NYC Yogurt

I love Frozen Yogurt and would love to try every Frozen Yogurt place! I recently discovered NYC Yogurt. The place was pretty small and honestly it didn’t look the cleanest. Service was decent. Topping were decent. I got the pistachio & salted caramel flavors. These flavors were dead on. Absolutely delicious! I could have had a couple more bowls of that. This is definitely the second best frozen yogurt place I’ve tried in NYC. YoArt in the Plaza is still number one but this place is cheaper and excellent!
Updated: I passed this place the other day and it looks closed. I hope they are just renovating and not closed for good.

We stopped by for a nice afternoon treat. $ 0.59/ounce. Lots of toppings and $ 1 waffle bowls. Very clean. Good customer service. Samples available upon request, but they have to pump it for you.
There are 12 flavors total (not counting the middle pump, which is just a swirl of the flavor on either side of it), but they’re all just the regular olé flavors with the exception of Coconut and Pomegranate Berry.
–Peanut Butter: Good.
–Cake Batter: Meh.
–Cookies ‘n Cream: Even more meh.
–Melba sauce: Tasty. Kind of like a blend of blueberry and raspberry jam.
Good place for a simple froyo fix, but I prefer Red Mango for its more interesting flavors, and Pinkberry because it’s «cute» and not pay-​per-​weight.

Self service prices are always a surprise but yogurt is tasty with unique flavors like salted carmel and graham cracker. Lots of toppings to choose from. Came here on a saturday in late May amd no ONE was in here with us. Surprising but much appreciated after crowds at Times Square.

Great customer service, solid choice of toppings, and rotating selection of choices makes this THE go to fro-​yo spot in the area.

Got Groupon for this deal. Soooo worth it. Must try Kiwi Strawberry and Cake Batter. Actually went over Groupon deal of $ 7 and just paid the additional $ 2.37. Friendly staff. Very quiet. Free wifi. Will def be back. Only issue was that they played ibnoxious Taylor Swift songs the whole time. Aaarghh!

Good service and a wide range of toppings in convenient location at not too expensive a price. However, I felt that the flavors were a little bit off — the cookies & cream and cake batter was minty tasting. The toppings also were slightly stale — the chocolate pretzels were soft and the mochi was really hard. The strawberries didn’t look fresh. Overall, an okay experience, maybe because I went towards the end of the day.

BEST SERVICE EVER for a frozen yogurt place
This location of NYC Yogurt is basically your usual froyo place coupled with VALET service
The young guy at the place was jovile, polite, and above all friendly. THe time I went, he personally introduced all the flavors to me and helped me with sampling. Thanks!
FLAVORS:
Cookies and cream– delicious w/​o being overly sweet
Toasted marshmellow– this is the actual marshmellow but without all the stickiness or the sugery aftertaste. So refreshing!
TOPPPINGS
this is hands-​down the most variety I’ve seen in any froyo places. And if you konw me, I’m the type who eats froyos every week of the year. So, take my word.
Spoiler: they are also surveying customers for new flavors. I def voted for egg nog and gingerbread… hope to see them soon in the store! :P

The original non fat tart was good like Red Mango or Pink Berry. The variety of toppings is okay, didn’t find anything unique but it’s fine as long as they serve mochi. I didn’t see any marsh mellow. What turns me off is the cashier kept chatting with someone while I was waiting to find out the cost. I’d probably stood there for at least 15 seconds before the cashier was done with punching the price. I ended up paying $ 8.55 for less than half a cup with a little mochi and 7 blue berries. I was shocked but paid anyway. I used to pay less than $ 4 for that amount. I didn’t know how it ended that pricey but I didn’t want to go back anymore given the bad service and high price. I still wondered if that cashier wasn’t concentrating or over charged me by mistake.

Yogurt was good and tasty. But they charged me a lot for 2 cups. Double the price I normally would get at Pinkberry or Red Mango. I’m not sure if the cashier made a mistake since he was busy talking to other people while ringing us up. Either way I am disappointed that I got ripped off for paying that much for FroYo

Love the self-​serve concept, love the variety of flavors, like the array of toppings, & LOVE the price! But are you sure this is «frozen yogurt» and not ice-​cream??? This tastes heavy like ice-​cream. Dn’t get me wrong, I love ice-​cream but when I’m trying to be healthy and going for frozen yogurt, I don’t like being duped into downing calories unsuspectingly.
This place is great except for the actual product. Start selling real fro-​yo and I’ll be back.

