The Original Randazzo’s Pizza

Pizza is good. I really like the Sicilian pizza. I enjoy their salads always fresh and prepared to your request. Staff are the owners and are always very pleasant. Seating area always clean. Plenty of parking and they deliver

This place has okay pizza. I would just walk down the street to Gino’s which has great pizza.

I just had a meatball pizza. It was outstanding. The sauce is so fresh. This might be the best pizzeria in North Shore.

Not a bad place
for what it is its great, its trying to compete with 2 already established pizza joints but this place is cheap and taste is not bad
staff is friendly can be slow at times, they deliver which is always a plus
i will order from here again

Garlic knots, and lots of knots of every variety, spinich, cheese, plain, garlic, simply delicious. Pizza rolls of all types looking scrumptious. Specialty pizzas are next also. Will return.

finally a counter thats normal height! theres also a new menu…
Baked clams and spinach knots are delicious

WORST EXPERIENCE*
Have gone here a few times and thought it was good (despite my son having ‘unrelated ’ stomach upset hours later)
This time, ordered a Sicilian pie with half mushroom and olives.
NASTY– undercooked, canned product, cheese was undercooked.
The rubbery mushrooms and tasteless olives were basically dumped on top of an already cooked pizza and were cool to the touch.
I asked to speak to the owner, but the cook came on the phone pretending to be the owner. I know the owner doesn’t have an accent.
When I explained that fresh ingredients are what I expect, he said I should have asked for «fresh mushrooms or olives».
It was MY FAULT.
He then hung up abruptly.
I called back about 20 minutes later, just as my wife’s stomach started acting up…
I was told by the cook that I could bring back remainder of pizza, but only if there’s ¾ or more left… I’m sorry, I had a slice of the topped and a slice of plain (wishful thinking) as did my wife, plus my two kids made projects out of theirs.
BEWARE!!!

Good pizza! I always get the regular cheese slices here and its always so juicy and mouthwatering. I could eat this stuff for the rest of my life if I had to. Plus the service is always on point and the prices aren’t too bad.

Yes the parking lot is large enough to where you don’t have a problem pulling in, but pulling out can be a hassle because where normally there is an exit it is closed off.
I had there $ 5 special, two slices of small square deep dish with no topping slices and a cola beverage. It was very bland and very forgettable. The seating area is very small. I wouldn’t return.

Best pizza in Manhasset, luckily they deliver to Port Washington. Food is always fresh. Staff isn’t bad either. Here is how I look at it:
If you want the best plain pizza — Randazzo’s… by far
If you want the best specialty pizza — Rosa’s in Port

I love randazzos pizza… Always fresh, pasta is delicious. I love there salads. I can live on them .:)) overall clean and nice atmosphere…

this place is at the north end, and quieter end of the village… brave to open with gino’s and villa milano’s on the same block, two long time businesses in the area, but parking in the back improves the experience, and not a bad slice helps too. i had the buffalo with blue cheese on the side and it was quite good. the service was good, but not overbearing. given the choice between the three pizzerias on plandome road, i would go here hands down.

4 stars for the parking. Anyone who works in Manhasset knows how hard it is to park in the town. 4 stars for the Grandma slice! 2 stars for the buffalo slice. I like spicy things, but just to spicy. Nice atmosphere, and clean. I would def eat here again.

This place recently changed hands and was previously known as Billy Dee’s Pizza. As previous patrons of Billy Dee’s, my coworker and I decided to try this place out for lunch. The overall look of the place has not changed much but the food has improved. The menu is the usual LI pizza place fare with nothing unusual standing out. I ordered a sicilian and a regular slice and both were fairly good. Their sicilian was a bit too fluffy for my taste so I would probably stick to the regular. I also ordered some garlic knots which were also good, but not exceptionally so.
The thing that sticks out the most is the price. This place easily offers one of the cheapest lunches in Manhasset and the food quality isn’t bad so if you are looking for a low-​cost alternative to the usual high-​price food in the area I would definitely recommend it.
Some minor gripes: the place is a little cramped if you have a crowd but they do have a TV and allow you to change the channel. Also, at the time of this review they did not have a credit card machine available despite advertising that they accept credit cards. This will probably no longer be an issue in the near future. Overall a 3-​star average pizza place.