Angelotti’s Pizza & Trattoria

Rude staff … Awful subs … Mediocre pizza. Don’t go out of your way for this place.

I live around the corner from this place and thought that since I had no dinner plans, I figured might as order to try them out. Huge mistake and I will not be making it again. I ordered a thin crust pizza half plain and half no-​cheese with pepperoni and I can honestly say it was the worst and most disappointing pizza I’ve ever had in my entire life (and I am not someone with terribly high standards).
I can’t believe I paid nearly $ 16 (with tax and toppings) for this! It tasted like the pizza was left out for hours before I picked it up. It honestly tasted like the cardboard pizza you would get in school since the cheese and the sauce were horrendous. The staff members were nice, but I will definitely not order from here again.

Moved to town in September. Have gone here a handful of times and great experience. Attempted to place our first delivery order since we saw a special on their website. After placing the order, the man says we need to print the page from their own website and give to the driver. We tell him we don’t have a printer and he said «sorry» and hung up on us. Let me repeat, this is a special on their website that says promotions are good as long as they are on our website. He didn’t even give us a chance to say «ok, we’ll still order». Just hung up on us. When we called back to ask if he just cancelled our order, he said yeah, I won’t charge your card.
Very disappointing from a place we thought was our new regular spot for pizza and Italian.

This place is absolutely fantastic! The pizza is delicious, the dinners are superb and the staff is more than friendly. I was taken aback by some of the asinine comments below, as every interaction I have had with the owners has been an absolute pleasure! This place truly rocks

Good pizza, thin and crispy how I like it. Also had a buffalo chicken wrap. Wayyy too spicy, but decent. Chicken was grilled thinly sliced and goosed w hot sauce

We just moved into the area and have been trying all the pizza joints around to find a good one. With Angelottis it appears we found it. We have ordered pick up a few times and recently tried delivery. I see the other reviews talking about the staff being rude. Not our experience. Recently ordering delivery they were skeptical of our location since we are back in the sticks but the guy on the phone was willing to take my word for it that we were really not far at all. The driver called twice lost and I guided him. Great food. Yes entrees don’t come with salad but most come with pasta and its a solid portion. As a tip if your ordering a few entrees for take out get a side of meatballs. It’s just a few bucks and you can throw them in with all that left over pasta. Prob will order every Friday now lol.

If I could i would rate this dump –1 stars. I walked in and this pig of a man tells me that my family better hurry up because they’re closing soon. Mind you, it was 9:00 –ish and the sign in the front said it closes at 10:00. We tell him about the sign, to which he replies he could care less, it is his store so he makes the rules. We just left. Will never return, and I made sure to let everyone in Marlboro, Morganville, and OldBridge know.

This place has become very disappointing. NEVER order a sub from them…1 piece of meat and 1 piece of cheese is what you will get broken up all over the bread. The cheesesteaks are AWFUL it looks like some kind of fake meat… The pizza on the other hand is decent… definitely nothing to go out of your way for.

My first (& last) visit. I ordered 2 slices and a coke. They charged me $ 7.80 for 2 slices and a medium soda. I pay 5 to 6 bucks for the same thing in most other local pizza joints. So I expected really great pizza. It wasn’t. I got 2 smallish slices of rather bland pizza. Well, at least the place was clean and the table and chair was comfortable.

Me and my husband visited this place about 3 years ago when we first moved to the area and were disappointed and never went back. Recently we were at a loss of what to do for dinner and we decided to give it a shot because it’s just so conveniently close. Well I have to say we were extremely surprised at how much we enjoyed it this time. I got the chicken Marsala and my husband got chicken franchaise. It was delicious we also got a rice ball special (basically rice ball parm) and it was unbelievable. We have had them again a few times and have been very happy with the service and the food! You can tell they use good products and everything is mostly fresh! Definitely recommend!

Love this place! I got the lemon chicken and my family really enjoyed the pizza! The portions are large (I got 3 meals out of the lemon chicken) and the staff is very friendly.

I have to admit I haven’t eaten inside yet but I always cater from here. The food they prepare is NOT «pizza place» quality it is true catering. We ordered trays and trays of appetizers and everyone always raves about the food! Love their rolls too like Eggplant and Sausage. Nicest people to deal with too! I ordered from here numerous times and they will be catering my NYE party too!

Angelotti’s is delicious. Thin, crispy crust that is baked nicely. You can order by the slice and they reheat the slices in the oven for you, or they will make you a fresh whole pizza. Their margarita pizza and garlic knots are excellent! Reasonable prices, fast service, overall a good experience.

Pizza by the slice. So good! Crispy crust! Perfect balance of cheese crust and sauce.

I love this place. It was originally in Howell and I used to make the drive to get it. It’s the perfect sauce-​to-​cheese-​to-​crust ratio. Very flavorful!