Filetto’s

Almost always eat here when visiting family on Long Island. Chicken parm w/​pasta is on the money. Pizza is pretty good, too. Bread and salad also on the plus side. Haven’t had anything else because of the «ain’t broke don’t fit it» motto, and I don’t live nearby.
I see a lot of negative reviews about service (more than the food), but most of it is for takeout. This doesn’t apply to me, and it might not apply to you. If you plan on dining it, recommended. If you plan on taking out, I don’t know. The waitstaff has always been good when I ate there, but the staff is young, so the odds of takeout errors increase.

Went here with a group of 5 kids and 6 adults. We ordered a large meatball pie for the kids and that’s the best that can be said about the whole meal. The adults ordered 3 salads, lasagna with meatballs on the side and a «baked salmon encrusted with pistachios». It took 1 hour for food to arrive from the time we ordered. The salmon was unrecognizable it was so covered in white sauce. It was truly unappetizing. The menu description was nothing like what was delivered! Chef or manager comes out and says that’s the way we make it. Pistachios are in the sauce. Apologized and took off bill but my mom was so disgusted and it would have taken so long for her to get any kind of food at that point, she gracefully declined anything. We told the manger we waited over an hour and he said they were busy with takeout! Restaurant was ¼ full on a sat night. Glad they took care of their take out customers… couldn’t believe he actually said that to us.
Salads were mediocre. Lasagna mediocre. Meatballs didn’t arrive until after the lasagna was finished and we kept asking where the meatballs were bc he wanted to eat them WITH the lasagna. They came out as our friend finished the lasagna. Our very young and inexperienced waiter was sadly terrible. Nice kid but in no way competent. The bad service and experience there was all anyone could talk about toward the end of our dinner and completely overshadowed the whole experience. We will never go back to filetto’s. The pizza there is good but get it to go and save yourself a headache. We wanted to like this place so bad, this was our second try. Same thing happened the first time about a year ago with the bad service and mediocre food, so we tried again. Total mistake! Especially when there are other great places to go. The bad service is just an understatement. Don’t waste your time.

What more can i say? I had food catered and everything was PERFECT just perfect.
I ordered a bunch of different trays, eggplant part, escarole and beans, broccoli rabe, a delicious pasta, chicken francais, sausage and peppers. My picky italian family loved it and raved! Even the salad was delicious. It was nice great to get extra sauce and serving spoons too. Filettos I am a fan for life

They have the worst service. There is I shortage of Italian pizza places. Stay away. Not worth it

Busy place and worth the wait. When you go to eat at a busy place you should expect some sort of wait. If it was slow, the food wouldn’t be very good of fresh! LOL
Love the cappelini cakes and the heroes!
I Recommend!

Just back from this place, very disappointed with the quality of service… I phoned in the order (chicken Parm hero) the girl over the phone says 25 min I show up 35 min later an wait 10 min for a sandwich… So45min to get a chicken Parm sandwichTO TOP IT OFF ITS UNDER COOKED!!! Lol you guys got to b kidding me I’ll stick to CHEFS OF NY. YOU GUYS LOST ME AS A CUSTOMER… And I live a round the block… GOOD LUCK

We go every Wednesday night for the Parmigiana Menu. Staff is friendly and attentive. The portions are large and the red sauce is fresh and light. Delicious!

Great food– nice restaurant. We had huge portions for a reasonable price on pasta night. It was a Monday night. I will be returning.

Okay. Was craving there Mac n cheese pizza so we went. 1^st of all the waiter the rude older waiter that thinks he is the best sucks basically threw my horrible stuffed artichoke. at me, the choke, I didn’t touch, I just stared at it, saying to myself, «really» chunks of garlic through whole thing and my boyfriends food wasn’t even served to him. Well anyway, finally, his so called pepperoni and sausage roll came with my Mac and cheese (20 min) later and of course, his is wrong, he hates peppers and onions, so what was served.-«Peppers onions and sausage «oh and the waiter in the beginning, we told him just sausage and pepperoni roll nothing else at all on it. The waiter comes back and asked does he want on hero or wrap. WHAT. ?? We just said s&p roll. Never will go back ever. The worst. And the week before we had the best little Latino woman order and food was perfect. Sad cause I’m not the only one who says the waiter sucks and won’t go back.

The food is just alright, have had better at many more places. We have give there now 3 times to give them a chance the service just plain sucks. Let me give a few examples.

We only order from here when we need it delivered. Staff and owners are not the nicest people which is the main reason I won’t even go here. Your in the customer service industry, make customers feel welcomed and wanted.

Food is great– service AWFUL. I recommend takeout only! I went there on a Thursday night. 3 other tables were there but no one came up to us for 15 minutes. Our pasta dishes were amazing! But the most attentive staff member was the bus boy, who I don’t think spoke English.

The food is still the best around (especially the pizza) but I am deducting one star for the poor delivery and take out order experience. They need to get someone other than young nitwits taking phone orders. Too many mistakes.

The good: Takeout. Typically the orders are correct and the wait time isn’t bad. The portion sizes are generous and they usually give you a good amount of bread.
The bad: Eat-​in, price, and service. I’ve eaten here maybe 5 times and twice, including the last visit, we left because nobody came to our table at all to take an order. We waited a good 15 minutes. This was also on a Wednesday night with a half full restaurant. Meanwhile, the manager is standing at a table adjacent to us talking to people and looking right at us. As we leave he says nothing and just lets us walk right out the door.
I’ve given Filettos many chances. For now on we will get better tasting pizza down the road at Mario’s and more reasonably priced pasta across the street at Chefs.

My absolute favorite restaurant. The atmosphere is great, very nice looking. The staff is always nice. The food is amazing. My favorite is the baked penne. Best sauce I’ve ever had. And who doesn’t love a restaurant that gives free bread appetizers?! I never want to lose Filetto’s from my life.

I don’t get why people love this place. I can’t stand their sauce and the service is always slow… But I give them three stars because everyone I know and their mother (literally) love this place…

The best and most authentic pasta I’ve ever had!!! I ordered the Pasta Alfano, so good, I will come back again if I’m in this town! Portions are so huge, you can share with a friend! Worth every penny I spent!

Nothing special. Food was cold and so was the restaurant. The place was cold, I asked for the heat to turned up. They said «the heat’s on». I will never go back.

Great Food Every time!
Just moved in to the neighborhood and I think I found my new pizzeria! Always a pleasure to deal with.

Love this place we are here almost every week, the food is great, love the Paninis !! We never had a bad dish here. The grandma pizza is amazing !!