The 1850 House Inn & Tavern

This was my first stay at 1850 but will not be my last. I have stayed at many b&b’s and this one has to rank at the top. The house is modern but comfy and immaculate. Every detail is thoughtful perfection. The bed and linens were so comfortable, me and my boyfriend didn’t want to leave our room. The breakfast was fresh and delicious. The back balcony area was beautifully decorated with flowers and a wonderful place to enjoy drinks from their tavern. Lastly, Simone was so friendly and gave us great hiking information. Oh… and the bacon!!!

I can’t say enough about this place! We had a wedding in town and we all stayed in the Inn. Staff was helpful, accommodating and friendly. The owners were lovely and we saw them several evenings at the bar and had drinks and conversation. The bartendar Sally was amazing! Deborah was a great hostess and super accommodating and Milton was very helpful as well. The rooms were clean and the beds were comfy. Breakast was great and not your basic muffins and cold eggs, it was fresh made coffee cakes, egg dishes, fresh fruit, etc. I would recommend this place to anyone coming to Rosendale. It’s very «homelike»

1850 is a very lovely hotel — quite beautiful, and we had a great stay. If you are just going to stay at the hotel, I would recommend it. It’s picturesque and quite lovely.
Unfortunately, I’m forced to give a negative review because leading up to our stay, we had an extremely bad experience. Lonnnnnng story short, we had planned to have our wedding party stay at the 1850 and were going to have our rehearsal dinner, after party, and after wedding breakfast at the hotel. We visited the 1850 four times throughout the process (it’s a 2 hour drive one way for us) and were lead to believe that everything was fine. About 2 months before our wedding, everything fell apart. The quick version is, 1850 just did not have the capacity to do all these events they promised and didn’t communicate that to us. I actually understand the situation and could have been fine with everything except at one point when we had everything worked out, my dad had a conversation with the owner, and the owner was very rude and said we were trying to take advantage of them. Trust me when I say — we ran everything by the hotel and were only trying to make the situation work since it was too late to make any changes. To me, it is simply unacceptable for an owner of an establishment to speak to a customer like that — no matter the circumstances, and that conversation is the reason I’m writing the negative review. If that had not happened, I could have looked past all the other issues.
Sadly, because of 1850, the months leading up to my wedding were quite stressful. I joke that planning the wedding was the easy part. We ended up having to pull all the events and reschedule them elsewhere. It did really work out for the best, as we had a lovely rehearsal dinner at Savona’s Next Door in Kingston, NY and breakfast at Deisings in Kingston, NY. I just wish 1850 would have been upfront with us and treated us respectfully in the process.
That said, the week of our wedding was wonderful — our entire wedding party stayed there is it was great. The staff was perfect and everyone who stayed there loved the hotel. So, I definitely recommend staying there — just don’t plan an event there.

Well, the Inn itself is very well designed, furnished, clean and simply beautiful.
The staff, Kyle, Jimmy, Allison, Mike and Genevieve were very friendly and accommodating. The breakfast was very well done.
The bad news… the owner himself, who is constantly walking around the inn or sitting at the bar was arrogant and argumentative.
We had numerous issues.
First, the restaurant was never opened the entire time of our stay because the chef had a «family emergency» (to which we later found out the chef had quit).
Secondly, we were told they had bikes to offer. They had three bikes of which all were in very bad condition. The bike I used ended up having no back brake. My wife’s bike was also in disrepair. Very dangerous.
Thirdly, we had inquired in advance if the Inn was nearby the Trailways bus station. We were told yes and there would be no need for a car (we were traveling from Manhattan and don’t own a car). The staff told us that they would pick us up at the bus station and drop us off as well. We were also told they would shuttle us to and from the Mohonk Preserve. Upon our arrival at the bus terminal we walked to the Inn (it’s about ½ mile). We told the staff we wanted to go to the Preserves the next day. They said no problem and arranged for 10am. When we came to the desk at 10am we were «greeted» by the owner who told us that there was some confusion but they don’t give shuttles. He pushed us to hike at the rail path nearby. We explained we had done that the previous day and wanted to go to the preserves. He suggested we get a cab. After further discussions he reluctantly agreed to take us but refused to pick us back up (7 miles = $ 30 cab ride back) and also informed us he was «going to fire the person who told us about the shuttle to Mohonk». It was all very aggressive and very unprofessional.
Fourth, we supported the Inn throughout our stay with having drinks at the bar before and after dinner (we would have eaten there too if the owner would have had his kitchen properly staffed to actually be open). Every night the owner was there sitting at the bar and not once did he apologize for the inconvenience/​miscommunication, thank us for staying at the Inn or offer to buy us a drink. Nothing.
Fifth, when we went to check out we asked to have the shuttle back to the bus stop (as we now had more bags because of shopping in New Paltz so walking wouldn’t do) and were told the owner took the shuttle and they couldn’t accommodate us. Thankfully one of the staff members was so kind and took us in his personal car.
In closing, Rosendale is a very small town and little to do. No real reason to come to this town for vacation (Woodstock, New Paltz or Kingston are all better choices). The one good thing would have been this Inn but until the owner stays behind the scenes I would say stay elsewhere. I feel bad for his staff.

