Slice Masters NY Pizzeria

We ordered a pizza and salad to be delivered. The only reason for 4 instead of 5 stars was how long it took for the pizza to be delivered– especially with how close I live to the location. I usually expect 45 minutes but this took over an hour. The delivery man had a hard time finding my apartment which is probably why it took so long but the pizza was cold and we had to reheat it in the oven which was disappointing. We ordered a medium pizza and a small Greek salad. The pizza was good and the salad was excellent. I loved the dressing. I would try this place again in hopes that the food arrives quicker

First timers and we couldn’t be more pleased! Pizza and Wu Tang wings were really good! Also had a tossed salad and their house dressing was delicious! It was like an Italian Parmesan dressing. Delivery was pretty fast!

Absolute best cheesesteak I’ve ever had. It took a bit to make, but he even made the bread from fresh dough. Totally recommend.

Awesome local place that delivers. The pizza and wings are great and the garlic knots are outstanding. They are very reasonably priced and delivery wait time isn’t bad even in weekends… the pizza is new York style with larger slices and lots of fresh toppings

LOVE their pizza and wings. Service is awesome. Food is awesome. Simple, casual, like a mom and pop pizza joint. This place is my go-​to.

My husband and I were looking for a new local pizza place to try out tonight and I am so happy we chose to come to slice masters! I must admit, when we first walked in it was not what we expected however, I happen to love places that are unique and not like everywhere else. We ordered an extra large pizza, a dozen garlic knots, and a couple of cokes. The food came out pretty quickly for how packed the place was, which was a pleasant surprise. As everyone else has stated the garlic knots are delicious! And so was the pizza! Other than the food being great I must say just how nice everyone was to us. The owner, employees, and even a large group of regular customers were all so laid back and made us feel like family. My only regret is not finding this place sooner. Definitely coming back!

Ordered a large pizza for deliverer. Noticed the reviews for their garlic knots so I tagged that on. The delivery was within a reasonable time and the food was nice and hot. The pizza was excellent. The garlic knots were ridiculously amazing. I would eat here again for sure.

Feels like family here! They know our names and greet us every time we go. Food is always excellent. We even get delivery sometimes (even though we live 2 miles away) and it’s always fast and the order correct. My favorite are the calzones and garlic knots. I’m not a big sandwich person, but love theirs. The meatball is my fave. The bread is their pizza dough. SOO good. And, of course, the pizza is great! Love this place and highly recommend!

Reading the other reviews I was a bit apprehensive, but I went ahead and tried Slice Masters anyway, and I’m very happy I did. I ordered a LG cheese pizza, with extra cheese, a small mushroom and spinach calzone, and a dozen garlic knots. Let me tell you, this was WAY better than my expectations, let me start with the pizza first.
The pizza was what I’d come to expect for a decent NY style pizza, the crust was soft but crispy and didn’t just taste like doughy bread, it was the perfect end to a rather enjoyable tasting pizza. My fiancé (from New Jersey) gave it a great review too saying it’s a lot closer than what some of these companies claim to be NY style pizza.
The calzone, was delicious. Period. The ricotta was a little heavy but I personally like ricotta so it wasn’t a bad thing. I was satisfied with the calzone as it met my expectations easily and wasn’t overcooked or doughy.
And the garlic knots. Oh, the garlic knots. Perfect. I’ve had a lot of different garlic knots but these were definitely on point. Soft, not doughy, a little crisp, real garlic on top and on every bite. Look if you like garlic knots these definitely are worth trying out. You won’t be disappointed.
Overall I think I’ve found my pizza joint while I’m living here in Tampa, I’m completely satisfied with taste and price. Give them a shot, I don’t think you’ll be disappointed.

New to neighborhood stopped to get a slice It was GREAT thin crust well made awesome service!!! Definitely will return

Delicious and cheap! What more can you ask for in pizza? We eat here at least once a week.

Definitely an above average Pizza place for Tampa, but there is some strange aftertaste that drops this to only 3 stars for me. I’m not sure what it is, but it tastes good when I bite into it, but then as you’re swallowing you get this weird bitter flavor. It’s probably the cheese, but I can’t be 100 percent sure.
Obviously this blows away the chain garbage like Domino’s, Papa Johns, etc. but you can definitely get better non-​chain NY style pizza in the Tampa Bay area.

