Maya Blue

Can’t possibly give this place a good score– It’s delivery only & has the same EXACT address on seamless as Braised, Butcher Block, Bushwick, ‘Leafage and Authentic. I am sure there are others. All listed with the address of 146 East 44^th Street — WHAT’S GOING ON HERE? Orders beware!

Horrible. If they spent more money on the quality of ingredients instead of the packaging it might be mediocre at best. However this food isn’t edible for a dog. Not to mention the delivery took over an hour so I basically got a plate of cold wet mud

Ordered on seamless, got the confirmation so the restaurant had the order. Food never came and no one picked up the phone.

Super great! I got this for lunch the other day and the quinoa bowls are delicious. It is a bit expensive but it’s a good treat! They delivered my meal quickly too :)

The food they delivered is inedible. I spoke with the floor manager, and I told her all the food looked and tasted like it had been made a few days ago. She told me that was what I ordered and they would not offer any solution. I just had to order from another restaurant. Their customer service was actually worse than the food.

Maya Blue has been mine and my colleagues go to for lunch in the office. Their food is amazing, they have great delivery time and they have fantastic healthy options. Always fresh. One time, the order was lacking romaine (I know. silly, but I was used to getting the same amount), I called and spoke to the manager who had a new bowl sent out right away. What great all around service and satisfaction of the food. We have decided that we need to stop in to the actual restaurant for margaritas soon. Thanks for always being on point Maya Blue.

In all honesty, probably the best quesadilla I’ve ever had. The salsas are great as well, and their delivery time for group orders is very good.

So in honor of cinco de mayo I ordered tacos for lunch from Maya Blue on seamless. I didn’t know what to expect. I was very pleased with the swift and pleasant delivery. My three soft tacos were inside each labelled so I actually knew what I was eating. They threw in a free bag of chips and salsa which was super cool in my book. Chips tasted fresh and salsa was tasty. I ordered the Adobe brisket con queso which was cooked nicely with cilantro, habanero corn, cotija, and jalapeño aioli on s soft tortilla. The smokiness of the brisket and the tenderness of the meat worked beautifully with the rest of the taco. The beef is grass fed and very clean tasting. Next was the crock pot al pastor. Berkshire pork marinated in pineapple & chili, with jalapeño pineapple relish, cilantro, cotija, red onion, and line aioli on a soft corn taco. Might be my favorite. The juxtaposition of sweet and salty was a grand slam to me. Lastly I had the chorizo con picante. Grilled chorizo with poblano pepper, cilantro, red onion, and line aioli on soft corn tortilla. I liked the chorizo but I liked the brisket more. Maya Blue is big on sourcing responsibly so if your into that it’s an added plus. I will definitely order from here again and more fully explore the menu. Not sure how I missed this place but I plan on making up for lost time. Woo hoo!

Tacos are dry and tiny. Do NOT get the Peking Duck taco — it’s weirdly seasoned (too much chive, I think) and doesn’t pair well with the corn taco. Shrimp was ok, but avoid duck at all costs. I’m a fan of the salsa and chips delivery comes with, though!

Nooo coments on this

the food is fantastic but what is up with the hours this restaurant is opened? Closed on a Friday night?

Order: Make your own quesadilla and a banarera smoothie. Presentation is great, very tasty. Price point is high, but its okay, you pay for homemade preparation.
One minus, it took 1hr 20 mins to get the order and quesadilla was luke warm.

I’ve only had delivery from here so this is reflective of that:
Overpriced. $ 55 for 3 lunches.
Took too long, over 1.5 hours for early lunch (ordered at 11)
Over packaged=Bad for the environment.
Forgot items on my order.
Shrimp tacos were dry and tasteless
Create your own salad, kale was over cooked.
Chicken salad was delicious and good portion size.
Lemonade was bland, tasted like flavored water.
Chips & salsa was good.
I really wanted to like this place but SO NOT WORTH the price.

Really fresh and good Mexican food in Midtown. Only have had the delivery so far, but it was an enjoyable meal and I’d definitely try them again.
Tried the build your own burrito and the carne taco. Both were well made with very good flavor. Side of hot sauces were just right.

I’ve been ordering from here for the past two weeks … the burrito bowls are amazing. I’ve had the chicken breast and shrimp. Chips and Salsa on the side, YUM. excellent lunch spot in midtown!

I’ve had Maya Blue few times via seamless, so this is my review as a delivery restaurant, not a visit to the establishment (yet). Too many aspects to review, so this is why I’m giving them 3 stars:
Food Taste: FIVE STARS! Food is very good! I love the flavors. Please keep in mind that this is not an average street food joint, but what they do with ingredients is very creative. My personal favorite is Peking Duck taco, and I know, you might be making a «what?!» face, but I lived the majority of my life in northern Mexico, and some of the Chinese food restaurants in Mexico (Mexicali has the largest population of Chinese in Mexico) it is common to eat Peking Duck with a corn tortilla… so it’s not Mexican, but at least is how Mexicans eat Peking Duck! (got it?). Bottom line, Food might not be 100% authentic, but has a great flavor.
Delivery: Two stars. Here is my issue… tacos aren’t meant to be delivered/​takeout. The results are soggy, cold food. It’s a disappointment because tacos aren’t cheap, so the last thing you want is to eat cold food.
Price: They’re expensive. I love the food flavor but +$ 4 each taco is bit too much. If they were bit cheaper and ensure a quick delivery, I would be order from there more often. I understand that they only use local ingredients, etc. It’s the price to pay, but too often gets too expensive (like everything in this city).
Overall: 3 stars, food is great but still need better execution of delivery standards.

The tacos are to DIE FOR. Each bite is filled with meat and deliciousness, you can order like 10 different hot sauces. This farm –to-​table joint is really the cats meow. Plus, they put a bag of chips and salsa in every bag!
Even though they messed up my order, and it came 2 hours late, I’m giving them 5 stars because they’re newbies and were absolutely delightful on the phone.

For some reason I feel like I’ve ordered from this place before… but maybe that’s just my memory playing tricks on me. Apparently this is a new Mexican place that opened up in midtown. I opted for a very simple option in ordering the Scoville Salmon salad on Seamless. It’s $ 15.00…which is pretty pricey. But I will say that their focus is on locally and «responsibly-​sourced» ingredients. Small snippets from their menu include cage-​free chicken, grass-​fed beef, berkshire pork… all of them from notable farms. The salmon was actually pretty small and average at best on the flavor side. BUT the veggies were delicious– everything from the artichokes to brussel sprouts was fresh as can be. I’m happy I ordered from there. but it remains to be seen whether this can be a consistent day-​to-​day lunch option.
I just ordered 4 of their tacos though, so a follow up review coming soon.