Extreme Pizza

Pizza sauce nothing special, cheese wasn’t good quality, their powwow was gross not fully baked and poorly made as if to not have a care in the world. I was better off going to little Cesar’s, They charged me for ranch that I never received (ranch that I made sure to ask for twice by phone) the guy came late, I gave him 30 and he tried to keep my $ 5 change. He kept saying «oh I’m just a delivery guy I don’t carry change and you have to ask for ranch by phone» the order was $ 25something, I took my 5 back gave him 26. I WOULDN’T EAT HERE AGAIN EVEN IF IT WERE A FREE COURTESY!!!

Paid $ 20 dollars for a «large» 14 inch pizza that was paper thin and was actually 12 inches lol. I’ll never go back there again. There’s other New York style pizza places near bye on Fremont Blvd that for that price you can get a huge pizza. Asked for cheese and peppers and we got home to find there were none. Girl got a tip she didn’t deserve. Spent more time blasting music and dancing then making a good product. Pleas if the owner reads this can you justify this to me? I am disappointed and laughing. This place must have a ton of fake reviews because there is no way it’s 4 out of 5 stars.

I went in today for the tuesday special which is buy a large, xlarge or huge pizza and get one free. I ordered two pizzas but ordered the wrong size for one. The employee, Deven, was very nice and said that the next time I came back they would give me the correct size without charge. Deven went to go get the pizzas and when he came back he told me that they put onions on one of the pizzas (I had asked them for no onions) and said that they could remake it for me and make the other pizza the size I wanted as well. When the pizzas were done he gave me both of my pizzas and the extra pizza with onions on the house. I will definitely be coming back here since Deven was so accommodating and gave great customer service!

We ordered the vegan garden pizza, was looking toward eating a little healthier pizza but was highly disappointed. We ordered delivery and the pizza arrived over an hour later (we live literally 1 minute away). I thought that was a bit long considering how close we are but anyways took a bite out of the pizza and it was undercooked. The crust was still mushy inside under all the toppings and ended up not eating it at all. not going to be ordering from here anymore. $ 30 dollars for an undercooked pizza that took over an hour?

First time at extreme pizza, their signature pizzas are really good and they have a bunch of different choices. We tried yard sale, Pandora and Mont Blanc (was my fav). Lily was are a cashier and she took care of us the whole entire time making sure our table was clean and everything tasted good. Lily will take good care of you and don’t forget the cheese twisted sticks they were to good. Tip well spent!

Worst customer service ever. Had to wait for half hour. Then went to ask if my pizza is ready just to know that it was not yet started. In all had to wait for 50 mins. Chef was not there. Won’t ever visit again

Went to a party here tonight and I must say the place is very clean. The workers were awesome. Excellent service and very tentative. The food came out very hot, fresh and Omg the combinations were amazing. Our favorites were the Ragin Rooster and The Yard sale. Highly recommended. Thank you for a great evening extreme pizza!

While the pizza is good, the service is lacking. Called in a pickup order and they said 20 mins. 25 mins later, I walk in and am told 20 more minutes. I’m now at 60 minutes … Just told 2 more minutes.
Pros: awesome pizza. Clean restrooms and nice big LCD TVs for sports. Good beer on tap but only 4.
Cons: management. Training 2 new people on a Saturday night is going to kill this business. Maybe if other staff were on… But learn to deal with labor costs.

Boyfriend ordered from here for delivery Sunday night at 5pm. Got a large pizza and an order of wings. Got a call a while later and was told they no longer have regular wings and only boneless. Bf is really easy going so he said that would be fine. Pizza came at the expected 1 hour later and although everything looked good, I was not impressed. The boneless wings were cold, it felt like it was made about 1 hour prior and sat on the counter. The pizza was also a bit cold and the cheese had begun to harder. That basically ruined the experience. I felt since they ran out of something we ordered, they should have made more of an effort to make sure the rest of the food is HOT and good. Skip if you like your pizza hot.

This place is okay but a little on the pricey side, I guess you need coupons for an okay deal. The pizza crust is really thin, not even like New York style, just thin like you are trying to save on carbs.
The pizza was okay when it came out hot but nothing too special about it, toppings, sauce and cheese were just average and nothing memorial. Me, a 3 year old and a 6-​year old (that generally don’t even eat much) polished off a 16″ pizza no problem. I like my crust to have a little more substance and feel like you have to work on each bite. Also a pet peeve, I hate pizza joints that charge the regular topping price even if you only put it on half the pizza.
Honestly I would go back to Bronco Billy’s, Mission Pizza, Round Table or even Mountain Mikes around the corner before coming back here. If you are going to eat pre-​formed dough pizzas made on a rolling oven might as well go to discount joints (ie Dominos though toppings here are better)… They do have a few TVs but its not that big of a dinning area, the 2 people working were friendly but seemed to have trouble keeping up with orders and had no time to bus the tables when guests were done. Also over heard that they recently changed owners as a customer was getting the beat-​down for trying to use some coupons the prior owner had put out.

First time going there and we had a party of 8. They were low staffed on a Sunday afternoon. Service was excellent, the pizzas came out fast. We ordered a huge pepperoni, large yard sale and a large Mont Blanc. I highly recommend the Mont Blanc it was my favorite of the three. They were all delicious. The crust was thin and the toppings were actually there, I liked how in every bite I could taste the toppings. I was full off of the toppings and not just a bunch of dough. Before I tried this place out, my go to pizza joints were Mountain Mikes and Round Table. I can truthfully say, this will be on the top of my preferred list.

