Pudge Bros. Pizza

This was my first time to this particular store. I had a Groupon for carry-​out, and was looking forward to the pizza. The huge disappointment came when I found out that they have an everyday «special» for carry-​out for a large 1-​topping pizza for $ 9.95; but the Groupon specifically excludes specials, so the same pizza I could pick up for $ 9.95 ANY day, would be $ 15.95 because I was using a Groupon. The markup on the pizza used up the entire «discount» of the Groupon. I ordered the large pizza, bread sticks and cheesy bread. The pizza was soggy from grease in the middle and not cut all the way through. The cheesy bread was good. The bread sticks needed to be cooked a little longer and lacked flavor. Overall a pretty disappointing experience at this store.

Great pizza a little pricey and service times are not the fastest. Made for carry out or delivery

My husband picked up the pizza, so I can’t remark on the cleanliness of the place, but I was very disappointed in the pizza. It’s EXPENSIVE! But, it’s in the neighborhood, so we thought we give them a try. We’ve lived here 25 years and went once in the early 90s and didn’t like it then, but it’s changed hands at least once. Guess what? Nothing has changed. Actually, it’s worse.
Earlier in the day, my husband stopped in and got a jalapeño burger and loved it. He brought a menu home with him, and it looked so good we decided to go back and get pizza for dinner.
We ordered two large pizzas, 14″ — The crust measured 14 inches, but the toppings were only on 6 inches in the very center of the pizza. There was a 4 inch band all around that was nothing but crust. There wasn’t even much cheese on that part. (Yes, I measured it) As far as the toppings, they charge $ 2 per topping on top of the regular price of $ 12.99 — I had four slices of mushroom and 8 halves of black olive. I was charged $ 4 for that??? The other toppings, Canadian Bacon and pineapple, were just as nearly nonexistent. My husband ordered double sausage, jalapeño, and black olive, and they were as sparse as mine. We should have taken them back. Shame on us for not doing so. We paid almost $ 40 for two pizzas that had a couple of tablespoons of topping, the extra cheese was nonexistent, and the crust was not what I ordered. I ordered PIZZA. These people are robbers and thieves and if they went out of business tomorrow I wouldn’t feel sorry for any of them. From now on we’ll make sure everyone we know knows how bad this place is and when in the area we’ll just go next door and have teriyaki chicken, which is consistently always delicious.
I’ve heard the pizza at Capitol Pizza in Thornton is really good.

We ordered from here because we got one of the coupons with a special on it. The inside of the store itself is really gross. Peoples belongings sitting on a shelf right by the register hanging half off and all messy. We sat down at the table while waiting for our food and it felt like it had never been cleaned before. The stickiness of it made me actually gag. Overall the pizza was okay, the cheese bread was amazing and the wings were like Tyson appetizer wings they threw in the microwave and squirted some sauce over (yuck yuck yuck). I don’t think we would ever order from here again.

I’m gonna give u 5 stars cause I love u guys. I brag about u all the time. I had my family over tonight, ordered 2 monster pizzas, told them Pudge Brothers is the best.
I know it’s Friday night and the wait might be long. The nice girl said 45 minutes to an hour. Well it was almost 2 hours. I called at 1.45 asking if it was coming, they said any minute. It did come finally.
It was really old and cold. Was kind of embarressing. Told my family they were getting the best pizza ever.
So this is a little shout out Pudge Brothers. You are the best. You have the best pizza hands down. I don’t want anything for free or anyone to get in trouble. Just wanted to give u some heads up. I’ll be just as excited to order from u again. Just please get it to us on an hour hot an fresh. Thanks pizza gods.

Pudge Bros. Pizza is absolutely brilliant every step of the way. When you order, they don’t care. When your food is bad, they don’t care. When you call to complain, they. don’t. care. They stay true to their pudgy name every step of the way. I, for one, know a thing or two about pudge. You don’t earn that pudge by caring. Noooo sir!
Competing franchise owners should be bowing down to this establishment. No advertisement of their’s could ever be as effective as the Pudge Bros Experience in turning customers on to their unquestionably superior establishments. The Pudge Bros, like Orville and Wilbur Wright, are true pioneers in customer flight. 2 big stars for that.
But seriously, don’t order from here lest you desire the same «Pudge Bros Experience»

Never again. Please, believe the reviews. I didn’t and now i am $ 25 poorer and $ 25 sadder.

