2 Brothers From Italy

I have been buying pizza and dinners from Tino and John since 1994. In my opinion after trying a slice here or there from other pizza places, they have the best pie in the area. If I ever travel, I eat my last meal from them and they are the first meal when I return. Over the decades I have seen them start their relatives out bussing tables, waiting tables, tending the ovens and then on with their lives. They have had the same guy working in the kitchen doing shortorder cooking for this entire time. If you are looking for delicious dinners, sit down and order one of my favorites, tortallini alfredo or my wife’s eggplant rollatini. Cheesesteak with REAL fresh fried bacon and onions… mmmm. The veal, eggplant or chicken parm subs are always great. Every once in awhile I get a pizza that is skimpy on cheese with too much crust showing, but they make so many pies maybe the temp in the oven dropped and the cheese doesn’t melt as far. If you are passing through or a local and want a good delicious deal daily for lunch, get the 2 big slices and a cold Pepsi for $ 4+ tax up until 3 p.m., and they still have a Mon/​Tues special large cheese pie for $ 8.99 + tax. There are I think 3 eat in dinner specials well priced as well every day. Galloway Liquors is a few stores down in the plaza so you can buy beer and wine to enjoy at 2 Brothers who supply wine glass and opener. Forget about those chainstore cardboard pizzas with the prebagged toppings, everything is fresh and made by the guys at 2 Brothers. If I sound like an advertisement it’s because the restaurant and owners staff make a point of remembering your name after just so many times ordering takeout and the place becomes like Cheers! where everybody knows your name.

Best quick lunch in the area. 2 slices of what I think is REALLY good pizza and a soda for $ 4. I know they make their own sauce everyday. Good good for a fair price.

I remeber eating pizza here when I was little it was so good. Depending on how you like your pizza will determine if you like theirs. I thought the pizza was ok. It was crispy well done crust on the thin side… i like my crust soft and gooey but fresh and not over cooked… i like a generous portion of pizza sauce and theirs was lightly coated. I like lots of cheese that is of higher quality… they barely put any cheese. Now i order dinner salads and was disapointed. For five and a half dollars i got mostly iceberg lettuce and a few thinly sliced pieces of cucumber tomsto and white onion. Jojos and joe and johns is better.

Great tasting food and fast service friendly service. We ordered pizza, spaghetti, eggplant parm, and garlic bread.

Just a little hole-​in-​the-​wall Italian place located at the Pomona shopping center. I discovered them close to a year ago and I haven’t looked back.
Pros: The pizza is phenomenal here and it is most definitely some of the best in the area, though they do have a tendency to skimp on the toppings a bit. Hot subs, such as chicken parm, are decent and about on-​par with similar places. I haven’t tried any of their cold subs, so I can’t offer any advice in that department.
Cons: Don’t waste your money on pasta here. I ordered baked ziti once and it was terrible. The sauce clearly came from a large can or jar, the pasta was boiled for far too long and was still very wet despite having been baked, and they used tortiglioni instead of penne, which is more of a personal gripe, I suppose.
Bottom line: If you want Italian takeout (pizza, subs, etc.), this is your place. If you’re looking for a pasta dish or something fancier, order at your own risk.
BONUS TIP: Every Monday and Tuesday, large cheese pizzas are only $ 7.95.

I would order pizza from here during my college days some 15 years ago. In the 4 years I would order from here I honestly never once went to the store… and if its the same as it was then I am glad I didn’t — its very small inside and basically just a counter with a few tables. Not sure if its the same management/​owners etc. as it was then but I made it a point to stop there for lunch today on a trip I had taken into the area.
The pizza was pretty good — nothing special — but far from awful. I am sure if it was a fresh pie vs. a counter slice it would have been even better.
What I loved the most about this place was the prices. It seemed like it was from 15 years ago as well. 2 slices and a can of soda — $ 4.40! That’s a steal these days and was well worth it. I gave them a full additional star just because of their pricing.