I’ve ordered delivery before. They have really interesting concoctions. I tried the buffet yesterday for lunch. I don’t know what I was thinking. It was way too much food for me! They had four pizzas, calzones. bread bites, and a dessert. They checked on all of it frequently to make sure it wasn’t dying under the lamps and pizzas were refreshed in the 45 minutes that i was there. Yard Sale is my favorite. I like their sauce. For me, the crust is just okay. I also had a slice with Canadian Bacon and mandarin oranges. That’s a much better play than pineapple in my opinion. They have several specials and meal deals in the $ 8 range for pizza and a drink (some include salad and there’s also a sandwich option).
Yesterday’s staff was so nice. Armando was personable and helpful.
The parlor is clean. They have mutiple TVs and they’ll put whatever you want on. They don’t have to all be on sports channels.

Came in for the $ 7.99 weekday buffet lunch. Although the pizza was good tasting with a good thin crust (nice variety of cheese, pepperoni, combination, Hawaiian, and vegetarian), there was never a constant supply. All the customers were waiting and waiting for something to come out. And I never saw any calzones which is part of the deal. Not to mention, you have to ask for the salad which they bring out to you (no self serve). They’re too busy making pizzas for take out and/​or delivery with not a lot of attention to the buffet line. You’re better off coming here after 1:00 PM when the lunch crowd is gone. I would have liked to have given this place 4 stars…

Really, really, really very slow. Pleasant enough help in front, but kitchen is understaffed. People complaining right and left about service. Pizza pretty good though.
UPDATE: Added a star because the owner explained that the cook unexpectedly no-​showed. He offered me a free pizza to return. I haven’t taken him up, but I will give it another try.

Last night, I ordered two pizzas and two salads for delivery. They get points for being punctual and having decent pizzas. However, the arugula salad was inedible. 80% of the arugula was yellowed and wilted. Had I eaten at the restaurant, I would have returned it, but since it was a delivery, I just dumped it. I don’t understand how a business can serve food like that. What a disappointment!
Edit — after my review, the manager contacted me and apologized, admitting they were super busy and didn’t deliver the excellent food that they normally do. He offered a free pizza and salad, which I thought was very kind. Thank you.

Worst delivery service ever. I placed a order at 6pm and it did not arrive at my residence untill 7:45pm.
I called numerous times to find out the ETA of the delivery and they kept saying it would be arriving in 15 mins. I live about 10 mins. away from this place.
The manager was not helpful at all when I complained about the situation. The customer service needs alot of work on being reliable for there actions.
They were never going to give me a refund unless I had called and made sure that the refund was going to happen. I will never order from them again.

So originally we were not happy with this place b/​c of their unfriendliness to celiac patients and their gluten allergies.
But once the new owner saw that we had issues w/​their pizza, we decided to try the pizza out again.
we tried 3 flavors this time.
They needed to be educated on cross contamination and the importance of NOT doing that w/​ce. but after trying out 3 pizzas recently, no allergies were done! Make sure you alert them of your gluten allergy and the need for NO cross contamination when making your pizza and they should be good to go, especially if Joe, the owner, is the one making or ordering your pizza.
Flavors tried:
THE SPICE ROUTE
Chicken marinated in a spicy Tandoori sauce, green pepper, red onion, cilantro and mozzarella.
—- if you like heat, you’ll like this one.
PEACE IN THE MIDDLE EAST
Homemade hummus, vine ripe tomatoes, black olives, caramelized onions, feta, fresh basil, pepperoncini and mozzarella.
—- a bit funky but if you love hummus you’ll like this.
PAIA PIE — fave flavor, by far.
Hawaiian pineapple, Canadian bacon, Mandarin oranges, tomato sauce, mozzarella and cheddar.
DRAG IT THRU THE GARDEN
Fresh mushrooms, green peppers, red onions, artichoke hearts, broccoli, vine ripe tomatoes, fresh basil, tomato sauce, mozzarella and cheddar.
— lots of fresh veggies!
For their gluten free pizzas, they Excessive topping amounts end up making the dough soggy. so if you eat the pizza fresh. it’s good. but if you’re gonna eat it as leftovers, eating the toppings is good enough.
next time we’ll try regular pizzas for us non-​allergy staff. :)
Thanks Joe, for your amazing customer service!

First time trying their pizza and I wasn’t too enthused about it, but it wasn’t bad by any means. I tried a version of the standard combination pizza, it was alright but not saucy enough. I also ordered a Hawaiian and a pepperoni, good pizza but still not enough sauce. The buffalo wings were good, but needed to be a little crispier for my liking. They deliver to my new house, so that’s a plus when I’m craving pizza but to lazy to get up, but I wouldn’t order it for any other reason.

The reviews do not lie. This pizza is really, really good. I would always go for the for sure but Extreme Pizza has definitely changed my mind about going out of my comfort zone. I ordered a pepperoni and the railroad rage for delivery and the pow pows where thrown in for free thanks to a Unilocal’s Deal. The pizza was delivered within the promised time by a very cute young lady, or so I heard. In my younger days I worked for a local pizzeria so I know fresh dough when I see it. The crust was not too thick or too thin, the toppings went all the way to the edge and it was just fantastic. The pow pows where soooo good that I couldn’t stop eating them. Overall, great over the phone customer service and the food was perfect, will most definitely order again.

Called in my order so I could pick it up on the way home. I spoke with John he was friendly over the phone and offered additional menu items like the Pow Pows. I ordered a Pepperoni and the Spice Route. Pizza was delicious. Pepperoni tasted like no other pizza I have had in a long time and my kids loved it. The Spice Route had such a wonderful flavor spicy and sweet and oh so good.
For Dessert pick up the Pow Pows they are so sweet and yummy a definite treat. I look forward to returning and eating inside the restaurant. It has TV’s everywhere so baseball season should be fun. It was clean and modern looking. Check it out.