Pepperoni’s PIzza and Subs

I ordered the cheese steak, spaghetti and meatballs, a calzone and grilled chicken salad last night (Friday) for take out. The lady on the phone was very nice and our order was correct. So, we’re off to a great start. My wife loved her salad. The spaghetti and meatballs were OKAY, and fine for my son. The sauce tasted canned, but the meatballs were tender. Thankfully the meal came with garlic cheese bread that we loved, The cheese steak was the shining star of the meal. I would recommend ordering it.
I have been to Pepperonis for lunch before and I love their slices of pizza. They can be ready quickly and the price is right. Bring your lady to lunch, order a couple slices and split a cheese steak. You wont be disappointed.

I’ve only gotten food here once and opted for carry out during the lunch rush on a weekday. My eggplant parm sub was perfect and customer service was lovely. It’s hard to find a variety of vegetarian options around here. I’ll definitely go back for more.
Update: I’ve been back for pizza twice. I had great service each visit and it is the best pizza I’ve ever had in southern MD. Crust was perfect for a hand tossed style, the sauce was noticeable but not overpowering, and the cheese was just the right amount of greasy. Perfect! They even gave me $ 3 off one day because of a «coupon» that they said they had but I was oblivious about.

I have just visited this place for the first time. I had this incredibly nice lady serve me and checked up on me to see if I needed anything else! I didn’t try the pizza but I fell in love with their colzone!!! No ricotta cheese!!! Just loads of mozzarella! I am definitely coming back!

Still a four-​star review, two years later. Although other reviewers have mentioned problems with customer service, I’ve never had issues there. I normally order for carry-​out, though, so I’m not sure if that’s the difference. The pizza is still possibly the best in the area, and we enjoy picking up a pizza or two for social gatherings when we have them. Lots of cheese, a good chewy crust, and the pizza is always gone quickly (because we eat it fast because it tastes good).

This place does the trick if you just want a simple slice and soda in a pinch. It’s okay. Not great. Not bad. Just… average.
One thing that is very below average is the customer service! I’ve been there a handful of times and it seems that every time, I am bothering them with my patronage. There are never any «thank you’s, have a good day’s», the usual stuff you’re supposed to hear when you’re a customer.
So, if you’re looking for mediocre pizza and to feel like a burden to a staff, then Pepperoni’s is the place for you!

Overpriced, mediocre food, watered down fountain drinks, and a staff with terrible attitudes — no concept of customer service. I constant go out out of my way to support small business but after two times of going there and saying to myself, «the food and service will get better,» I’ve come to the conclusion that it won’t. Stick with Ledo or Nicolleti’s Pizza.

Went here over the holidays. My mom and I, both NJ natives, tried the white pizza with green apples and feta and it was absolutely delicious, even by NJ standards. I’m not a huge fan of white pizza in general but this one was delicious and my mom (who loves white pizza) said it was the best she’d had. There were small holes on the bottom, as the reviewer below mentioned, but I’m pretty sure that’s just from the pizza screens they use. I thought the crust was flavorful and the ingredients were fresh. I also think it’s uncommon (and awesome) for a delivery place to offer seasonal gourmet-​style options like green apples. Will definitely come back when I’m in the Morgantown area.

I had ordered from here twice and my first pizza was good. The cheese and sauce had a nice flavor and consistency. They are missing something in their crust though it just did not taste right and had an odd consistency. My second pizza was over cooked and dried out, but edible.
I agree with Erin E. this place has potential.

This place seems to be hit or miss. I’ve always been satisfied with their pizzas, but the subs are usually sub-​par. The chicken parm sub was gross, but the cheese steak is amazing MOST of the time. Really sucks because I wish there were more good cheese steak places down here, and this place has potential.

If you grew up in NY or NJ (like me) you know pizza should have a crust with a light fluffy texture, rich tomato sauce, excellent cheese and olive oil! The pizza here seems to have crust that is pre-​purchased with hundreds of tiny holes across the bottom (to expedite cooking?) and a taste similar to cardboard. The sauce and cheese are average and there is a slight taste of olive oil. The usual toppings can be added. And it’s pricey! I can say it compares favorably to the pizza in the Walmart deli area, but it is about 3 times more expensive. I am still searching for a really good NY style pizza in southern Maryland!