I have eaten at Bella many times. The pizza, made New York style, is very tasty! However, the shop is run by armatures, and that is what gets tiring to watch. This place could be a lot more successful if they just took the ambiance into account. Do not leave tables dirty all day long, don’t leave chairs on top of tables when you aren’t cleaning the floor. There is obvious laziness and lack of attention with the employees, and that is the only reason this isn’t getting more stars.
Chris P.
Classificação do local: 5 Boca Raton, FL
Pizza made the way it should be. Solid, tasty crust. Awesome sauce. Quality cheese and the freshest toppings they can get their hand on. We love this place.
Whatdoesit M.
Classificação do local: 5 Manhattan, NY
Consistently the best NY style pizza on the north side. I should know; NYC is home. My wife and I get a large cheese pie almost every Friday night and enjoy the remaining slices for lunch on Saturday
Craig T.
Classificação do local: 5 Carmel, IN
Stopped in while looking for some dinner. Just grabbed a classic pepperoni pizza. There was a good menu to choose from. The young lady who took my order was nice and helpful advising me how long it would take. The pizza was what I expected. Good!!! Will eat here again.
Matt H.
Classificação do local: 1 Anderson, IN
I have tried to go here for lunch twice and it never opens on time. I end up having to go somewhere else. It would be nice to actually be able to give a review of the food. If your sign says open at 11, then is it never open? Doors locked, lights off, but someone always in the window working on making food. I just don’t get it. Even another customer was wondering why they weren’t open. Good way to lose business.
Tom B.
Classificação do local: 3 Westfield, IN
I go here for lunch quite a bit. There’s nothing really special about this place, but it’s just a good quality New York-style pizza joint. I like their pizza sauce, which is a sweeter, New York type of taste. The slices are very large, so you kind of have to fold them — another East Coast thing. Service has always been very good.
Cory K.
Classificação do local: 5 Carmel, IN
I have gone here many times to know that I love this place. The stuffed pizza is phenomenal. There isn’t really any other pizza like it, as it’s not really a deep dish, nor a normal pizza. The breadsticks are very good too.
Mari F.
Classificação do local: 4 El Cajon, CA
I’m not a fan of fast food type pizza, but there’s something about this pizza that I really like. It’s in no way fancy, gourmet pizza. It reminds me of good old New York pizza. We like thin, crunchy, well done crust which they do great. We’ve eaten it there and had it delivered to our house and I like it much better when we eat it there. When we had it delivered it wasn’t quite as crisp and slightly greasy. I also love that you can stop in and buy it by the slice to cure a quick craving!
Tierra R.
Classificação do local: 4 Indianapolis, IN
I’m here for the first time and if I weren’t too full from the pizza/breadsticks combo I’d get another slice of the meat lover’s.
Gina R.
Classificação do local: 5 Westfield, IN
We ordered this pizza yesterday bc Jets Pizza did not deliver to us. All I can say is, wow. The quality of this pizza is outstanding. The pizza was hot when it got here and was very good. I no longer care about Jets Pizza. This is our new go-to for pizza!
MJ W.
Classificação do local: 4 Indianapolis, IN
Well hello there Bella Pizzeria! I’m embarrassed to say that I live walking distance of this place and have NEVER been here before now. This is the most authentic NY style pizza in Carmel. The prices are fair and service is quick. They also deliver!
T.j. K.
Classificação do local: 3 Carmel, IN
A slice, 2 breadsticks, and a drink for around $ 8 sounds good to me. What you would expect out of a large slice of and breadsticks from anywhere like this in the area. On this visit I had a supreme which was really good although their stuffed pizza is still my favorite. Besides pizza and breadsticks they also have garlic knots, calzones, salad, and usually a pasta selection.
Jason L.
Classificação do local: 5 Carmel, IN
Fellow Unilocaler’s, is this place as good as it looks? The crust and cheese looks amazing. Please let me know your thoughts. I am going to try it next week and will post a formal review. Also, what is the best thin crust pizza in the Carmel area? Thanks
Ashley P.
Classificação do local: 4 Dayton, OH
Looking for a quintessential Pizzeria experience in Carmel? Look no further than Bella Pizzeria for a quick dishing of delicious pizza and pasta. I recently stopped in to fill an Italian craving and had a difficult time deciding between a slice of ‘Za and their home made Baked Ziti. As the Ziti was served with their tasty Garlic Knots, I was easily swayed. Not only do you get a generous portion, but a rather inexpensive upgrade of about $ 1.75 will include a sizeable amount of spicy sausage, meatballs or chicken. Top the meal off with a homemade cannoli or a yummy looking cheesecake brownie.
LC H.
Classificação do local: 5 Carmel, IN
Really friendly staff! It’s small little pizza pie place. The White Pie and the garlic knots are the best! Super yummy!
Amy C.
Classificação do local: 2 Carmel, IN
We’ve ordered take out pizza a few times from here. I’ve also stopped in for a slice while shopping at clay terrace. The pizza isn’t great. It’s kind of like mall pizza. Also count your change! Twice they have shorted me. Both times I caught it right away. It shouldn’t happen as the register tells them the amount… The customer service is crappy.
Rae Ann P.
Classificação do local: 3 Bunker Hill, IN
Yes, close to NY pizza — but it isn’t anything like what I grew up on and ate for decades. Sorry folks — don’t think this cuts it quite right. Yes, you can fold it and it is thin and not a dry cracker, but that’s where it ends. Got the deluxe — maybe a pepperoni would be a better choice. We got a deal from Fox 59 — so we have another certificate to use. Maybe next time I can say something better. after I try the pepperoni… not in a rush to go back. Small alley like room — at least there were two TV sets to watch the Olympics on while we waited.
Dramara S.
Classificação do local: 1 Carmel, IN
Been here three times and each time have experienced bad customer service from the non English speaking manager Jaime I refuse to continue spending my money at a place that doesn’t value great customer service
Neesha M.
Classificação do local: 5 Somerville, NJ
Bella’s(specifically the Clay Terrace location) comes as close to NYC style pizza as I have been able to get in Indy. The crust is thin and foldable, the sauce is zippy(not sweet) and flavorful, and the cheese is just right. I always go for plain cheese… toppings mess it up for me. It’s a touch pricy, but it’s worth it.
Patricia N.
Classificação do local: 4 Indianapolis, IN
Would’ve been better if the cost wasn’t so much. My friend and I ended up at $ 13.12 for two slices of pizza and two breadsticks total. We thought this was excessive considering we didn’t even order any drinks.