Great selection of frozen yogurt that’s nicely organized under famous street names. Knobs are blocked as in NYC subway lines — i.e. ABC, 456.
Must try the pistachio and salted caramel — out of this world. Poor service that makes you feel as if they are trying to save money by limiting your samples. But the great tasting yogurt and awesome selection of toppings makes up for that =)
Bottom line: Great tasting yogurt that cancels out the not-​so-​great service.

Much to my chagrin, I was under the impression that there was not a solid frozen yogurt establishment in my new neighborhood (sorry Pinkberry just doesn’t do it for me). Luckily, I soon realized that NYC Yogurt recently opened up! Of course, I had to try it immediately.
The verdict: It’s pretty good. The inside is cute with all the subway paraphernalia. There are a couple of tables. The frozen yogurt itself is tasty. Some of the flavors were better than others. I did not think the Salted Caramel tasted much like its namesake – it was closer to a demented peanut butter. I enjoyed the cake batter a lot. The toasted marshmallow was tasty.
I’m docking it a star because I specifically mentioned Unilocal at the cash register since their page suggested that that would grant me a 20% discount. No such luck. The guy looked at me like I was an imbecile. Oh well. I really could have used to catch a break today. Better luck next time…

Ok so i’m not a New Yorker, I come from a small city in Australia.
We have 4 flavors at my nearest frozen yogurt place so I really liked NYC Yogurt.
They have a good range of flavors and an even better range of toppings! Reasonably priced per weight too.

This place is half a block from my office and will most likely become a summer staple. It’s located right next door to Toastie’s or across the street from Hale & Hearty on 49^th Street.
They have about 16 different flavors and an open toppings bar. They charge by weight so you can load that 16oz cup sky high, but you’ll pay for it. It’s $ 0.48 per ounce if I recall correctly.
I mixed my fro-​yo flavors and added quite a few toppings and it only came to $ 6.55. If you work in the area be sure to mention it because they offer a small discount.

The only reason why it has 2 stars instead of 1 is because the people serving there are awesome. They greet you very nicely and are helpful in serving you (and they are very open to suggestions on the menu/​toppings that they may be missing).
I LOVE MOCHI, and can make it myself, so when I say the mochi here ABSOLUTELY SUCKS, I mean it – the texture is not chewy at all, but more of a chalky hard piece of I-don’t-know-what. The balance of flour, water and sugar has not been achieved here.
If you have never tried boba poppers (filled with fruit juice), I’d recommend trying some for fun — the flavors available when I went were passionfruit and strawberry.
Now — on to the main thing, the froyo. The froyo kind of tastes just like ice cream — and don’t let the name «frozen yogurt» make you believe that these are «healthier alternatives» to ice cream (it is probably around the same) unless you get the plain or sherbert flavors (which happen to be very tart).
Tried the cookie dough as well — also not a giant fan of it :(
All in all, I was excited to try it, but probably will stick to Pinkberry/​Red Mango.

Just what we needed in this area! 8 different flavors! yum! and its only 59 cents an ounce! n the toppings bar is awesome! Mini gummy bears. So cool!

Finally: a true contender for the best frozen yogurt in the city to beat 16 Handles.
They only have 12 handles here, but the flavors are so much better. I think there were only one or two throwaway fruity flavors here, unlike a lot of the other chains that waste too many flavors on that nonsense. But every flavor here was great: Peanut Butter, Dulce De Leche, NY Cheesecake, Cake Batter, Red Velvet, Toasted Marshmallow, Coffee, Cookies & Cream, and your classic Chocolate and Vanilla flavors.
The yogurt here is so good it reminds me of that Seinfeld episode where they realize that the yogurt they love so much is really not healthy at all. The «premium» flavors I tried (such as Red Velvet) were so good they must be bad for you, but who cares. They don’t have the nutrition facts posted here next to each flavor like at other places, but I think that’s a good thing.
Another pitfall of most new places is the lack of toppings, but this place has easily overcome that. There is a huge selection of toppings that covers just about all bases. They have the normal old stuff like Oreos and chopped up Almonds and candy bars, as well as some more out there stuff, like Nerds and Mets Sprinkles (just blue and orange sprinkles). The one thing I did see missing though that I would have liked was some good old chopped peanuts, but the almonds were good enough.
My only real gripe is the chintzy samples the guy doles out. I just wish they would give out sample cups like they do at most other places so I could run wild instead of having to feel ashamed as I ask the guy for sample after sample.
This one happens to be in a pretty unfortunate location, on a strange side street right near the midtown theater district and tourist wasteland of Times Square. I was very excited though to learn that they are opening TWO new locations in the frozen yogurt-​starved Financial District.
I am not around this area that often, but I will definitely be frequenting the new downtown locations constantly once they open up in the next few months.