High Pie Pizzeria & Taproom

Loved this place! We were really craving pizza and beer for dinner, and High Pie gave us just that. We sat at the bar and ordered some great draft beers. They also offered a sample if you wanted to try something new. The Caesar salad was outstanding, the pepperoni pizza delicious. The staff was really wonderful as well. Excellent service. If you’re looking for great beer and a fantastic selection of pizzas, check High Pie out!

SLOW — nobody in sight and it takes 15 minutes for a draft? No wonder this place is dead.
Not important in the stops. Head to Brown Dog — better all around.

Gluten free meatballs… yum!!! Boyfriend got a delicious sandwich and the chips with it were awesome. Soda was great too. Great atmosphere. I give it 4 stars instead of 5 because they offer gluten free meatballs in a bun, but the bun is not gluten free… makes no sense! Still loved the meatballs though!

Ate here last night for our first night in town– everywhere else was crowded but we managed to grab seats at the bar. Ordering was easy enough, and bartenders were attentive– the pizza just lacked some flavor. Good for a bite when you’ve got time to kill– took almost an hour for our pizza to arrive.

They have a bar, tvs and area for children to run around, but the service is extremely slow, seating isn’t very comfortable, it’s loud and the food isn’t very good. Our food came up at separate times. I ordered the chicken tenders, which were awful and tough, and then our pizza came out about ½ hr later. The pizza was eh. There aren’t really any «servers» So, if you are sitting down eating and you want to get another drink from the bar you have to get up from your table and stand in a long line for a drink and by the time you come back your food is cold. I wouldn’t come here again.

Don’t get fooled by the awards of Brown Dog pizza. High Pie has the hands down best pizza in Telluride. Fresh tasty ingredients delivered quickly with huge TVs and a large tap beer selection. If you want greasy $ 30 pizza and blacked garlic knots then don’t eat here.

Excellent service, friendly staff, yummy bites and consistent wifi. During my recent Telluride trip, this spot served as our morning headquarters… and will do the same on our next trip, as well.

Great little bar and pizzeria. We had the BBQ chicken pie which was quite tasty. We brought our dog after hiking so they showed us where we could sit on the back patio right by their ice cream shop. Plenty of beers on tap and a wide selection of food. Great place to stop in for a beer and a pizza.

Locals do not come here — for a reason. Food is marginal, priced for tourists and the service is horrible. They always have an attitude…
Pass it by…

Worst service EVER. We sat at the bar for 15 minutes without so much as a «hello» or «just a minute and I’ll be with you» from the bartender (blonde woman in her 40’s). She served other people their 2^nd and 3^rd rounds, then started helping people who came in after us. That’s when I spoke up and told her we’d been waiting and were here before the others. She made excuses about how busy they were, blah, blah, blah. And her attitude was terrible! Very rude. She didn’t apologize for overlooking us, or offer to help us next. There was another customer sitting next to us who had the exact same complaint. We all got up and left.
The place was dirty and the empty dishes sitting on the bar were never picked up.
Don’t waste your time going to High Pie; there are too many other nice restaurants and bars in telluride.

We didn’t eat here, so I’m not sure what the food landscape is. However, we had a nice time sitting at the bar, watching football. They made me a mean cucumber martini. It was perfectly blended, probably one of the best cocktails I’ve had to date.

welcoming place for tourists, bartender Shane really made us feel comfortable. Also met the kitchen Manager Angel who checked with us to make sure we were taken care of.
Kids were able to run around and play games which was great. Pizza was also really good. They had live music, which was a nice touch.
Kids liked it so much we came back two nights in a row.

Nothing special here. Service was ok. You have to order at the bar and a server brings your food out. Not sure how hard it would be to have servers waiting on tables but ok. Food was very average and drinks were eh. Better places to eat in town for sure.

Bartender was aloof, salad was drenched in balsamic and the calzone lacked a healthy amount of ingredients and was not tastie.

3.5 stars seams about right. They have all the right things going for them including live music, a rustic setting with an open bar and an easy pizza ordering system. They ran out of ingredients for the drink I wanted and graciously comp’d me another drink.
The pizza is where they are lacking… friends who ate there in the winter said their pizza was burnt and refused to get the pizza again. We decided to give it another go and one pizza was cooked well and the other was undercooked. So they need a timer on the pizzas or something because they were all over the place. They tasted alright with some good flavor combinations (not traditional toppings).
The other reason why they lose a star is because they assured us there would only be a 10 minute wait and clearly after waiting in an extremely slow line to order (thanks to all the customers ahead with custom pie orders) it was over 50 minutes before a pizza arrived and we had to order them to go!

Cocktails are awesome
Food was delicious
We had a great experience at High Pie. Great menu with lots of choices and even gluten free items. The caprese salad was great as was the pizza. The summer drink specials were amazing especially the Orange Crush and Graceland Margarita.

I usually don’t write reviews if I haven’t actually eaten a place’s food, but after sitting at the bar for a solid 15 – 20 minutes without either or the two bartenders asking me if I’d possibly like something to eat or drink, I decided to get up and head next door to a much more crowded Brown Dog, where I was able to order almost immediately after sitting down.
Sorry, High Pie, but time is money (even more so when it’s vacation time), and you wasted mine without anything to show for it. Oh well, I can tell by looking at the photos that the pizza is mediocre.

High Pie is worth the trip. We sat at the bar for lunch a few days ago and ordered the 12″ Shifty Pie with prosciutto ham, arugula, onions, mushrooms and sausage. Absolutely delicious! Our server was very friendly and helped us select our pizza and chatted with us while we ate.
The layout is nice and there is entertainment for kids including a foosball table, games and a ping pong table in the back. Great food, great place.

Cool place in downtown Telluride.
Excellent thin crust pizza! Service was great. Our pizza came out perfectly in about 10 minutes. Good selection local beers. Large flat screen TVs.

8 customers in restaurant and it took 50 minutes from the time I ordered two pizzas. Crust was undercooked, soggy, spongy, uneatable. To many toppings with no balance of flavors for their specialty pizzas. Also a 10″ HAIR was in one of my pizzas, disgusting (wear a hat in the kitchen!)! At $ 30.91 for two 12″ pizza with extra hair I would never go back to this place. No table service yet the staff is dressed in black (fine dining?). They are completely clueless. Only wish I could them 0 stars.