Antonio’s Pizza Pasta & Wings

This is our go to pizzeria. We moved from NYC/​NJ and have a very particular taste when it comes to pizza and wings; we’ve tried the other places around and I have to say I like this place the best.
It seems as though many places around here are chains… And I like that Antonios is a small family owned pizzeria. I found that customer service is much more different than the larger places around.
Their pizza is ⁴⁄₅ stars; I would actually like to see a tad bit more sauce but it’s still flavorful and crisp just like it should be. They also slice the pizza (dare I say it?) the way it should be. I’m glad I can easily fold it and hold it with one hand… I know that’s an odd thing to comment on.
The hot traditional wings are also nice and HOT! Yes!!! Oh and they aren’t these tiny little things either! They are normal sized wings!
The mozzarella sticks– this unfortunately I cannot «rave» about; they just seem like frozen mozzarella sticks you get from wegmans.
We’ve only gone to pick up so I can’t speak about delivery but I will say that we will continue to order from them since their customer service is worth noting as well as their pizza!

I would like to make a correction to my last review.
After talking with Eat Street and Antonio’s we have discovered that it was OUR mistake. I placed the order and payed for it. My wife went to pick it up, and she payed for it. Hence the double charge. Oops. That was our mistake.
Still, Jason was awesome. He correct the error immediately. Also, Eat Street did their due diligence to help us solve the mystery.

I grew up in Liverpool. Used to wash their dishes for free slices sometimes at close. Best pizza across the nation worth pit stopping on when I return home.

Ordered from here tonight for the first and last time. We got a small white pizza, two orders of wings (one hot, one garlic, and onion peels. The pizza was dry and bland. I’ve had far more flavorful white pizza. This tasted like something that came from the freezer section at Wegmans. We also ordered our wings extra extra crispy. I don’t order them that way for my health. I order them that way because I want them extra crispy. I don’t understand why that’s such a hard concept for an establishment that specializes in pizza and wings. The garlic wings were ok other than not being crispy. On the other hand, the hot wings were atrocious. The sauce was incredibly hot but also strangely sweet. A classic hot wing sauce should be nothing but Frank’s or some other similar sauce and butter. Antonios also offers a hot BBQ so I thought maybe I had gotten those by accident. I called to see if this had happened and was informed that their hot sauce had BBQ in it. Why??! Just why??! When I order hot wings I expect a classic buffalo not a hot sauce with BBQ in it. Not to mention why would you put BBQ in the hot sauce when you have a hot BBQ already on the menu? This makes zero sense. If an establishment is going to alter what they call hot sauce to any other flavor than classic buffalo it should state so clearly on the menu. Otherwise, it’s false advertisement and leads to disappointment.
There’s better pizza to be had at Pizza Villa and far better wings at The Endzone or Cobblestone. I would not waste my money here for bland pizza and disgustingly flavored wings. It was a total waste of $ 40 and ended up having to crisp my wings in the oven. That is not acceptable.

I can definitely back up the owner who has a lower review claiming that the pizza in the pictures is not his. It definitely isn’t. That really poor review is definitely a scam.
So, I was hunting on Unilocal to try a local pizza place. I really like the convenience of ordering online, so on the rare occasions I do order pizza, it often ends up at one of the chains.
I was excited to see that I could order online right through Unilocal,but I was worried online ordering can often be a bit difficult for small businesses to execute well.
I have to say, this was a great experience all around. I really went into it not expecting anything since I haven’t tried their pizza or online ordering through Unilocal before, and in fact, was kind of anticipating something to go wrong. Not the case at all.
I was surprised by Antonio’s large menu; I’ll definitely order again. The pizza was definitely really decent, not greasy at all, the crust wasn’t overly hard or crunchy, slices were even, appropriate topping coverage, flavor tasted just like pizza. All good in my book.
I also ordered mild boneless wings, which instead of being nuggety like I expected were more like small chicken tenders that were breaded and tossed in sauce. They tasted great and were a large serving.
The order was delivered promptly with no issues and the delivery driver was friendly. I will definitely order from this place again.

You don’t know what you got til its gone. One of the best pizza places I’ve been to nationwide is this shop known once as the Liverpool Pizzeria. I traveled 3000 miles to go to the NY state fair and take a trip to Niagara Falls and picked up a pizza. My favorite is chicken wing aka buffalo wing pizza. They don’t make this out west at all. This place beat out another big establishment nearby by a mile in terms of pizza. I tried a slice from both. You have to give Antonio’s a try.

Definitely one of the better pizza places in Liverpool. Try the breaded garlic parmesan wings!

Gave these guys a shot, as we’ve run out of decent pizza options in the area. They have online ordering, which is a plus, and really decent prices. I was super-​duper surprised that a large one topping pizza and garlic wings was only $ 23 with no hidden fees (maybe $ 2 delivery was in there, but not on top of the $ 23). That may still sound high, but I don’t think it is for a delivered meal like that.
The delivery was very prompt, the pizza was extremely flavorful and delightfully thin — the kind you see in NYC. We did broccoli on top, which was large, fresh florettes rather than chopped up nasty frozen bit like other unmentionable places where they «treat you like family.» The wings were crispy and tasty, with a nice garlic flavor.
We’ll definitely repeat… I hope they stick around, because it seems like whenever we settle on a place, they either close or change things up. Oh — we ordered everything well done, (pizza well done and wings crispy), so maybe that was the problem the other reviewer from November had.

Don’t order from this place. It took me an hour to get the wrong order, an hour and a half more to get the right order but it was cold and nasty. I called the store, and they didn’t care. The dough felt pretty undercooked and they sent me cold fried mushrooms, which are impossible to reheat. They talked to me like an idiot on the phone. Go elsewhere.