We loved this hotel! Very nice boutique property that is the perfect blend of a 4 star chain and a historic b&b.
— Rooms are sizable and well appointed with nice linens, plenty of outlets, and good a/​c. Property is quiet and we slept well.
— Staff are very courteous and helpful from front desk to owner
— Food is solid and better than expected for a small property. Menu is limited but covers most needs. Lots of locals were eating here on a Friday night. The restaurant is on a big patio next to the creek.
— The hotel has a small bar inside that is wonderful. Great bartender, full bar, and many nice wines by the glass. I enjoyed the house beer, a crisp light ale.
— Relaxed, comfortable, and inviting atmosphere.
— Reasonably priced, both hotel and food.
Charming place. We’ll be back.

I give this place high marks. Clean, comfortable and reasonable. My only problem was the stairs – there is no elevator to accommodate seniors or those who might have some sort of disability. But the hosts were friendly and gracious, the breakfasts (included) were hot and ample. And the deck overlooking the Roundout River is lovely for relaxing over a meal or just drinks. I sampled the Tavern food, and it was pretty good, too. I will continue to return to this place as long as I can climb stairs.

As a local I really enjoy the 1850 House. The back deck is a great place to hangout and visit w/​friends. Menu is limited but I’ve always enjoyed everything I’ve eaten. Wait staff and kitchen are on the slow side but I wasn’t in a rush and for me it wasn’t a distraction.

My partner and I ate here for dinner. We’re staying at Captain Shoonmaker’s Bed & Breakfast which is 3 miles away from 1850. Service was very good. Food menu is limited. We both had Tavern burger which was delicious. Served with chips (no fries). Soup was warm, should have been served hotter. The highlight of our evening was playing, «Shoot the Moon». I am Deaf, once the server noticed me communicating in ASL, she/​he turned on the captioning on their TV. This is something I appreciated. Very much.

This review is based on an evening at the 1850s house, not the food.
We had a very nice experience here. I loved the atmosphere and comfort.
Also, slept in a bit and missed the continental breakfast!
We booked room 4, $ 189 for a Thursday night (a steal in my book) and it was just lovely. Everything was clean, although not sterile feeling. The bed was comfy and the bedding was high quality. The room was airy and bright but had heavy shutters and curtains. It was warm and welcoming, unlike any Holiday Inn.
Being from the area and just looking for a place to sleep, we did not take the receptionist up on any advice, although she seemed very willing to make suggestions for things to do in the area, and the room was well equipped with a binder of organized activities. Oh, and free wifi!
Went out for dinner in Stone Ridge and once returned, sat on the back porch and looked at the stars. The back deck would really be a great place to hang out.
Only downfall was the noise. Could hear other guests walking around and talking in the morning, although that comes with the territory of an older building. Can’t have your cake and eat it to.
One VERY annoying thing although not the fault of the 1850s house, was that the Rosendale Café across the street had loud salsa music until midnight. If you book any room towards the front of the building, you may want to check to see if the Rosendale Café has music that night (and avoid it…)
This may be better with the windows closed, but it was a warm evening and we wanted the breeze.
I would definitely return to the 1850s house and recommend it to all!

I can only speak to the bar, I’ve never been an over night guest. I went in one day just after opening to take a look around and it was like pulling teeth trying to get information. The woman was so cold that I left feeling like the bar was only for their guests. My second experience came when colleagues were staying over night for several days. We were working in the lobby the next morning into the afternoon. We were very abruptly told we needed to leave or face being charged another night. They could have handled this in a much more professional manor, it only reinforced my first impression. I won’t be heading back if I can help it.

Everything was so perfect! The bedding is extremely comfortable, the atmosphere is very relaxing and the breakfast was perfect. I definitely recommend this place for anyone who wants to have a relaxing stay.
Thank you!

Its official! The 1850 House Inn & Tavern is my family’s favorite place to stay.
Our four-​night visit at the hotel was nothing less than marvelous. The common areas and rooms played off the town and building’s rich history without compromising on modern comforts or updated décor. But that’s only half of why we enjoyed our stay so much, the rest of the credit goes to the owner and staff who became like loving family by the time we left. Nothing, and I mean nothing, was ever over looked and we were so taken by the kindness/​attentiveness that made the experience so warm.
We booked the suite, which was beautifully appointed like the other rooms but included a separate bedroom and half bath for myself. Everything was comfortable and clean; in fact, it didn’t take this germaphobe too long to feel right at home.
The tavern and living area were beautiful and relaxed as well, allowing you to come and go as you pleased to sit at the bar or nestle on the couch with something warm from the Keurig. The large deck outside played host to guests at all times of the day from early morning breakfasts to late afternoon drinks, amazing flatbreads, and other nibbles cooked on the wood fire oven right there.
Being nestled at the base of the Joppenbergh Mountain and the Rosendale Trestle (as a part of the Wallkill Valley Rail Trail) we found ourselves enjoying morning hikes and taking in the views before we started our days. Rosendale is also a quiet little town that boosts an amazing vegetarian café (across the street), alternative stores, a theater, Pilates/​yoga studios, a bakery, and a cheese shop. (Think of it as a calm New Paltz and you’ll have a good picture.)
Our stay in one word: perfect.

