Manhattan’s Pizza Parlor & More

We were traveling and found Manhattan on the internet. Ordered while driving. Pizza was ready when we got there. Staff was helpful. Back room had a party that was not cleaned up. Dirty dishes on every table.
Took the pizza straight to our hotel a block away, got to our room it was cold. Pizza had little sauce or toppings. Green peppers were cut too big and we’re not cooked enough. Mediocre at best. Would not go back if I lived here.

Manhattan was not as special as I had hoped. Don’t get me wrong, it’s not bad but it still leaves something to be desired. I tried the Calzone and the pizza, the former was much better. Staff are really nice so kudos on that. I think it’s pretty comparable to Angelo’s so you might as well try them both.

I attended an event here and knew I wanted to come back for a sit down pizza. The soda’s are served in gigantic cups. We had a local classic Pueblo pizza. Pepperoni, sausage and roasted green chili. I did not think I would enjoy the addition of the chili but I was pleasantly surprised it tasted great. There was a mix up with our entrée order but management took care of it and our server was upfront and honest. I will happily come back when I crave pizza again.

The place was dirty and gross and the food was… Hopefully eatable, I tried to choke down my «egg plant»

Place was filthy! Bugs in bathroom, I only saw this after we ate or we would not have eaten there. Rude service. Nobody would wait on us and we were told we were somebody else’s problem. Food was horrible, nothing fresh. Would not recommend. Very disappointed

We just had this today, 3 large pizzas, meatlovers, pepperoni, sausage. You should never put chicken on a meat lovers pizza first off, second why is colorado so afraid to use pizza sauce! There was no sauce on it at all, and last but not least the crust was absolutely flavorless, nothing good about the crust. The pizza in general was ok however, good use of spices, meat was bunched up instead of spread out and instead of 40 minutes it took the delivery kid over an hour. I’m becoming more and more sure that there is no such thing as good pizza in Colorado.

So I’m told the food is great… so Friday night go out with 8 friends and come to get dinner. The host at the door said they were busy and refused to seat us even at separate tables, then they just told us to try somewhere else. so we did and we always will try somewhere else when we come to pueblo now

Great food. Very good service. We will come back all the way from Texas. Service was good also

Very good pie. Price was awesone. Just wished it had more cheese on it. All n all it is a very good slice of New York pizza here on the front range

While babysitting my Grandson in Pueblo (I’m from San Diego) I wanted some good pizza. My daughter recommended Manhattan Pizza so we gave it a try. I wasn’t disappointed. We ordered two large pizzas (one cheese and one Italian Sausage) and asked for delivery.
The pizza arrived within the time promised and it was hot and one of the best pizzas that I’ve had in a very long time. I’m usually a cheese only guy, but their Italian Sausage was out of this world. The prices are a little higher than the chain places but WORTH it.

Once or twice a year, we drive from East Texas to the Denver area to visit one set of our adult children. A few years ago we discovered Bella Luna in Trinidad and I thought I had died and went to Heaven. Ever after, we timed our trip to pass through Trinidad around lunch time for some of the best pizza we have ever eaten. Yesterday, unfortunately, our timing was off and we got to Trinidad around 4 (they are closed ‘tween 3 and 5 daily) and didn’t want to wait. Back to Unilocal,looking up I-​25 to Pueblo and found Manhattan’s Pizza, an easy off and on exit (Hwy 50), less than a mile West.
The rest was pure pleasure.
We spotted the Pepperoni/​Sausage, Hatch Green Chili pie and ordered up a 14″ to go. It was still another couple of hours to Highlands Ranch, our final destination. I also ordered a small «Stella» beer to get the dust of travel out of my throat. The we noticed the chalkboard! Friday special, Order one 19″ pizza, get a 10″ free. The wife returned to the register and asked if we could change the order, now 10 or more minutes into the process. I figured the first one we ordered was already in the making, but no matter, they changed the order. Then we notice there was a deal on beer, too. Buy one, get one free. WOO, HOO, I had a second small glass. Perfect.
Pizza came, and we with great anticipation we took it to the car, banished the dogs to the far rear, and opened the big box. Oh my, I wish I had taken a picture. It looked simply awesome. I was handed my first (huge) piece and wondered how I was going to eat it and drive. I didn’t, just sat there and stuffed my face, listening to my mate’s Mmmmm’s and sighs. So good, what else can I say. I ate it to the last crumb wondering why we hadn’t been stopping here instead of Trinidad. The second piece was delivered to my mouth, fork by fork as we traveled North. Sated and looking forward to some warmed up pieces today…
Not to compare them, Both good, but next time through I believe we will be stopping in Pueblo. Maybe both ways :)

