Tilly’s Tea Room

This place deserves my first Unilocal review in 5 years. Immediately upon walking into the restaurant, it is obvious that the owner has injected her English sensibility into the décor and ambiance. Initially I felt uncomfortable with the light blue sitting room, as I am a 25 year old bearded male. But my dad reminded me that Fortnum Mason in London uses the same color palette so it makes sense. I ordered the English Breakfast tea with a tomato mozzarella panini. Everything felt thoroughly English but tasted so much better than English food. I also had a scone to top off the meal. Wow. Try this place out. Even if you’re a bearded male.

Oh my goodness this place is adorable with bright cheery colors, pennant banners and English charm. The perfect setting for spending time with a friend catching up over tea and fresh baked scones. I highly recommend pairing these homemade tasty cakes with clotted cream and lemon curd — amazing! The menu is very limited to a few salads, sandwiches, a daily soup, tea and pastries. The simple menu is actually refreshing. Mimosas and wine are also available. I chose the salad with a scoop of homemade chicken salad, it was very good and filling.
Tilly’s also offers options for kids and offers party services for showers, birthday parties and bridal showers. A small sitting room with couches and British flair makes for a great space for a party or even a place to relax and read a good book.
Notes: I have heard wonderful things about the traditional English recipe Fish ‘n’ chips, only offered on select days and times of year (Spring, Summer, Fall) as they are made outside. Sun King Beer is also available on Fish ‘n’ Chip days. This dish is on my list.

Fun little place to grab a good lunch. My daughters think it is fun and cute and I think the food is great.

Fishers needed something new and interesting and Tilly’s Tea Room hits the mark. The tea shop has a cozy atmosphere, full of pastel colors and cute tea cups, and of course, the tea is fantastic. I recommend a pot of the Ginger Peach tea and a Strawberry Jam scone. The sandwiches and other foodstuff are a bit on the pricey side, but Tilly’s is definitely affordable for a nice cup of tea with friends.

Adorable place. I have spent a summer in England so it was to find this lovely tea room. The tea choices were great — plenty of delicious flavors as well as traditional British tea.
Get the scones and clotted cream with the strawberries or lemon curd. The scones are absolutely wonderful.
This is definitely my new favorite place!

Absolutely love Tilly’s tearoom! Everything about my visit was absolute perfection. It’s a little escape to London in the Midwest. So thrilled that they also offered many gluten free options!

Loved the fish and chips that was served at the Fishers Freedom Festival. Great find and will definitely be back to try more of the menu.

So excited! Just got to try out with a friend Tilly’s, a local tea place opened in February. Nice, airy, great light. Had a crumpet but they also had lovely scones. Can’t wait to go back! The owner is very personable. I enjoyed speaking with her. This is a great place for lunch or for after work, if you get done early. They had sandwiches and soups as well as carrot cake.

This was such a fun girls day out!!! Everyone is very friendly and the staff is great. Their menu is small and perfect for the store. It’s just cute, simple and delicious! I’m pretty excited to go back for more tea and scones!
I ended up with the blueberry tea and ordered the turkey sandwich for lunch. This is for sure a soon to be favorite/​tradition for girls weekend !

Locally owned, Tilly’s adds the perfect amount of whimsy and charm to the developing downtown Fishers’ scene. Located on 116^th street, Tilly’s offers tea, sweets, trinkets, and lunch items Tuesday through Saturdays. We arrived right before the lunch crowd and were promptly seated. The menu offers a small array of sandwiches with a few salad options and the occasional soup. Afternoon tea service is also offered that comes with tea, tea sandwiches, scones, and mini desserts. Tucked in throughout the restaurant are locally made products, mugs, along with English chips and sweets for purchase. Definitely a great place for girlfriends, mothers and daughters, and families to go and enjoy a light lunch and dessert.

1^st Time in, Very Nice Tea Room, Food was OK, Service needs improvement, had to wait a long time but lucky we weren’t in a big hurry. I hope they get more help. I’d like to try this again. Nice addition to Fishers Area.

What a gem located in downtown Fishers! Had an awesome lunch with a friend today! It was delicious. Tea options were great too! Our sandwiches were very filling and came with small salad and chips. Great deal! It has a very girly feel which I loved. I like that a few of previous owner’s consignments have continued to have items available. She even has some of her furniture. The owner is British and super friendly! She has some great ideas coming in the future so watch for all of those too. Think about stopping by prior to concerts this summer for carryout dinner! Great place for girls tea parties no matter what age! I will definitely be back. How nice to have original non chain establishments in downtown Fishers!

What a wonderful tea room in downtown Fishers IN. In an old house on the south side of 116^th St. (used to be the Best of What’s Around Boutique). The owner is British and is truly a gem. She was so nice in letting us explore the tea room, take pictures, admire her decoration and have a wonderful lunch here. There is even a small play room for children. Whether you are in the mood for just tea and a scone, or lunch, this is a great new spot in town. For lunch I enjoyed the egg salad sandwich that came with some chips and a small salad. My friend enjoyed the carrot coriander (cilantro) soup and a salad with chicken salad on top. The soup also came with a slice of bread and butter. We enjoyed some hot tea as well. There are some consignment items in here for sale as well. What a lovely place for a nice meal between friends, family and all.