That’s Italian Too

If you want to get a huge Italian sub for a New Year’s party, this is the only place that matters. I’ve never actually been in there. But for 2 straight years I’ve absolutely destroyed Italian subs that have been picked up from this place on New Year’s Eve.
I’m sure there’s nothing that looks more attractive for a girl walking into a kitchen in Quincy than seeing a dude going to town on a four foot Italian sub without a care in the world, but that’s how good this place is.
Buckle up buckaroos, you’re in for a treat.

I used to live right down the street from this place and I would grab a meatball sub occasionally and it was delicious

I love this place! Great quality sandwiches. The cranberry walnut chicken salad is my favorite. Doesn’t matter what toy order it is always fresh and delicious.

I’m a moron, because I’ve lived 2 blocks from this place for 4 years, and I only just started going there. Truly regretful delay. Italian sub was amazing — loaded with meat. Quality ingredients, fresh bread, and friendly service. Can’t go wrong.
As a math teacher, I am qualified to declare that this place is at least 3 godzillion times better than Subway. (FYI: 1 godzillion = 100 brazillion)

Small sub shop on Washington st in Weymouth. Stopped in for an Italian around noon during the week and it was already getting busy. The folks working were very nice and were like a little army working behind the counter. I got a sub roll but meant to get bulkie, my fault. The sub was absolutely loaded with meat and toppings but almost too much. It was the messiest Italian I’ve ever had and most of the toppings kept falling out all over the place :(if it wasn’t as messy and falling out everywhere it would’ve been a lot better but I threw the towel in after I could only do so much with what was left in the roll that hasn’t fallen out.
Next time I’ll make sure to get it on a bulkie roll and hope it isn’t as messy. Overall though great quality ingredients, fast friendly staff, bad location. def recommend if you’re in the area for a good sub shop.

Have gotten take out from these guys before and it’s always delicious! Without a doubt one of the best sandwich shops in Massachusetts. It’s a delicious selection with mouth watering sides and drinks to go along with your meal. Highly recommend them!

I have been searching for a good Italian cold cut sub near Milton, to no avail. My sister told me to try That’s Italian Too, and I wish they’d move closer to me! Great sub, nice people!

Best cold cuts around! I love their Italian sub and their Pastrami sandwiches. Their potato salad is also excellent as well as their fresh rolls.

Had a large buffalo chicken sub with the works. One of the best subs I’ve had in a good long time. Plenty of thick sliced buffalo chicken and stuffed with all the additives you could want. Also, had their home made cream soda. Best thing on gods green earth. Friendly staff behind the counter who were eager to help me made this first visit a good one. I’ll definitely be going back frequently.

I go here for lunch all the time. Best sandwiches around. You need to take it to go as there is no seating, but the italian sub makes it well worth it. I usually only get the ‘smal’ on a bulky roll and it’s plenty. Very friendly staff. A real hidden gem

Food — Get the Italian sandwich. Good meat cut.
Service Ambience — quick moving line. Only take away.
Cost -~$ 7.00 per pax

Came here at lunch. Good quick service. Chicken salad with cranberries and walnuts was excellent.

There have been other Italian cold cut subs that come close, but none as good!

Awesome Italian sub dripping with oil and pickles and onions.
I think I reeked of it all day which wasn’t the best thing since I had meetings for the rest of the afternoon, but so worth it!
I do wish I had gotten the special of the day though (which was a pulled pork sandwich with either Russian or BBQ sauce). Mmmmmmmm sounded so good!
The guys were SUPER nice and friendly, and I was given my sub in record time! It looked like they did a super brisk takeout business (note: nowhere to eat inside)!

I’ve had better Italians elsewhere. The location is great but there is like 1 parking spot there. Papa Ginos actually has better tasting subs (weird). Maybe its just me.

Great subs and platters. Owner is very nice and always has a smile.

Booyah!!! The BEST Italian sub you will EVER EAT IN YOUR LIFE!!! I have been going here since I was a little girl, they never EVER disappoint. I would give them 10 stars if I could! Seriously, I lick my fingers after the sandwich is gone. I am Italian, and I know great Italian!!!

I’m a sucker for a great sandwich. Something about a tasty sub bring back childhood memories of going to the corner deli and getting a sub with everything tasty on it. Now the search for a great sub in Weymouth is over.
They place is small but easy to get to. Plenty of parking (small lot but never filled up), and everyone that works there is very attentive. Fresh cut meats, Utz potato chips (Salt & Pepper chips are ridic), and plenty of choices for sides and drinks. The owner is a great guy that always seems to be working the register and is very appreciative.
If you’re getting a sandwich at Subway and know that this place is just down the road, you shall be flogged. Stop in here and don’t be disappointed.

Cant go wrong here the best subs in Weymouth the owner/​manager is super friendly too he always has a smile and you can tell he truly cares about the customers and the shop — ps try the cannolis they are delish!!!

Super Subs on the South Shore and More
If you read my reviews you know that I hail from the City of Brotherly Love and the land of Hoagies. Ever since I’ve left Philly I’m in constant search for quality subs. That’s Italian Too has the essentials for a quality sub spot.
First, the meats on their Italian Sub ($ 5.25) are the right blend of Mortadella, Genoa Salami and Pepperoni (I would’ve liked to see some Capicola but hey). Next, the cheese the use is a nice sharp Provolone, that provides the right bite to the sub. Following up is the hot peppers they use, not the rings but the finely diced hot peppers that add heat to every bite. The bread is little soft but the length was generous and held a hefty sandwich for the price. The chopped onion/​tomato relish that goes on it is tasty with the olive oil and spice but a bit messy.
The only points I would take off would be that the everything comes with pickles. I mean pickles? What is this Subway?
Bonus points are given for their great chip selection including many varieties of Utz (my personal faves being the Salt & Pepper) and the fact that they bottle and sell their own soda. I got a Root Beer and it was great (other flavors include Cream Soda and Raspberry Lime).