Piezanos Pizza

My family and I are new to the Piezanos Pizza experience. We had our first taste when they catered a local family event late this summer; the pizzas (a large variety) were fresh, hot, and delicious. We have now ordered from them a couple of times for delivery and once for pickup. No one ever wants the same toppings in our house so we’ve tried quite a few of their specialty pies and created a couple of our own.
First, the staff: Always friendly and professional. They tend to be very busy multitasking in store so I can see where some single-​perspective reviewers could misinterpret the staffs’ interactions as «short» or even «rude» but I have never been uptight enough to take them as anything other than very popular. When they do happen to have a moment to catch their breaths, they are usually funny and, as I’ve observed, personable with their regular customers.
Second, the food: Absolutely delicious. I have eaten pizza in a number of shops in a number cities, states, and countries over 25 years or so. Piezanos Pizza isn’t the best I’ve ever had but it is definitely the best in Indianapolis and central Indiana. Their sauce is very unique; sweet and zesty at the same time. The crust and toppings are always fresh; and definitely abundant. Personally, the sausage is a little too spicy for my taste but my boyfriend loves it. We’ve also not had a pizza that wasn’t cooked perfectly; never raw and cold or burnt and crunchy. Always delicious. We have not tried the pastas or any other offerings yet.
Third, the delivery: Prompt and very courteous. We’ve had a couple of drivers and both have been incredibly polite and clean. I know that second one probably sounds picky but I was pleased to see that they must be held to the same standards as servers in a restaurant. Both gentlemen were wearing clean, not-​rumpled shirts tucked into their clean, not-​rumpled pants (they weren’t crisply pressed; they simply appeared freshly laundered). They’ve arrived close to the estimated time; give or take ten minutes or so. The driver that was later rather than earlier apologized as he had driven past our house initially.
Overall: After a couple of months of being Piezanos Pizza customers, I am greatly satisfied. Their staff, food, and service are all really great. I was very surprised to read some of the negative reviews previously posted for this business but the complaints listed seem to be due more to the personality of the reviewers than the fault of the business. I have recommended Piezanos Pizza and I will continue to do so.

Love their around the world pizza! The around the world is one of the best pizza’s I ever tasted! Their chef salads and spaghetti & meatballs are the best, too! Piezano’s is my favorite pizza place!

Best pizza in Indy. I have NEVER been disappointed with the Around the World pie from here.

I called at 1:10 to order lunch. The woman that answered the phone (and she was horribly unpleasant) said it would be an hour. At 2:30, I called for an update. She said she was waiting on a driver. I live less than a mile away, they could have walked it here faster. They delivered around 2:50. We sat down to one of the worst pizzas I’ve ever had. The sauce is very sweet which made me think of pancakes. I was hugely disappointed.

Staff is rude… I called to see if they were open & they answered saying «Thank you for calling Piezanos but you’re out of luck. We are closed.» For one, the website says yall close at 1. Its 1217 a.m. What do they mean they’re «closed?» I didn’t even get a chance to get any words out, he just hung up in my face! I’m not pleased & I’ll never consider eating here again…

I called up an order for a 16″ around the world, 20 wings, and an order of loaded breadsticks. Came out to $ 90.00+ I asked how they came up with that total and they told me half the special online weren’t being honored due to changing of the owner. How is that possible, never ordering again.

Maybe the worst pizza I ever had.

I’m sorry, perhaps pizza expectations mean different things to different people. Where I live a place that offers frozen pre-​made crust pizza would last about a week. $ 17 for a 14″ one topping that is about as good as a grocery store frozen pizza is totally unacceptable. I ate 3 square cut (Columbus Ohio style) pieces & the rest is sitting on my hotel room floor. If i were home I wouldn’t even feed it to my dog, that is how bad it is. Sorry, just the honest truth.

I only work about a mile from Piezano’s so we get delivery a couple of times a month. Pretty good pizza all in all and very nice people. One of the best pizzas in the area for sure.

I just love their pizza, The Around-​The-​World. It’s delicious and takes me back to my childhood when my family would order this pizza with ice cold pepsi. It hasn’t changed and it’s so yummy! Delivery to my house is always fast and friendly and I have no complaints. They’re certainly not a chain pizza place, but that’s what makes it nice, IMO. Keep doing what you’re doing Piezano!!!

Pizza fine, wings… «where’s the beef?». No, really, they must have been anorexic chickens… So skinny… Total waste of sauce. By the way, I ordered mild sauce… if that was mild, I am afraid of the spicy… must be three alarms! Will only return if we get in a pinch.

No love on Unilocal,I see… but I like Piezano’s!
I call Piezano’s from time to time when I’m really hungry, late at night. It’s not love, not yet. Maybe we’ll get there someday.
Piezano’s is not the cheapest pie around, nor is it the best. For the prices they charge the dang mushrooms really should be fresh! But the people who work here are friendly, the pizza is filling and different than everywhere else, and they’re open late. Works for me!

Mushrooms probably came from a jar and the pizza is thin crust. I’ve had better but then again, I’m incredibly picky when it comes to pizza.

#1: Any pizza joint that uses CANED mushrooms should be avoided at all costs!
#2: They seem to only hire illiterate delivery drivers. I work pm’s in a QC lab of a large manufacturing co. On any given fri. night there about a half dozen pizza’s ordered at 2^nd shifts lunch hour between 7 & 8. Being the only person in the building at that time who’s near a phone, my extension is given for all food delivers. To me it seems basic logic that when delivering something to a business the two main pieces of info given to receiving would be the name of your company & name of person receiving delivery. This is what the Piezano’s drivers most often say: «I’ve got a delivery for someone» and with that information, I’m supposed to know who to page… Hello!!! A tiny bit of professionalism would go a long, long way!

DEALS DEALS DEALS, they give Discounts all the time
Amanda has a great phone voice & is always helpful,
all the delivery guys are great,
the Hot Wings were FAB tonight