Brothers Pizza

We’ve ordered from here before and it was fine. Today, for the Super Bowl, we ordered the Big V and the pizza is so burnt that it can’t be eaten. Incredibly disappointing! We paid for food, paid for delivery, and tipped the driver all for food that can’t be eaten! Never ordering from here again!

It has been over 30 years since I graduated from Elizabethtown College and just as long since I have had Brother’s Stromboli! Brother’s pizza and stromboli were a staple on our dorm floor in Brinser, particularly on the weekends! Stopped in today for lunch as I was back in town for a meeting at the college. I had to see if Brother’s offered the same awesome stromboli they did in the early 1980’s. I had the small Brother’s stromboli and it was excellent. Even the small stromboil was more than I could eat for lunch… had the rest for dinner! Price and service were great. Place looks just like it did when I was in college in the early 80’s…neat and clean! Way to go Brother’s! Since leaving college and E-​town, I have lived in Pittsburgh, NYC, Princeton, NJ, Laguna Niguel, CA, Fort Myers Beach, FL, Orlando, FL and Maitland, FL… and NO ONE makes stromboli like Brother’s! It was soooo good to be back.

SO GOOD! I love coming to this pizza place when I’m in Elizabethtown. They’re alwasy friendly and quick.

Ate here today due to the reviews on Unilocal,pizza was excellent and staff very friendly. I would highly recommend this establishment.

My personal favorite pizza around. Its not new york style but it is delicious. The italian sub is the best around too. Plus the staff is pretty friendly! :)

Love this place! They’re pizzas are pretty good and the subs are huge! The half sub is enough to fill anyone up, and the whole subs easily make 2 – 3 meals in themselves. Has a nice small town pizzeria atmosphere and they’re open pretty late (Till 11pm on most nights). Staff is always nice and quick to fill orders. Great place to stop in for a homemade sub or pizza.

Being from the Philly area I know a good hoagie and this place by far has the best hoagies in the Lancaster area.

Good sandwiches and pizza.

Ridiculously cheap! $ 8 dollars for a large pizza with several toppings! yowsers. Ordered a pepperoni pizza and it had its own topping of grease. My fiancé actually had to blot the pizza (and we all know guys will refuse to because it’s «girly) it was that excessive. After the de-​greasing, it was pretty good. I wouldn’t say it’s like NY style pizza, but it’s pretty good for the middle of Pennsylvnia

Brother’s is one of the best pizza places in etown — the owners and staff are friendly and fast. They will pretty much make any kind of pizza you want, even if it’s not on the menu. My favorite is the Margherita pizza, which is phenominal. Their sauce has a nice spice to it, and the crust is very tasty. I often go here for lunch, and the subs, as well as the wings are excellent. Do yourself a favor and check ‘em out!

I always say pizza is like sex… even when its bad, its still pizza. If so, consider this the awkward, fumbling, early sex that is over before it began.
Ok so that analogy might not have worked this time, but the food was awful. The entire time i was there (on a saturday — at lunch time) NO ONE ELSE CAME IN. I should’ve taken that as a sign.
Awful, freezerburned, premade crusts — this is the kind of pizza you’d get at a gas station. My youngest son got a fish sandwich — the fish was half the size of the bun,
This place is dump. Drive on by.