — pretty much sautéed spinach with balsamic and ricotta cheese. It sounds kind of strange but surprisingly very good! Pene ala vodka — good creamy sauce, wish they put more sauce. Service is prompt and efficient. It’s not the cheapest option around but overall, a solid Italian meal!
Alexander Y.
Classificação do local: 4 Rowland Heights, CA
I mean… if you’re going to come to New York, you gotta get New York pizza right? Felt blasphemous if I didn’t, especially considering I was coming to New York for my birthday! The first thing I noticed about my pie is that it was extremely high quality in terms of ingredients and NOT greasy at all. I know it’s kinda hard to pull off that combination given the type of food we’re dealing with here, but Nick’s pulled it off. Also love that we could make custom pizzas, which made it easy for me(white pie, half onion/garlic/sausage/meatball, half anchovies/garlic). Other stuff I managed to pound down is a chicken caesar salad and penne vodka. Side note: family size is MASSIVE… we’re talking 3 meals level huge. Definitely impressed, will return if I ever get a chance.