Smart Cookie Company

It’s all about the sugar cookie with the cream cheese frosting. The workers are also really nice. Me gusta.

I got the cinnamon and the almond cookie. They were pretty average run of the mill cookies. Rubynap I’m SLC is much better.

Their cookies are good! I would go back and try some more!

The rootbeer float is really good and so are the cookies! Also every time I go there the employees seem really friendly. Nice place.

Had a chocolate chip toffee cookie and it was very good. It was sort and flavorful. The worker didn’t seem to happy about being there, but overall very good.

Way too much frosting on their sugar cookies. The milk chocolate toffee cookies are fantastic, but they rarely have any left when I go. For these reasons, I only give them 3 stars.

Stop what you are doing and go buy a cookie! Absolutely delish. I have had their chocolate chip, toffee chocolate chip and a giant sugar cookie covered in cream cheese frosting. I would highly recommend this place for a sweet tooth fix! Reasonable prices too, it was only $ 4 for 3 cookies. You can also order ice cream and coffee. Go now!

We didn’t really think this place was that great. We tried a lemon and red velvet cookie. Pretty standard. If you want better cookies from a place that makes cookies, go to RubySnap, they’re so much fresher and tastier.

I’ve had a lot of friends recommend this place to me, so I decided to give it a try. The décor is hilarious, a bunch of photos of geniuses which I’m sure is where he name must have came from. The girl behind the founder was very nice, I got myself a ice cream sandwich, it was giant, i could not finish it. It was very good, but the oatmeal raisin cookie that I got with my sandwich was very stale and hard to eat, so I instead ate my chocolate chip cookie and some of my cookies and cream ice cream that was inside. Only negative was that stale cookie, other than that great place!

Love love love Smart Cookie! It’s my go-​to dessert spot. Cookie sandwiches are huge, so I usually go with 1 cookie and a scoop of ice cream. Even better since they started using Leatherby’s ice cream. Also, the sugar cookies are some of the best around.
However, I’m always super annoyed when I show up a half hour before closing and the employees act like I showed up as they’re locking the doors. Sorry I’m stopping you from closing early, but I want my cookie! It’s not big, but it’s happened to me many times.

Get the icecream sandwich. Icecream and cookie selection would suit any taste. Cookie was not as fresh as I might have hoped, but I guess you truly never can have it all.

Stopped in after a movie. Ordered a box of frosted and non frosted cookies. Staff was friendly. Husband commented as he ate a frosted red velvet cookie «this is weird. This cookie has no flavor. Might as well be a sugar cookie.» The cookies were just ok. We both thought the cookies at the cookie shop in most local malls here (that’s been around for 25+ years) had better flavor and more options.

There’s plenty here to love. You’ve got your cookies. You’ve got your shakes. You’ve got your ice cream. You’ve got a few combinations of all those ingredients. So I’m not going to have much negative to say.
For $ 3.25 I got two cookies with ice cream in between. I wish the cookies had been a little softer, because you clamp your mouth over it to bite in and all you get is ice cream squeezed out of the sides. As a sandwich it didn’t really work. But c’mon. Ice cream. Cookies. Just eat them.
As cookies go, there are better in town. These are a little flatter and more traditional than other bakeries. Except the sugar/​frosting ones. Those are big and tall. I do wish they were softer, too. But you can’t have everything.
Go in and get a cookies. Catch a movie before or after. Get some ice cream. You’re not going to regret it, if that’s what you’re wondering. Because chocolate and sugar.

It’s a fifty-​fifty split. Enjoyed the Almond cookie (perfect after an evening of spicy Thai food), but didn’t really appreciate the semi-​sweet chocolate chip and toffee cookie. The almond cookie wasn’t overly sweet, had plenty of flavor and a nice soft texture. I expected more toffee flavor out of the choco-​toffee cookie but it just didn’t come out that much. I guess I could consider the cookie jar as half full on this one.

Great cookies! I try to save half for later, but that never happens. Try the cinnamon; AMAZING!

