Chirios Pizza

One of the worst pizza I have had the displeasure of introducing to my taste buds. Substandard flavor on a cracker-​like crust that had blackened burned portion on bottom — Also waited 2 hours for this culinary delight.

Have been eating here over the last 4 years and it’s consistently great. The pizza crust, to me is the best. Love the white Greek pizza with chicken. Amazing.
I have read some of the other reviews and it’s true the wait times can be rather long. But it’s worth the wait. Nellysford is a small town that is all about relaxing and taking it slow. Just breathe.

Here is a link to their website & menu:
I guess this place doesn’t want to mess with the bother of a grease trap or whatever they call those things, because in all the years we’ve lived here, they have never had fries on the menu & say they never will. That is the most annoying thing about this place, mostly because they don’t offer quality chips to make up for it – only lousy ones. If you are a subs & pizza joint without fries on the menu, at least offer quality chips, please.
Fav here: The Bonecrusher sub, and their ham & cheese croissant. They have thin crust pizza with some interesting toppings on offer. Their service is usually quite slow, but they are the only local eatery that will actually deliver on a good day. See above for their menu link, if you need it.

We used to like Chirio’s subs and sandwiches, but the service kept getting slower and sloooower, with more confused orders. Last time we ordered 2 sandwiches and they somehow forgot one after waiting for half hour. Seriously?
There is a room with tables at the back so you can wait and wait and wait…

Love this place and have been coming here for years. Great hot subs. The owner is a super nice guy. They serve Inexpensive delicious pizza.

I get that one shouldn’t expect good exceptionally quick at places other than McD’s, but Chirios should be renamed Molasses. We’ve eaten there twice and the wait was absurd in both cases. Over 45 minutes to make three hot sandwiches is just ridiculous. And they don’t always get the orders right either.
Food is decent, but not even close to good enough to justify this.

Chirios Pizza has consistently delivered great pizza and sandwiches. We Orders can be slow, but this is partly because the owner rolls out the pizza dough for each order. We typically put an order for pick up as soon as we get off Interstate 64, timing usually works well. The owner is almost always there and has been since the 80’s.

My husband and I stumbled upon this place while staying at a nearby B & B. We placed our order at the counter and were given an approximate wait time for our food to be prepared. The set up is typical local deli style — don’t expect fast food turn around times. There is a small dining area for those who wish to eat there. It has small tables and chairs and may not be the most comfortable — we placed our order to go. One cool thing about the dining area is that there are shelves & shelves of books! The place serves as a book swap, so you can take a book, trade books, or leave a book. There is also free wifi.
Now to the best part — the food! I had the Greek sub and it was one of the best sandwiches I have ever had. Perfectly done! If I lived close by, this would probably become a favorite of mine.

Best veggie pizza ever! Ask for a little «hot» on it for some added zing. Try the open-​faced Recovery, #5…yummy! The Bonecrusher, #2, rocks! Sometimes it does get hectic, but they are always upfront about how long the wait will be.

The worst service! Called in an order for three large pizzas and two salads… was told it would be 1hour. Okay. So we waited. And waited. Only to receive a call back from the restaurant, well AFTER an hour, stating they were just leaving to delivery the food. Worst part was whomever called had a TON of attitude. No apologies for the extended delay, no concession, nothing. Oh, and then basically hung up. Pizza was terrible and cold. A lot of money for poor service and bad food. Do not make the same mistake… especially if there are hungry kids in your group.

Pizza is comfort food for the gods. Chirio’s Pizza is done right in the New York style with thin crust. The owner of this local pizza place has great humor. This place serves hot dogs, salads, hot & cold subs. The sandwiches are not bad too. For your sweet tooth, Chirio’s has 15 different flavors of ice cream to choose from. And the prices are very reasonable.
Food B
Staff B
Décor D
Location D

Great NY thin crust. Best local, friendly atmosphere.WIFI. Love the food, love the people.
Visited again on Columbus Day. Still friendly, not good atmosphere, sweltering, out of IT sausage, pizza underdone. Was really looking forward to a repeat