Pizzalley’s

Great tasting pizza. Friendly staff and decently priced. It was pretty busy and I had to wait over 10 minutes but the pizza was good and fresh out the oven. Well priced food.

Best pizza in st Augustine! Their breadsticks are great too. You do have to order at the counter but they bring it to you. Seating is kind of limited but it is hands down the best pizza you will get here!

Got a slice of Italian lover’s (sausage, onions and peppers) pizza today. Pretty tasty, great crust, only $ 4. Very filling.

Great atmosphere. Great customer service. Great food!
Been there for pizza 4 times and have recommended it to our friends!

After eating at the Chianti Room side of this establishment, I popped in one day to grab a slice of pizza, to-​go. Beware of drill weekends in town, as this place is suddenly packed with 100 soldiers grabbing chow.
I got the Garbage Can slice, to-​go, and sat on a bench in the warm winter sun, and ate it with 15 napkins. The best way to eat pizza is with hundreds of napkins, for sure.
The pizza was incredible.

We love this place when you want to grab a quick bite with the family or come with a friend. It never fails us. Pizza is satisfying. You can order pitchers. The waitress was very accommodating, as we had small children with us. Walk to the back and their Chianti room had live music during happy hour. 2 for 1, which comes with a slice of pizza. Great price. This is across from Pizza Time & both places have unique qualities!

My family and I have been coming to St Augustine for 15+ years and ALWAYS make Pizzalleys a stop! Great staff and great food! Never a bad experience!

Go during happy hour buy one drink get a second free and a slice of pizza service was good! Always go to here for pizza in st. Augustine I’ve tried pizza time and they’re not nearly as good as pizza alley and they accept cards (:

We came here because, frankly, I didn’t see any REAL reason to wait in line across the alley for what is outrageously purposed to be USA’s #2 pizza.
First off, that’s absurd. the #2 pizza is in TLH. The #1 pizza, across the land (the cognoscenti will agree) is Frank Pepe’s Pizzeria Napoletana in New Haven, CT.
But I digress into petty pizza squabbles.
Pizzalley’s slices were good — I could tell they intended for them to come out as they did, because the pizzas at the other tables looked precisely the same.
This dough is light and crumbly on the bottom millimeter or two, rising up to 3 – 4 millimeters of airy doughishness. the connection between the cheese and the dough is clearly demarcated — and the sauce has a distinct signature.
I think it’s silly to go on and on waxing gastronomically about this pizza. It’s a good slice, the wait is insignificant, and (even though I didn’t have the pizza from across the street — with their «#2 in Tripadvisor’s book (big deal, who uses Tripadvisor anyway?)) I suspect equally satisfying after the commercial rigors up and down St. George street.

I know Pizzalleys as the pizza place always giving out samples to draw in tourists.
There is nothing spectacular about the pizza here. It’s average pizza for Florida, and that isn’t saying much. For better «but pricier» pizza head to the other side of St George Street.

Pizza was good. We had the cheese burger pizza, fajita chicken pizza and buffalo wings. Nice place. And God pizza

If you want a quick bite to eat this place is good for that. .I found out by the samples being offered to your by the door to lure you into the pizza shop it work on me… it’s good quality pizza at a cheap price

I think this place is very overrated. Everything was fresh and the people are nice. My Cesar salad was the best thing I had. We ordered the garbage can pizza and especially that is the name and the seafood pizza. They both lacked much needed flavor. Sadly to say if you are looking for good pizza this is not the place. Did not try the other foods so I can’t speak on that.

After a night of mediocre meals in the area as «tourists», PizzaAlley –Chianti room was highly recommended by friends. We gave it a whirl and couldn’t have been happier! Our party of 4 were greeted by a friendly hostess and seated in «the back room» per friends’ instructions. The complimentary, homemade bread and olive oil was on point! We ordered a bottle of Cab, and split two entrees which the chef evenly and beautifully served! Finished with sharing a Tiramisu made from scratch, that was heavenly. Highly recommended, paying it forward. We will return!

We went here for lunch, it was crowded, and we ended up sitting by the front door. Our waiter was really nice and was quick to point out that I could have a gluten free pizza with no dairy, which was great, because I’m allergic to both things. My sons enjoyed their mussels and fries thoroughly. They smelled delicious. My husband ordered a Greek Pizza, and I ordered the gluten free and dairy free pizza with goat’s cheese. Though the crust of my pizza was better than other that I’ve tasted, the sauce was really acidic. I felt like it’d burned a hole through my stomach.
The restaurant is extremely pricey. We ended up with a $ 100.00 bill, without alcohol or dessert, for four people.

Amazing!
Great atmosphere. Great food! Great drinks!
Not vegetarian or gluten-​free friendly, but I ordered a build your own pasta w/​all the veggies and w/​o the pasta, and it was phenom!
My husband is the ultimate carnivore and he was blown away by the calzone. And he is not easy to please.

This place is delicious! Great portions, amazing flavor, even the side salad is good. Pizza is yummy and lobster ravioli to die for. Service was great and Kerrie was very sweet!

For whatever reason, this is where I ALWAYS eat when I come to St George Street! The pizza is always made to order, and even though it may be about $ 20 for a full pizza, it worth it for the size and the sheer taste of it!
The only downside is the size of the actually place to eat and the limited seating in the front where most people want to be. There’s a full serve restaurant that’s theirs that’s in the back and a place to also eat outside when the weather is nice!
Try their pizza samples outside of you’re curious :)

I’ve eaten here twice now and it is just «A-​OK,» hence the 3 stars. It’s not bad… it’s not great. It just is what it is. A pretty decent pizza slice for a good price. A slice of cheese is just under $ 3 with tax. I thought the sauce had a nice flavour. A little sweet, but no so sweet like Papa John’s. I HATE Papa John’s because their sauce is just way too sweet. I like the crispy crust. My main complaint is for a slice of cheese pizza, it could have definitely used a little more cheese. I felt they were rather stingy in that department.
The pizza isn’t so great that I would ever come here and order a large pizza with friends for a full meal, but when strolling along St. George Street and in the mood for a snack, it’s a good place to pop in to just grab a slice for cheap. It’s enough to keep my belly full until I’m ready to have a full meal somewhere else. It’s also good for a late night snack around 10pm when everything else along St. George Street is shutting down.
The restaurant itself is nice, clean, and inviting. I found the customer service both times to be well above average. Very friendly, cheerful, and helpful employees working here.
I’ll return.

It’s a meh. The samples they give out in front of the door are different than when you order the exact same thing (a cheese pizza). Apparently the samples are with ‘extra cheese’ which would have been nice to know beforehand.
The crust is crispy, the sauce a strange kind of sweet and soupy combination and the overall pizza was a below average experience. HOWEVER — the bread sticks were great.
Fluffy, doughey and very well seasoned these were a total winner. They remind me of Little Caesars crazy bread upped a couple of notches. This is a compliment, seeing that I love those suckers.