Andiamo’s Pizzeria

Excellent food. Large sized portions. We had small house salad, chicken capriciosa and bowties Mama Anna. All very nicely presented and tasty.
Rob and Jordan made us feel right at home although it was out first visit.
We will be back with a larger group shortly.

We ordered pizza here last week (takeout) to switch it up… try a new place… We were all totally sold… the crust was excellent, the sauce was really flavorful & the cheese wasn’t overly greasy like some other places. So so good… totally worth it! I wish I could comment on some of the negative reviewers reviews and disagree because our experience was 100% positive. My whole family agreed that its better than any of the other local places. They also have excellent deals… I found their service to be pleasant as well. I wish them very well as a business!

Ordered fried calzones (not on the menu but they were very accommodating) and it was honestly unbelievable. Delivery was on time if not early and the food was great! We found our new pizza spot in east northport.

We decided to try Andiamo’s for dinner a couple of weeks ago and overall the experience was mixed.
First the good. We ordered the Penne a la Vodka as part of a combo, and it was probably the most flavorful Vodka sauce we ever had, which I would be happy to eat any day. Unfortunately they didn’t include the dessert that was supposed to come with the combo.
Now the bad, and unfortunately it involves the pizza. We ordered a regular pie as well as a mixed white pie (half broccoli half spinach) and both were disappointing. Both pies were a little bland, but the real issue was the crust which tasted terrible (like uncooked flour). I suspect the issue was that they apply too much flour to the peel to keep it from sticking.
We will probably be back to try some other kitchen items, but I think we are going to stay away from the pizza.
— — — -
Update 4÷11÷2016
In response to the owners comments below. This was absolutely a combo that included pasta a bowl of soup, salad (and was supposed to include half a canoli) that was advertised on the board outside the store. I have the reciept (which was emailed) confirming the amount and that the cashier was Robert Grimaldi (presumably the same Robert G. that commented below)
Perhaps this isn’t a permanent special, but it was what we purchased. The pizza was not part of this special and was ordered separately. As for any confusion the restaurant I am referring to is at 400 Larkfield Rd in East Northport, in the location formerly occupied by Joey’s of Mulberry St.
Regardless of the cause the pizza tasted like uncooked flour.

Ordered a grandma pie for delivery online from their mobile site. The pizza arrived under 30 minutes, hot and delicious. While not your typical grandma pie, it has a lot of cheese, the flavor was delicious. The crust was crispy and the sauce was on point!
Very happy with a last minute decision for pizza!

Pizza was bad, wayyyy too much oregano. And they took 90 minutes to deliver. I get it that delivery is slow on Friday nights, but we were told 45 – 60 and when we called it was obvious that they completely forgot about our order. Oh, and the lady my husband placed the order with was super bitchy, like we were doing them a favor. Never again.

Amazing cheese slice, reminds me of NYC slices. Went late at night right before closing and the slices tasted as if they just came out the oven.

Wow! Really good. I had the chicken Chipotle slice which was simply delicious. The chicken and the slice were nice and crispy. Also there was a strange but delicious ingredient in it. Maybe bacon. But I couldn’t see any. I also had the $ 5 half hero special (which I didn’t need after the chicken slice since I was so full). It was also nice and crispy and came with extra say on the side. You could tell that whoever makes the food here really cares about the quality. Even the cheese on the hero was extra special. Also the food was hot not warm like everywhere else likes to serve you. Plus the girl behind the counter was super nice and very attentive. Also they play Fran Sinatra in the background. What more can you want in a pizzeria?

After the owner honored his business and stood by his customer, he replaced my prior order of which I was dissatisfied with and made me a happy customer, pizza was good and everything was as expected. Thank you and you will hear from me again!

This place gets 5 stars for the fact that the pizza is both delicious AND something a little different, the price is right, the cleanliness of the restaurant and the great service. The pizza is delicious and slightly unusual for Long Island pizza… slightly thicker crust than usual with a grainy bottom. As someone else commented, the cheese to sauce ratio is absolutely perfect. I could not believe the low prices for the lunch specials. I will be back when I’m on LI!

