Waterstone Pizza

Best pizza in the world. We’ve compared it to other highly praised pizza places and Waterstone always beats them. Great place for either casual or fancy. The cheesecake is amazing too!

The atmosphere is great. Music is a little loud at lunch, but not a huge deal. The food is very good. I like the Federal. All the pizzas are delicious. I really like the club sandwich, too.

Waterstone has the best pizzas! I love going here for a romantic dinner date or getting a bite with my girl friends. The atmosphere is great and the price is reasonable. I once tried their lunch special which was eggplant spaghetti and it was delicious! I cannot wait to go back again.

My wife and I LOVE Waterstone! The pizza is obviously what they are known for and it becomes very evident why once you try it. The atmosphere is very cool on the inside of this old building with the exposed rock walls. We always enjoy our experience here. The only con I would say is how loud it gets when the restaurant Is full, but hey we can handle a little noise for the quality of food and service you get!

The pizza and beer are awesome! It is really cool that everything is made in the same building. The bartenders are great, and the manager was joking with me giving this place a relaxed atmosphere.

I had a salad, and it was everything a man could ask for. The pizza here is also very good. This is not your ordinary pizza place, its chef run, and worth facing the busy crowd to enjoy the food.

This is the second time we have been here, I must say that this is a 5 star in food, service,
The music selection is good and not too loud but loud enough so that you do not overhear your neighbors.
This is a very classy joint … Chris our server was on top of it she knew what we wanted and how we wanted it.
Service, management etc. are all 5 stars
Thank you for a great lunch and a great dining experence

Really good food.
Quality ingredients and the pizza is amazingly flavorful.
Service can be lacking sometimes, but you can’t win them all.
Overall this place is amazing!

The atmosphere is nice, the beer is good, service excellent but I’m kind of spoiled with Dr. Ho’s and even Christian’s Pizza!

Always a favorite for a Friday night in Lynchburg. Classy dining. While on the pricier side, the quality of pizza is probably the best around.

This place, the environnent, the pizza, the beer choices… Literally everything here was so excellent. I felt like I couldn’t have asked for anything to be better. The pizza is so fresh, and brick-​oven baked. You can watch them do it, and it only adds to the charm. I went to this place 2 years ago and my mouth still waters, wishing I could once again experience a little slice of heaven.
I can’t remember the name of the pizza we got, but I took pics, as shown. I am big on quality cheese, fresh toppings, vegetables (which can sometimes lend to a soggy crust), but this pizza was perfect. It was so fun trying a flight of their beers too, and unfortunately I am writing this review 2 years after visiting so I don’t recall which beers we tried, but rest assured I had no complaints.
*Always keep in mind when ordering beers that some people prefer IPA/​hoppy beers vs Hefeweisen style or stouts… I do prefer Hefeweisen’s so I steer clear of hoppy blends or IPA, and this keeps me happy. I will try IPA every once in awhile just to keep it real lol. Order what makes you happy.

Love love love this place! Excellent service, excellent pizza amazing beer! Visit every time we are in Lynchburg.

This is a nice place to hang when you’re in town. Cool old building with a ton of character, low key attire makes it very comfortable. The staff was friendly and they have a pile of good local beers on tap. Food was good, not great. I had the supreme pizza that was plenty of food for one person. The desserts were okay but they do not have espresso (which I crave after a full meal). Worth the stop!

I ordered carryout to take back to my hotel room.
The pizza (an Italian Stallion) was tasty, as was the giant pretzel.
Price wise things were a little high, it was almost $ 30 for the pizza and pretzel. Their pies only come in one size which would be about a medium at most places.
They were super busy so I chose to get carryout. Took about 30 minutes to make my pie, and in the mean time no one really told me where to wait or what to do. I hovered near the door, but felt out of place there too as I was asked on three occasions if I’d like to be put on the list for a table. I suppose it’s better to be over helpful that under helpful.
If the price was a bit lower this is a four star review. Might have gotten the fifth based on service had it been a dine in experience.

I loved this place!!! I came here by myself last night after a long day of being in class for an intensive at LU. I was immediately seated at the bar and both bartenders were very attentive to my needs. I got the honey wheat ale (it’s so good) and the four cheese pizza. My pizza came out so quick but was cooked to perfection. It was huge too and only $ 10.95. Atmosphere was fun and they had 3 big TV’s showing all the great college games on that night. I loved the energy of this place and I can’t wait to come back the next time I’m in town for another intensive. Highly recommended

Had a great dinner here recently. Started with the crab dip, which my date said was delicious, though I am not really into crab dip! I ordered a Greek salad to start. It was a huge portion and full of feta and other goodness.
For dinner, we order a pizza. It was a thin, crispy crust. Every bite was amazingly yummy. For dessert, I wanted the brownie sundae. Well, this dessert is definitely for sharing, maybe 3 – 4 people. The two of us did not finish it my any means. But it was tasty!
Service was prompt and courteous. Definitely enjoyed this place!

Casual elegance is how I’d describe this restaurant. Interesting architecture and attention to detail makes it great. Wood fired pizza makes the crusty crispy them add in a variety of toppings and choices made this a good choice. Looks like they have a great bar as I’ve seen some pretty drinks go by. Too bad we’re rushing to the airport.
If I’m ever back in Lynchburg I’m dining here again!

I’ve been 4 times since they opened and have never found anything good. Pizza is soggy and the angel hair pasta I had on my most recent visit was overdone. Almost like it was microwaved or left sitting in hot water for way too long. Beer is bland and not on the same level as any other local brewery. The wait to be seated is almost unbearable and they don’t even seem that busy.
Am I unlucky, or just don’t get it?

Great local beer on tap (especially their pale ale). Their salads are equally satisfying as their pizzas. They are a bit of a ways off main st., and I would have never come here if it weren’t for word of mouth. I’ve glad I found this place!

Went the other night on a date…
Very nice atmosphere,
Pretty packed, but not way too loud,
Great service, wish I could remember her name.
Food was excellent,
Great drinks,
Very clean bathrooms…
My date is extremely well traveled and said its the best pizza he’s ever had.
My dad also loved it, and so did I.
Build your own pizza! And get goat cheese :) it doesn’t come from cows that have been eating Monsanto’s genetically modified corn… Plus it’s delicious.
Great spot. 5*s