P & J Pizza

Their homemade bread is amazing — what keeps me going back. Walking from the office is a plus. LOUD TV can be annoying if dining in, so we don’t.

Delicious pizza, although the staff always seems miserable. They also have a bit of a fly problem in the dining and kitchen areas. They’re literally swarming around me as i sit here typing this.

In the area for business and stopped for lunch today based on Unilocal rating and comments. I ordered a small regular Stromboli – too much for the average person. Tasty and a crispy crust served w/​marinara sauce – very good!
They could pay a bit more attention to service – napkins were empty at my table, table behind me was dirty and diet soda at dispenser was empty. One clerk on his personal cell phone after waiting on me while another clerk with the next customer had trouble finding prices on the menu.
An average rating as the food is good but the little things for service & atmosphere bring it down… including the horror flick on tv at lunch!?!

I might up my rating in a few weeks, as I am going here regularly. But at the moment their web site is expired and even when it was working you could not order a pizza, because they did not have the pizza options on the menu, except for the ‘special’ pizza.
That one costs over 13 bucks for a small. It has far too much stuff on it, in fact it has everything. So in most cases it is far too much. The crust is good, very good. But it is not what I would call thin at all.
I used to frequent real Italian pizza joints back in New Joisey, and I like an Italian ambiance. This place has old photo of some village in Sicilia on the walls, but the employees speak Spanish exclusively.
There are tables inside, but the décor is spartan and utilitarian at best. And in the winter there is a draft when people come in the door.
Only tried two of the subs, which were fine but no different from Brothers down the street, which is a bit cheaper.
I was looking forward to this, living so close, and reading some of these reviews. But so far I would say it is pretty ordinary rather than exceptional. It is good enough and I will go back. I hope to discover something they do better than elsewhere, but not so far.
These places change, a lot, over time and according to who is working there. The owner started a new place down on the highway and I suspect this one in town has been neglected.

I have been a few times before, but no longer. Ordered 2 plain slices and a soup, waited 20 minutes (in an empty dining area) only to find out that they had not thrown slices in oven or served my mother her soup. Staff was too busy talking to friends and on their cellphone to concentrate on customer service. Lastly, when I told them we had to go due to holiday commitments, they refunded the $ for the food but charged us for the fountain soda. Really!!!
Do yourself a favor, if you wish to be treated as a valuable customer, don’t go here. Either that or pay AFTER you have received your order.

The food is okay, but I see the pizza sit there for ages until they pop it in the oven to a room temp. The mozzarella sticks are always in the form of tough cheese sticks, not melted. They never listen on their orders, and the employees are tolerable. I’ve had experiences of an employee picking up the phone and talking on it and then getting annoyed when I asked a question about their menu. I’d rather have My Place.

Ever since I moved here, I went to this place many times, and I have to say that the place did decline in quality. This place used to serve excellent pizza, but now it has pizza that is too cheesy, too doughy, and sometimes undercooked. I wouldn’t recommend.

The pizza is good and cheap but the woman who works the counter isn’t exactly a people person. The place had a lot of take out orders at the time and being coldly stared at when you walk up to the counter with your business makes me forget about how the pies are cheaper than most places in town.

We love this place! The staff is very friendly and always makes their customers feel welcome. Their food is amazing, generous portions, and always delicious. We usually order something different (pizza, subs, calzones, pasta dinners) and have never been disappointed on what we order. I think this is the best pizzeria in Elizabethtown!

I think there are more banks and pizza joints in E-​town then they have people. They opened another place, Sal’s, between E-​town & Mt. Joy. Their pizza needs a lot to be desired, but their subs are out of this world. They make their own bread, so it is always very fresh and delicious. Hot or cold, their subs are stuffed with delicousness.

Great pizza place. Good portions. Their large subs and Stromboli can easily feed two people. Friendly staff. Highly recommended.

Their ranch chicken pizza is yummy but a little overpriced. Ordered from here a few times and it was pretty much a hit or miss with whether it was delicious or not.

Best place for subs and boli’s in Harrisburg area! Moved away and miss our neighborhood pizza joint! Great portion sizes and you can’t beat the homemade bread for the subs. My favorite was veggie boli!

Best pizza in etown!

By far the best Pizza joint in Elizabethtown. Wonderful, delicious Pizzas, fantastic Hoagies and Subs and when you walk in, the smell of «Genuine Pizzeria» will infiltrate your nostrils and tap dance on your taste buds… in a good way.
You don’t know what a «Genuine Pizzeria» smells like? Go there now, you will find out.
I recommend the Italian Hoagie or a pizza with whatever you want on it, the bread is freshly made and is one of a kind. Just beware, if you eat there once, you may never go to another pizza place. Ever.

Pizza has gotten better and now is one of the top 2 nearby. Cheesesteaks and subs are the best around. Homemade Italian rolls.
Better than Pittsburgh for sandwiches.

This is our regular Friday night pizza place. Great thin crust and good subs as well. Staff is friendly — the just opened up a place in Mount Joy called «Sal’s» — haven’t been there yet, but will try soon.

I can really only talk about the wings and pizza, because that’s all I ever get here. I could eat them everyday and not get tired of them. Actually I’m going to cut this review short and go get some.

This place is great!!! We moved away from Etown 4 years ago and this was our first stop for lunch on a recent visit!!! Yummmmmm!!! There homemade bread for the sandwiches rocks! Bolis yum! Pizza yum! I heard the ham puffs are awesome but they go fast so we did not get to try them!

Love the food. Friendly service. Nice little eating area.