Mr Peeper’s Ice Cream

My ice cream was good but my boyfriends had a hair in it, the guy offered to remake it but we declined.

Got an ice cream cake for my daughter’s birthday and it was very good. Cost a lot less than Carvel too.

Love the ice cream pies with chocolate crunchies! Ice cream is amazing but add the crunchies, in the middle of the chocolate and vanilla layers and on top and omg. Puts carvel to shame. Esp if you add extra toppings like marshmallow fluff. This place kills me. I want my freezer at home to look like theirs, filled with delicious frozen ice cream sandwiches and cakes and pies.

Yummy ice cream. Large servings sizes. They have a good selection of ice cream cakes and ice cream sandwiches.

Mr. Peeper’s has some of the greatest ice cream in the area! They are tucked away to the side of the intersection and while the building/​scenery in that area is lack-​luster they make up for it with fabulous ice cream!
They make premium soft serve with a high milk-​fat content that is super creamy and delicious! They have pretty standard flavors, serving methods (cone/​dish) and toppings but it’s the ice cream that you come for!
The cakes are great too! You get WAYYY more ice cream cake for your money than you do at a big chain like Carvel. The important lesson I learned is to order custom cakes well ahead of time (about 24 hours) but even if you forget these have well over two dozen, freshly made cakes in a cooler to pick from.
This is really a great place to check out after dinner this summer.