This is the only pizza place I will order delivery pizza from. I’ve only had the pizza so I cannot speak for the rest of the menu, but it’s always great tasting. The Jersey Girl is my favorite menu pizza, and they have a nice selection of toppings if you decide to build your own. The delivery people are nice and courteous; their service is far superior to any other delivery service I’ve encountered.

Pizza is ok — Delivery is AWFUL. Delivery people NEVER bring Parmesan cheese — even when asked to. Delivery people almost always get the order wrong and manager doesn’t care. Will be taking my business elsewhere after this happened 3 times.
Edit: In response to the manager’s comment below. I did call and talk to a manager after the second time. Nothing changed — delivery people are as bad as ever. I am noticing that I;m not the only one complaining about the horrid delivery service.

Been an hour no pizza never had this bad service here ever guess find a new pizza joint goin down hill should of listened to the other Unilocalers :(never again fuck this shit grrrrr then the idiot lady told me 45-​hr called back barely left then told me i told u hour n few minutes broad must be high NEVER AGAIN

Ordered at 8… Still not delivered at 10. Said it was out for delivery at 9:20 when I called to check and I can only imagine it will be cold and gross when/​if it ever shows up

Took 2 hours to deliver a cold pizza. Isn’t this what you do? Won’t be ordering from here again Anthony’s pizza is better anyway

Haven’t gotten to my food yet, but in the notes (on specific items and at end of order through eat24) asked specifically for plastic silverware, condiments, napkins. I received none of these things. Now I get to hunt down fork, etc so I can eat my food. Thanks for that. Simple idea, silverware and napkins should be in EVERY ORDER.

The pizza toppings are all awesome. Homemade meatballs, cut up linked sausage (instead of pre-​slices), delicious sauce and tasty crust. Really great! They miss by 1 star due to the bottom being too soft to hold and eat. So, they just needed to cook it a few more minutes. Other than that, great!

Not a good pizza… Ordered a monster plain cheese and it came 45 mins later cold, soggy, and chewy. Called back they offered a new pizza be sent «right away». After waiting 45 mins for the first (on a Wednesday night at 8pm) I asked to be refunded my money instead. Threw the whole pizza in the trash as it was pretty much inedible. Ate ramen for dinner. Sad night.

They were over an hour late. As soon as I was picking up my phone to call and see where the hell my food was, the delivery driver called asking my apartment #. Turns out they had written down a way different number. My pizza was terribly soggy in the middle, the driver forgot to leave my salad, but did come back a few minutes later to drop it off, nice and warm, just the way anyone wants their salad. The driver also divulged that someone else had accidentally grabbed my pizza so they had to make a whole new one but without being courteous enough to call and let me know of the delay. They left me with a few coupons that I have no intention on using.

First time ordering from the 92^nd ave location about 3:05 pm today I ordered the Monday madness combo .20 inch 3 topping and rec. a free med.3 topping and both pizzas were really, really tasty, very happy with all the toppings. everyone i dealt with was polite. i was told 35 to 45 mins. and it was closer to 55 min. delivery time which really didn’t make me unhappy. the down side was the pizza was warm at best, hotter would have been 5 stars for sure. we would order again .(.p.s. i haven’t erased blackjack’s number just yet) but it could happen

Try the Cannoli’s they are BOMB!

I paid $ 10 for stale ore Ida fries and one of those buy 20 frozen burgers at a time burgers. There were like 6 people in there and they were just standing around. This place is filthy and I predict they won’t last long. You’d be better getting a hotdog at the gas station next door.
This is the first time I’ve felt compelled to write a review. They get a point for packaging the lettuce, onions and tomato separately to keep them crisp.

I got to give it to them. Normally not a fan of this chains pizza but the pizza I ordered, today, was delicious.
I ordered a basic, pepperoni pizza and it was it in less than 10 minutes. They guys were very friendly and informative. Apparently the dough is made fresh, daily. I would recommend this location to anyone in Westminster.