This is a solid pizzeria in a sea of solid pizza.
The regular pizza is different from your standard Long Island fare in that the crust is bumpy on the bottom– and it’s a pretty solid regular pie. The ratio of cheese to sauce to crust is just about perfect, but I do think the sauce is just a little on the weak side.
The prices are also very reasonable, and the owner is a really nice guy.
In all, I don’t think this is the best pizza in the area, but it is above average. It’s in our rotation of pizzerias.

I seem to be in the minority, but my husband and I were both so disappointed! It used to be Joey’s of Mulberry St, which had the best plain pizza around. We ordered a regular pie, well done, and a chicken parm hero. The bread on the chicken parm wasn’t toasted at all, so the sauce made complete mush out of it. It wasn’t even crusty italian bread – it was way too soft. The pizza was mediocre. The crust was thick and gritty with semolina, which wasn’t pleasant at all. The top was well done, the crust was soft and underdone. We threw the menu out, because we know we’ll never order from there again.

Great, service the place is really clean pie looked nice n hot when I got there for pickup the food is amazing. If your looking for a local place to get your pizza from this is the place. Extremely polite people and pizza is done right.
Service: 10
Food taste: 10
Cleanliness: 10

The regular pie is a bit too soft and doughy for my liking. It kinda felt like I was eating Italian bread with sauce and cheese. I prefer a thinner and crispy crust. The service there is friendly.

The pizza rocks! Get a calzone too or even a meatball slider because the dough they use is so flavorful it makes anything taste great. The staff are very nice and the service is quick and dependable. Get their pizza special when they have it… less than $ 20 cured my craving for a day.

I ordered take-​out from here. A regular pie and a Sicilian pie. The regular is unique in that the crust is bumpy on the bottom. It is really good. I can’t imagine anyone being disappointed with it. The Sicilian though, was phenomenal. Best Sicilian I’ve had outside of Umberto’s (New Hyde Park) unique take on Sicilian, which is really saying a lot, and since Umberto’s version is so different, perhaps Andiamo’s DOES qualify it as the best standard take on it. The specialty slices looked amazing too. I’ll have to try some of them one day.
I deducted a star because when I picked up the pizza it took about a minute for me to be acknowledged even though I was in there with only one other person, who was sitting down. They then grabbed the pizza without saying a word and said the price. No «thank you» or «have a nice day» after signing the credit card slip. Luckily, pick-​up isn’t contingent on customer service experience or this place would not have the reputation it is gaining. If you are in the area and have a hankering for pizza though, this is the place to come.

Love Andiamo’s the food is always great, you can tell they care about what they are making & serving. With plenty of options for lunch or dinner nearby, they are doing it right.

After two trips, I’m ready to commit. This was some damned fine pizza, with the perfect thickness and cheese to sauce ratio. Perfectly cooked, the crust was both soft and crispy. I can’t say enough good things. Oh wait, did I mention the $ 5 special? That’s the price for two slices and a 16 oz fountain drink all day.
The wife had the barbecue chicken slice, which had a nice sweet sauce. Another great choice.
The service was outstanding, the food perfect, the price just right. I want to come back with our granddaughter for an Olaf pie!
Totally recommended!

Andiamo Andiamo! («let’s go to Andiamo» in Italian)
I have only been here once and I love it! The staff was so friendly, the pizza was so good, and they even had a fine selection of energy drinks. The garlic knots were oily (in a good way) and seasoned and cooked to perfection.
There is plenty of parking in the front or in the rear and the establishment itself is very clean and has excellent lighting. The prices are on point! What’s not to love?
If I am ever back in the East Northport area, I will definitely be stopping by here to pick up a delicious pizza slice and get peppy on a cool energy drink.

I’ve been living in E. Northport for a year and a half now and haven’t been able to find good pizza… I was queens spoiled… well my prayers have been answered! Andiamo’s pizza was amazing! Crust was fantastic and pizza arrived nice and hot (in terrible weather mind you) the garlic knots were fantastic and they threw in some zeppoles for me to try! Amazing place with amazing people! Will definitely be ordering often! Thank you guys!!!