My boyfriend and I stayed here the weekend of May 2^nd for our 1 year anniversary. It was great!!! We live and work in NYC and had dinner before we went, so we didn’t arrive until late, but Genivieve was still at the bar and waiting for us with our keys and welcome packet.
We stayed in room 5 (3^rd floor corner) which was nice and private with a perfect view of the creek — we woke up to birds chirping every day! The breakfast was delicious and Amy was super friendly and helpful and gave us free passes to Mohonk.
We hiked Mohonk on Saturday (TIP: Go as EARLY as you can (or else parking is full) and park at the West Trapps Trailhead. Hike Undercliff to see all the climbers and continue around Laurel Ledge for AMAZING views… Bring plenty of water and snacks /​a lunch!). Saturday night we walked to a cute restaurant in town.
Sunday Mike let us borrow bikes and we biked the Rail Trail towards Kingston — awesome, easy ride after our huge hike. There were some really cool caves and ruins to see. Oh, and the trestle!
The staff at 1850 made us feel like we were staying with a friendly acquaintance and the other guests were friendly and happy to be there as well. We’ll be back!

Really cool place. I wish that I stayed here when I was in Rosendale. I really like historic places like this, because this place has character.
Only stopped for a pint, but they did have Dogfish Head on tap, which is nice. I’d definitely come back and stay here.
Nice place to warm up during Frozendale.

I found the Inn on the Internet when my wife and I were looking for a place to stay for a weekend of hiking in the Catskills. Wonderful place. Well renovated with a lovely inn feeling. Rooms (and beds) are very comfortable, wonderful hot breakfast in the morning, great tavern and relaxing grounds. Rosendale is a small village just north of New Paltz and a real find. I would definitely come back.

duration of stay 5÷25÷13 to 5÷27÷13.
Hubby and I stayed here with my mother in law and her sister during a Memorial day weekend visit with some family. We absolutely loved it!
This inn is located in Rosendale, NY along a lovely unique strip so there’s plenty to explore during the day in Rosendale alone, although you might wish to drive around and explore more towns upstate if you get here by car.
This place is absolutely beautiful, I took so many pictures but haven’t uploaded them to Unilocal yet. I believe they have about 13 rooms. We stayed on the second floor hubby and I in one room, my mother in law and her sister in another room. The staff of the inn actually took time to make the couch up into a bed so my mother in law and her sister didn’t have to share a bed if they didn’t want to.
The rooms are absolutely charming, with hard wood floors and a nice old fashioned yet modern feel to them. There wasn’t much space for clothing storage but we really didn’t care about that because we weren’t staying very long and didn’t pack too much. If you are staying awhile you might have to expect to literally live out of your suitcase if you are okay with that.
They offered breakfast in the morning from 8:00 A. M to 10:30 P.M. The breakfast choices were amazing for a bed&breakfast offering. The two days that we were there they baked a quiche, served fruit, yogurt, banana bread, muffins, and strawberry and rhubarb french toast. They also had a keurig available at all times for coffee and tea service. I’m not a fan of the keurig but they offered sleepy time tea which happily surprised hubby and I. We drink sleepy time tea every night before going to bed but we usually don’t take it with us if we go away, the fact that the inn had some on hand was a definite bonus of staying there.
It seems they offer food at other times but at a charge. They also have a tavern that we didn’t get to try out.
There’s two large sitting rooms which offer plenty of seating for every guest during breakfast, we didn’t have much time to hang out in the sitting rooms but there were couches and tables if we were spending more time there it would have been the perfect place to chill out and read a book.
You won’t regret your stay here this place is so wonderful!

I just had the most wonderful stay at The 1850 House Inn & Tavern. It is newly renovated, but maintains a lot of the historic charm, from the beautiful wide plank floors, to the photographs gracing the whole place. It feels more like an Inn than a B&B, but the breakfast we were served was absolutely delicious. A lot of care is put into the operation of this place, and it really shows. It’s also in a great location to explore the whole Hudson Valley… near to New Paltz, Mohonk Preserve and lots more. If I ever return to the Rosendale area to stay again I will definitely stay at the 1850 House again.

I can’t say enough good things about this place. I was so happily surprised by this gem. Recent renovations have been done well, blending historical attributes with modern comforts. The location is perfect, within walking distance to the rest of the small village as well as the creek. Our room was large, clean, quiet, with high quality towels and linens. Staff was friendly and attentive and didn’t have the «B&B Burnout» that we sometimes encounter. We loved our visit here and we’ll definitely be back.

Rosendales newest Gem, stop in for a drink and watch the creek go by.

Highly recommend this inn. It is spectacular and the service impeccable. So much to do in the area: kayak, bike ride, wine trails, sky dive, sip line… Love it! Thanks to owners and staff for so the attention to detail.