This place was delicious, very convenient off the highway great pizza and deals they serve beer and the service was quick friendly and a great atmosphere I would recommend to anyone. Enjoy

Terrible service. Servers had no personality. Served is rotten chicken wings. Not once got checked on. No sense of timing in this facility at all. Bunch of nonsense.

The pizza is reall good. I mean seriously good.
The b only complaint I have is that I ordered a beer and it came out in a under a pint glass. Make surr yoh say TALL when you order one

The food is good. I’ve been here twice and haven’t been disappointed with the food. Their pasta dishes are fantastic and their pizza is one of the best in the area. I would give 5 stars but the service takes FOR-​E-​VERRRRR! Lots of kitchen staff just standing around and the waitstaff just disappears. Overall, I recommend you try it if you have lots of time to waste.

absolute best pizza around! i lived there for a year after living in chicago and have to admit, i pick this pizza over chicago pizza but all the other pizza places around kinda suck. also my bf and i would order their fries and fried pickles. they have the best ranch sauce and everything is pretty cheap. It was our favorite place to go to in pueblo!

I’ve been craving some New York style pizza for a while so I was eager to try out Manhattans. I have to say it was one of the worst pizzas I’ve ever had.
I got a large pizza with sausage. It came to table quickly and was warm but not piping hot. It definitely didn’t taste fresh. I’m starting to wonder if they make a bunch of cheese pizzas and leave them under a warmer and then top them and put them in the oven for a short time to heat up the toppings. There was barely any sauce and so little cheese that my guest and I used almost a whole shaker of Parmesan on our pizza — this coming from someone who doesn’t normally use Parmesan on a decent pizza. The sausage was good but it was the only thing I tasted on the otherwise flavorless pizza.
The pizza was $ 14.49 which isn’t bad for a good pizza. However, this wasn’t a good pizza. Save your money and get DiGiorno. It’s far, far better.

I was here for an organizing committee meeting and had the lunch special. Basically, it is a two topping 7 inch personal pizza and a salad for about $ 7. I opted for pepperoni and black olives for my pizza and blue cheese for my salad dressing. Both were what I would classify as pretty average. They were decent and definitely a good value, but it was standard stuff ultimately. It’s a good place to have a meeting and also a nice spot to grab a quick and cheap lunch.

I spent a month living at the Super 8 down the street while doing a contract job in Pueblo. This place was on the regular rotation for dinner.
Good pizza. Thin, NY Style, but not too crispy
Can’t comment on their drink selection as their liquor license was suspended for the whole month I was there.
Definitely worth a return if I ever find myself living in a motel in Pueblo again.

I’ve had pizza all over the Denver metro area. Oddly, the very best pizza I’ve had in Colorado isn’t in Denver metro at all. Manhattan’s Pizza in Pueblo, Colorado has it all: great crust, excellent sauce, and amazing combinations of ingredients. My favorite was the Mussa Pizza (Hope I’m spelling that right…). The Mussa has pep, sausage, and local roasted mussa green chiles. AWESOME! I’ll be back every time I come to Pueblo. Hoping they bring their place to Denver soon.
If you are lost in Pueblo and don’t know where to go. Try Manhattan’s; have a beer, order some garlic knots, and check out the specialty pies.