Papa Tino’s Pizzeria

Super Bowl Sunday…
Placed the order 24 hours ahead of time to give them sufficient time since it’s their busiest day too.
5p pick-​up and everything seemed ready until I wanted to verify I had everything, before I opened all the containers an employee told me the breadsticks were missing. Odd that he knew this even though I was sent on my way. No apologies from the staff and I was told 20 minutes was the best they could do. Instead I requested a refund which was given.
On to the food itself. Fries we not great. Mozz sticks were the good ones, very nice. Chicken tenders were overcooked but well received by the kids. The pizza was «ok» and nothing spectacular and while there were lines to appear as if it was sliced it was not.
Price was good.
In summary messing up the order, ok quality, and not actually slicing the pizza gave them the 2 of 5 in my opinion.

Delicious small town pizza with fast delivery! Nice thick crust and a hefty amount of toppings on the meat lovers. We wandered in here, desperate for some food after moving into a home in the neighborhood in record time, and were immediately offered a menu to take home, along with quick delivery that they lived up to. Pretty lucky this place is less than a mile away. Decent prices, too. Not sure about all the crappy reviews here, as we had an awesome experience. Worth a shot in my opinion!

One star is too high. Stear clear of this place if you are looking for decent food and service.

They’ve got pretty good wings! The char-​pit option is great, too. Pizza from this location is less than good, however. Customer service is usually good. If you like good pizza, try Bernardo’s on Coffeen Street instead.

I write this review strictly on their calzones. I have not been into papa tinos, and I have had only two things on their menu, a peperoni calzone and their garlic bread. My wife and I recently moved into a house in watertown so decided to order out. I’m telling you, the calzone was possibly the best I’ve ever had. If you are looking for a giant, cheesy, delicious, mouthwatering calzone, you gotta try tinos. It was the bomb. I see these other reviews and see how people didnt like the restaurant or didnt like the chicago pizza replica, but if you are looking for a late night friday or saturday meal, you can’t get better than tinos. 1000 calories? probably. A grungy eat in experience? Maybe. The best calzones ever? absolutely.

We just moved to Watertown from La Crosse, WI a month ago and have been trying out the different pizza restaurants in the area. I’m originally from Chicago so pizza is very important!
We tried Papa Tino’s a few weeks ago and I have to say I won’t be eating it again.
We mainly chose them because we were looking for a truly thin crust pizza and they were willing to make us one. We ordered a small thin crust pizza and a large calzone.
The thin crust was inedible. The cheese was rubbery and the crust was hard and tasteless.
The calzone was a bit better, but not by much. I had to cut every piece with a fork and serrated knife because the crust was very hard. Normally the crust is one of my favorite parts, but the crust on this pizza was hard and literally tasted like cardboard.
The cheese in the calzone I thought was tasty, but the sauce was more like spaghetti sauce.
So far, I’m sticking with Cam’s!

I went to this place a few months ago, and like a strange person, I sat in the restaurant to eat my medium pizza (this place is definitely geared towards pickup/​delivery, but it has a few booths off to the side). The pizza was pretty good ! I plan to go back soon in order to give my review more depth.

I stopped here when I blew out a tire and needed a place to pull over. The owner happened to pull in right as I was inspecting the damage and was really friendly (tried to help me out, but calling the motor club was all I could really do since it was pretty much ruined). My 2-​yr old and I were pretty hungry, so we decided to have a sandwich inside while we waited for the tire guy to come.
The food was decent for the price… nothing spectacular. They have a good size selection of pizzas, subs, salads, calzones, wings and fried appetizers. No fountain to be seen – drinks are just bottled or canned beverages from the cooler. Staff were very friendly.
It was far too warm inside the restaurant and the parking lot is tiny, so I give it four stars.