Unless you live in the carrollwood area, you’re probably never gonna run across this place because its smack dab in the middle of a neighborhood. It’s at the intersection of West and South Village, right across the street from a basketball court that i grew up playing at. If you do live around the carrollwood, Slice Masters IMO is definitely worth a try.
I decided to support one of my local businesses after getting a flyer in the mail for XL 1 topping pizza for 10.99. Called to order a pepperoni pie around dinner time and they said it would be ready to be picked up in 15 minutes.
The pizza was still steaming hot when I picked it up. The crust was a little on the thin side for my liking but it was perfectly cooked — not burnt but with just the right about of crisp. It seemed a tad smaller than the other XL new york style pizzas i’ve ordered from other places but maybe its just me being more critical now that I’ve decided to take on Unilocal as a hobby. The sauce was good and the pizza overall wasn’t too salty. As I’m sitting here 2 days later eating whats left of it, I can say that it tastes good reheated too! Will definitely come back in the future to try their garlic knots
TL;DR — not a bad place for your ny style pizza fix

This is the closest pizza place to where I live, so I was happy to find out that their food is good. It’s not spectacular, but if you are jonesing for a pizza pie and are sick of the corporate chain crap, this place hits the spot. They put a good amount of cheese on their pizza and the ingredients are plenty. But I think my favorite thing they make are their garlic knots. They are delicious, doughy balls of goodness soaked in butter, garlic and parmesean cheese. They are certainly one of the best I’ve had and truly warrant many returns!

Best garlic knots in town! They have real garlic on top. Their pizzas are huge and delicious! Great neighborhood place to order a pie or a slice!

When pizza is on my mind I always go to Slice Masters. Everyone is very friendly & the food is yummy! The staff treats you as if you’re family or someone they have known for years lol. I personally think that Slice Masters has the Best pizza and wings In Tampa.

Hate to sound like a Pizza snob. But when you’ve had good Pizza in the past, there’s a certain standard that must be met. Slice Masters falls short IMO. I will give them credit for the garlic knots, they were among the best I’ve had, the perfect crunch and the right amount of tenderness. Wings were nothing special, just your average wings. At the end of the day I came here for the Pizza. It’s just ok, not the type that’d have me screaming for more, I know a good pizza when I see one. When I think of good Pizza, I think of Cristinos, Paul’s Pizza, costco (yes costco), Even Westshore Pizza when the mood is right. Slice Masters is worth a try but limit your expectations.

In search for a good pizza joint nearby i decided on Slice Masters to see what’s going on.
You feel like you’ve walked into an enclosed back porch entering the front of the restaurant. This is where the majority of the seating is located. Then you walk through another door to get to the main kitchen where you order food.
The guys that work here (all look and sound like New Yorkers) seem to run a tight ship… they take pride in what they are doing unlike the teenagers you find at Marcos pizza.
They had a large cheese pizza and 6 garlic knots on special for $ 8.99, so I ordered 2 of them. I like my pizza well done because I don’t like the point on my pizza to sag. It was ok. The sauce wasn’t bad, but there wasn’t a whole lot of it on the pie.
I also ordered barbecue wings and Wu Tang wings. The wing sauce is made in house. The barbecue is tomato based and sweet. The Wu Tang wings is Asian chili flavored so they were sweet, tangy and spicy. Both were decent, but I wasn’t blown away.
The garlic knots were the star of the show. They are crisp but you can sink your teeth into them without tearing away like most knots I’ve eaten. The inside was lighter and airy that I expected. Flavor was perfect. They must’ve forgotten to pack marinara, so that was disappointing since I wanted to get a better taste of their sauce.
I’ll have to come back for another visit and try a different pizza as well as the sauce. I’d actually give it 3 ½ for this visit. I’m hopeful that I can bump the rating up to a 4 after trying more of the menu… but it will depend mostly on good sauce.

We order from Slice Masters often, and it’s always a good experience.
The pizza is great, the subs are delicious and the delivery guy is fast and always friendly.

This has been my go-​to spot for pizza in Tampa for as long as I can remember. Thin crust, New York style pizza. Big foldable slices with all kinds of flavor. I typically get their supreme which is excellent, but even ordering a pie with just cheese or pepperoni will not disappoint.
I’ve only ever dined in, so I can’t speak to their delivery service. Owner is a good dude, and the prices are definitely reasonable for the quality of their product.
Next time you’re thinking about grabbing a slice or two, skip the chain joints and support this local gem.