I stopped in here for the first time last night with my family after a movie and was so impressed. Good prices, friendly staff and the cookies are incredible. The ice cream sandwich is big enough to share and only $ 3.25. You can pick what kind of cookie and choose from several flavors of ice cream. The lemon drop cookie was so good I want to go back!

Friendly. Good prices. Not a fan of the frosted cookies but a BIG fan of the nice variety of unfrosted cookies.
And you can sneak them into the theatre super easy!

So good! The ice cream sandwiches are a good price (3.25) and are big enough to share.

Smart Cookie Company is by far the best cookie bakery in existence. I’ve had cookies in almost every state from Alaska to New York to Hawaii to Florida. Nothing beats a Smart Cookie!
This place is pure deliciousness! In fact, Smart Cookie is the only cookie I prefer to one of my own homemade treats!
Every time I enter the doors in Fort Union and the miraculous scent wafting about the air hits me, my heart skips a beat. I panic and think, «Perhaps these cookies aren’t as delicious as I remember. Maybe I am only remembering them as God’s gift to cookie lovers everywhere because I don’t have treats that often.» Absence makes the heart grow fonder, right?
Then I take a bite and every doubt I have is washed away.
They are every bit as delectable as only one’s wildest imagination can conjure… crack for the cookie lover. I’ve even recruited more than my fare share of addicts — you few dozen folks know who you are.
My family always has me bring them a dozen when I fly home to Ohio. In fact, I had to ship some home for my sister’s bridal shower and bachelorette party!
The selection is great amongst the gourmet sugar cookies — sugar, lemon, almond, and cinnamon are the four you can always find in various shapes reflecting the time of year. Then, they often have a chocolate mint, red velvet, chocolate ganache, Chocolate Vanilla, and more. My personal favorite is the straight-​up sugar cookie with cream cheese frosting.
Their traditional gourmet cookies are also the tops from Peanut Butter to Milk or Dark Chocolate Toffee to snickerdoodles to traditional chocolate chip.
The thing most folks like to do before or after a movie is get the ice cream sandwiches they offer — hand-​scooped ice cream in about 12 different flavors smooshed between two of their traditional cookies of your choice. Yum! Just want a cookie and milk? No problem!
You can also find a variety of drinks like frozen hot chocolate and Italian sodas, but I’ve only tried the frozen hot chocolate once, so I can’t attest to how yummy their drink selection is.
I do often have to clarify to newbies that «Smart Cookie» does not mean Smart as in Healthy — it means Smart as in eating this deliciosity is the smartest thing you will ever do.
I have always found the staff very helpful and extremely patient with patrons trying to decide their cookie flavors, amounts, and ice cream flavors — it can be laborious, but they tend to everyone with smiles on their faces. They have met every special request I have asked of them — individually wrapping cookies, extra boxes, etc.
For a deal, you can always find coupons in the Savings books OR just go when they open and they always sell packages of their day-​old cookies for about half price. I promise you, they are just as delicious the next day.
They take orders for large events, which I recommend if you want more than two dozen.
The only downside? I get a sugar coma every time.
If you haven’t had Smart Cookie, you haven’t lived. Try it. Now.

Yep. Still a five star establishment. Wanted to throw a shout of to Nichole P. for putting in her two cents. I believe what she was trying to say was…
The little angels workers who tirelessly work day in and day out delivering only the finest ingredients that will ultimately culminate on our tongue take the bountiful gift from the man upstairs known here on earth as vanilla ice cream and strategically place them upon a bed of utter bliss aka a chocolate chip cookie. To add to the amazingness of it all they then grab another chocolate chip cookie and lay it upon the cream thus delivering an explosion of deliciousness as it twirls and dances upon your tongue with each bite.
Yeah, that was what I thought she meant.
Place is still awesome. Still a great value. Recently Ive been sticking to the same cookie for both the up and downstairs of my ‘which. Nice change up and provides a delicious consistent flavor. Oh, and the red velvet cookie. OMG that ‘ish CRAY!