Guiseppe’s Pizza & Pasta

I love the sweet pizza, moved to DC and they really don’t have good pizza in DC. While visiting NY I had to stop by and take 2 pies back to DC with me

Delicious. Idk about the sweet sauce but I did have the regular sauce. O! It was yummy.

What happened since I moved away, Guiseppes? You used to be so reliably delicious. I’ve come twice since I’ve been back to visit and both times the cheese was different… stringy and not nearly as good. It’s annoying that you can’t use coupons on your phone. The sweet sauce is still amazing. If you’re reviewing poorly because you don’t like sweet sauce… hold the phone. They have a regular one so give it a shot. Oh, and the eesame seed crust? Awesome. We have to bring that out west! Still one of my favorites, but I something is different and not quite as good.

Not too bad– and I do like the sesame seeds on the crust… however the SAUCE must have like 5 cups of sugar in it! Totally off-​putting.

Great Pizza, great service. Delivery was fast and friendly. I liked that they have two sauces, a sweet and a regular. Ordered both and both were delicious.

The whole menu is superb. Most definitely be wary about what you order because most things will be difficult to finish because they are so big. It is pricy but undoubtedly worth it.

I have passed this place hundreds of times. I tried it a long time ago and it was good. I then let some time pass and decided to try it again. Man can they make a great sauce!
Their original sauce is hands down the best I have ever had. I absolutely love their pies. I have also had the Fried Ravioli which is very good as well. Do not hesitate to grab a specialty slice either. The only problem I have is with delivery. It can take a very long time and sometimes the pizza is luke warm. If they increased the delivery time and delivered piping hot pizza every time, this would be 5 stars. It is always worth the wait and the food speaks for itself.

Best pizza ever! I’ve been eating here for years. Very quick and the staff is very nice. Love the sweet sauce!

Come all the way from the Bronx for this Pizza. Unless options on pizza. If theirs anything you don’t see. They will make it for you. Today I had a slice with sweet sauce. Family-​friendly business.

I’m in love. For 10 yrs now my number 1 pizza has been Umbertos in New Hyde location. But the regular slice here with sprinkling of sesame seeds (ordered w he regular, non sweet sauce) blew me away!
Hubby tho adores their sweet sauce. He was laughing looking at me bite in with my eyes closed and a big smile.
Highly recommend.

Just ordered for delivery. It took over an hour and a half to send my food. I ordered linguine they sent spaghetti. I called the resturant. They put me on hold for 5 mins and then came back and said my order would be here any minute. Aka they completely never made my food. 20 bucks for egg plant parm. Not worth it. I will never eat here again

Suggested too my by a Bostonian, not exactly the go to people for pizza joints but I gotta say she was right. Sesame seed crust is a new one for me but I think it’ll grow on me…

The only good thing at this spot is their sweet slice pizza and nice owner. I’ve tried most of their other slices too and not a fan. Their food is mostly made from frozen and not fresh, the guy at the counter admitted it to me when I returned calamari. that I got delivered. Very friendly owner though but they should cook from fresh and not charge so much extra for delivery if your one mile away. That sweet slice is amazing though but parking is tough. Nice owner

bleh. i’ve never been a big fan of sesame, and Guiseppe’s crust is crawling with it; they serve Schweppes «ginger ale,» which doesn’t taste like ginger ale (because it isn’t — you can’t make ginger ale without ginger, and there ain’t no ginger in Schweppes), and on top of nothing tasting right, the last pizza i ordered for delivery was wet (don’t ask me — i don’t think either of us wants to know) to the point of soaking the bottom of the box and causing it to sag. they also don’t use the little white plastic lid supports that many places put in the center of their pizzas, with the result that Guiseppe’s pizza often arrives with much of the cheese that was supposed to be on the pizza stuck instead to the lid of the box.
i think they must be really profit-​hungry; their prices aren’t low, yet the Schweppes, the generic pizza box that doesn’t identify the pizzeria, the cheap waxed paper that doesn’t do its job, and the absence of lid supports all suggest a cutting of corners.
and i too experienced the somewhat delayed delivery that another reviewer complained about.
i wish the folks at Guiseppe’s well, and will find my Italian food elsewhere.
addendum, 13 May 2015: i’ve discovered that i can ask for the sesame seeds to be left off the crust, and for me, that improves my experience of Guiseppe’s pizza considerably… but there are still other pizzas i like better and so will choose first.

Nothing fancy but great pizza! I had never tried the sweet slice before and decided to order one. I was skeptical but it was delicious. I had a grandma slice also with sesame seeds on the crust– yum! If your looking for a good slice or two or a pie I would recommend trying Guiseppe’s!

Ive had about half of their different slices. most of them are gross except the sweet slice. their calamari was deffinetly frozen, the owner even told me so, gross and chewy

I gotta give it up to Giuseppe’s for being Huntington’s most unique types of pizza. I’ve lived in the area for pretty much all my life and I have eaten this pizza a fair amount of times.
The uniqueness is definitely from their sweet sauce, which I’ve heard rumors of years ago they put Hawaiian Punch in their sauce which can be off putting to some but I think that’s what makes them so different from the other pizzerias around the area.

Came here last night for the first time in a long while. I happened to be in the neighborhood and was hungry and remembered that this amazing place was right down the block. The sweet slices are SOOO good and the sesame crust makes it even better. This is probably my favorite pizza place come to think of it. We also had a stuffed meat slice which was also delicious. Staff was very friendly and accomodating. Hope to be back soon!

If you want real NY pizza, then do not go here. After trying other establishments during my stay, I now know the meaning of a real NY pizza. The slice of pizza was a filler for a day of traveling.

In Huntington Station, is a quirky love it or hate it type of pizza place with a cult like following. Giuseppe’s makes two neapolitan pies with their own sweet sauce, and traditional for those who don’t appreciate their originality.
I first heard of Guiseppe’s while standing in a greek restaurant accross from Emelio’s of Commack. Before I could get an opinion of the multi town favorite, I was told by a woman at the counter that instead, she heads a few towns over to Guiseppe’s for their cool sweet sauce pizza. She warned you may not like it or be used to it.
Outside looking a little run down, and inside a clean but older place, there are a bunch of pizza’s clearly just made with many variations. Creativity is something that is everpresent here. On my first visit, they were warm and welcoming, and described the different sauces. There was a family there in from Islandia, who also travel to have this odd sweet sauce pizza.
I took it home, and it didn’t fly. Lol. I also brought two friends a meatball pizza for a late work night, and they liked that, where I didn’t. (meatballs were too light and soft and not baked in too well.
This time just tried the plain neapolitan slice. Driving home, this was a crispy somewhat light crust with sesame seeds on the rim, and the sauce and cheese were on the mild side. Not heavy or dense, but lighter blander, crispier crust.
Guiseppe’s Pizza is a fan favorite. Love it or hate for the tasty original sweet sauce they use. It is a bucket list (lol) must try. if you are passing through here, you should certainly see what side of the fence you are on with this. lol
For those in the city, who may be taking the LIE out to the east end, it’s an easy stop off on Rte 110 north up over Jericho Tpk on the left.