I tried this place today because I was close to it, despite a lot of bad reviews. I should have listened to those bad reviews, because their pizza reminded me of the pizza I used to have at the bowling alley when I was a kid at all my friends birthday parties. It looked like it’s been sitting out all day, was bland, oily, floppy, and cost me $ 10 for two slices and a small soda. I would’ve spent $ 6 for the same order at the place by my house and would’ve enjoyed it 100% more. Needless to say, I recommend you try another pizza place. Way overpriced, not very good
L H.
Classificação do local: 1 Manhattan, NY
Pizza is not very good! They are very expensive, definitely not worth it at all! I don’t mind spending a buck, but when it is more pricey in this dive of a pizzeria then it is in the city there is a problem…
Amelia B.
Classificação do local: 1 East Hampton, NY
So… I’ve been going to Fierro’s for forever, since I grew up in East Hampton, and only recently did I notice something: We ordered a large pizza and when we got the box I noticed it was small, measured it out, it came to 16.5 inches. I look at the menu, was under the impression that the 18 inch pizza was the large. Made a phone call, told them about my issue, was met with harsh voiced«whoa whoa whoa — The 18 inch is the EXTRALARGE. You didn’t order that.» I said fair enough, my mistake. My husband walked over, said he was charged for $ 19 extra large pizza though. Sounds like Fierro’s has their own little scam going on. Needless to say, they have definitely lost our business.
Nicole S.
Classificação do local: 1 New Britain, CT
This place was dirty and there were flies everywhere! I had the gluten free pizza which was horrible!!! On top of that I asked for garlic on the pizza… Needless to say It tasted like terrible bread and a painful amount of garlic! Highly advise against this place!
Holly M.
Classificação do local: 5 Scottsdale, AZ
This place is fabulous! If you’re looking for the best New York slice in the Hamptons, look no further. The pizza here is really well done and there are always a number of varieties, from traditional pepperoni to buffalo chicken, which is out of this world! They sell other stuff as well, but why would you bother? Get the pizza! Everyone who works there is really friendly and they know all the regulars by name. They are open year round as well, so no matter what time of year you’re in the Hamptons, you’re in luck. Make a point to stop in!
Ed Z.
Classificação do local: 5 Watchung, NJ
Best place to grab pizza in the Hamptons! Its located on the entrance road into the town lot from Race Lane, across from the Waldbaums. Be SURE to check parking regulations, as you WILL get a ticket if you go over the time limit in the lot or on the street. The food has always been terrific. I primarily order the pizza, the buffalo chicken and BBQ chicken being my favorites. The sandwiches are also terrific. The owner John is a super nice man and a true gentleman. When I need a quick meal, this is one of my favorite places in East Hampton. They have a TV for those who like to watch sports while eating.
Ed G.
Classificação do local: 4 Quakertown, PA
Had takeout pizza. It was very good. Crust was cooked well… not soggy but not burnt. Sauce was good and fresh. Enough pepperoni but not overpowering. And the cheese was good. And while pizza is a very personal thing, I would find it hard to believe someone would be dissapointed with pizza from here.
Kenneth B.
Classificação do local: 3 Marina Del Rey, CA
Prefect local pizzeria hangout! Friendly atmosphere and good food. Visiting from California and this was a gem in an area of over-priced establishments. I had the meatball sub which was served on an excellent roll. From the activity Fierro’d appears to be the local hangout.
Jane E.
Classificação do local: 1 East Hampton, NY
Went into Fierro’s about 8pm, ordered a large mushroom pie for eating in restaurant, by 8:30pm staff was sweeping floor and using a horrendous smelling floor wash to clean the premises. Managed to eat 1 slice before the smell of bleach [?] ruined everything. The staff members doing the cleaning had not much to say. No apologies, no sorry, no accomodation, nada. Paid the $ 25 had them wrap the remaining pie to go. What’s with these people, they just lost a regular customer due to their pure stupidity and being anxious to close shop. Hey, I’m going back to Pepperoni’s where the pie and staff are better.
Christiana M.
Classificação do local: 2 Hampton Bays, NY
Ordered a greek salad and a pepperoni slice by phone to go. $ 19.50…YIKES. Salad was on the small side(single serving, not one of those«large salads» that italian establishments are notorious for giving that can last two meals.) To my dismay the olive oil-based dressing tasted as if it had turned, so I tossed it and ate my salad dry. The kalamata olives were pitted but not well leaving very small shards that were enough to chip one’s tooth if you didn’t chew carefully enough. The salad as a whole was a bit of a disappointment from size to price to quality of produce; my «green» peppers had yellowed and the lettuce was a mix of white and yellowish-green(although the cherry tomatoes were lovely!) My pepperoni slice was ok, nothing fabulous, but it was sufficient. Not sure what happened to this place, it was a nice find over the summer. $ 19.50 for a small greek salad and a slice of pizza isn’t ok to charge when neither are phenomenal… probably won’t be back.
Ryan M.
Classificação do local: 4 Seminole, Tampa Bay, FL
As a Florida native, I’m not an expert on New York pizza; however, my dad is. Born in Long Island, he was itching to get a pie while we were visiting family. He wanted fresh out of the over and got pepperoni, I got a Hawaiian. Very tasty, even though mine was reheated from being on the display counter. Big slices, crispy crust, good flavor. My dad wasn’t raving after we left, but didn’t complain either. Apparently they are celebrating 30 years in business and the old owner came back after taking a few years leave. Friendly staff, cool TVs and quaint atmosphere.
Brian S.
Classificação do local: 1 Greenwich Village, Manhattan, NY
Hands down the worst pizza I have ever had. End of story. Doughy, and under cooked. No love for the art of pizza making at this place.
La H.
Classificação do local: 3 Great Neck, NY
This is not my favorite places in East Hampton to get pizza, but they are pretty decent. I had a basil pesto grandma slice, which was a bit strange. My friend had a meat lovers slice and he enjoyed it. Great service, friendly staff — I only I noticed they like to poke fun at people’s eating habit’s — the owner, for like 20 minutes, complained about a customer wanting blue cheese on their chicken park — honestly not the weirdest thing in the world.
Jonathan P.
Classificação do local: 4 New York, NY
I haven’t been to this place in a while. But by far, the best Sicilian slices and garlic knots around. Not a whole lot of eating room inside, so do take out.
Mason I.
Classificação do local: 4 Long Beach, NY
If you want a good slice and get the hometown experience, this is your best option.
Evan R.
Classificação do local: 3 New York, NY
This used to be hands down great pizza… it changed owners and now it is very uneven. Sometimes the old owner is there to help out… and then its very good… but I hate to say this… sometimes I have just had to throw the food away or I would be throwing… up seriously!
Michaela P.
Classificação do local: 4 New York, NY
I agree with Adam. If you’re from EH, this is a home town staple. My favorite slice is the buffalo chicken. The only reason this place doesn’t have full stars, is because the prices have gone up over the years.
Adam D.
Classificação do local: 4 NY, NY
This town is my home, and the pizza from here are one of the staples of my home experience.