Jimmy’s Pizza

Was visiting a friend for the weekend and we were running around doing errands and were STARVING, so she said hey I will call in an order to Jimmy’s and we can pick it up well turns out we were closer than we thought so we got there about 5 minutes after calling in an order. We walk in and decided to sit to wait for our order of a large cheese pizza and a greek salad with chicken, 5 minutes later our order came out and since it wasn’t boxed we said ok we will just eat here. The Pizza was delicious and perfectly melty cheesy goodness, but the Highlight was definitely the Grilled Chicken on the greek salad it has just the perfect amount of spices and tender juiciness. Also to be noted the Pizza was just as good warmed up the next day

I’ve been going to Jimmy’s since I was a kid, and I had always been a huge fan. Unfortunately since they changed owners the pizza has just been terrible. Even with the lack of competition in the area I can’t imagine them staying open much longer. I wish the old owner would come back so we can have some good pizza back in Dudley again.

We’ve gone here on and off for the past dozen years. Always remembered it as pretty good, especially the subs. Since we can never make up our minds we usually get a small pizza and a small sub, then have some of each. Until this past weekend we had been there maybe five months ago. Last Saturday was our last time. The pizza dough was hard and dry. I asked Himself if the pizza had been sitting on top the oven keeping warm before he got there; he said he had to wait because it wasn’t done. Hmmm, something is missing then. It was like three-​day-​old bread. The chicken parm sub was toasty but there was almost nothing inside. It had a tiny bit of sauce, a little cheese and maybe an almost-​cutlet of chicken. To add insult to injury the guy I ordered from couldn’t add. He asked if I wanted to know the exact amount for the $ 7.75 pizza and $ 6.99 sub plus tax. I said OK but then started to add on my calculator. I had the sum of $ 15.77 before he came back with «that will be exactly $ 16.00». HUH? When I questioned his figure by rebutting with my own number he said «no, it’s exactly $ 16». Went ahead with the order anyway (we were hungry!) and Himself was told the same total when he went to pick the items up. Believe me, the food was not worth the 23 cent tip. We ended up at Sturbridge Uno’s tonight because we still had wanted GOOD pizza (and boy was it!). Won’t be visiting Jimmy’s again.

Having just picked up a Happy Meal for my little one, I was in the mood for a sub. I was going to stop at one of the local Subways but decided that wasn’t going to cut it. I wanted a good sandwich. Anyone who has lived in the area will tell you that is what Jimmy’s is known for.
I walked in around two to an empty dining room and right to the counter and received a warm and friendly greeting. Not having been here in a while, which is something that should change, I needed a few minutes to look at the menu. Having placed my order for a medium veal parm, we had a seat and watched a little TV while we waited.
My sub was delicious, no microwave here. Just the right amount of sauce, toasted bread and great tasting veal.
They may be under new management but I think the food is still great.

This place has changed owners, though my personal memories are probably preventing me from giving it a complete fair review. It’s not any worse, I don’t think, but it is not the place I frequented as a high school student all those years ago. The bread is not the same, the pizza crust is not the same, the environment is not the same… and the people behind the counter do not smile and yell out my name when I walk in.
All that being said, they have expanded the menu and most of the stuff we tried (Eggplant Parm sub, Pulled Pork Pizza) was good… the Italian sub left a little to be desired, as the meat seemed a little too close to bologna than any of the meats you expect in an Italian.

The subs are really big and tasty.
Me and my girl asked the guy behind the counter what type of pizza he recommends. he told us to go with the taco pizza. It was great. It was a regular pizza with chips, letesse, totatoes, ground beef, taco seasoning, olives and more. A large fed us both and my roommate.