Toppers Pizza

HORRIBLE EXPERIENCE! Ordered pizza and after waiting 2 hours called to find out the driver never showed up. They should have told us that when I ordered. Called back to see how much longer and the manager said could be another 15 – 25 mins… NEVER ORDERING FROM THEM AGAIN!

Last night we ordered delivery from here and we were impressed!!! Great tasting, hot, fresh food. Lots of toppings and they all tasted great. Pepperoni breadsticks were awesome as well. Pizza arrived 15 minutes earlier than the online estimated time!!! When I’m back in town I will definitely go here for my pizza place!!! Yummy!

I generally stay away from pizza, most of it makes me feel like junk. But, hubby was craving pizza on NYE, Toppers is 10 minutes from us and we wanted to try someplace new. We set our pickup time for 6pm, it was ready on the dot. I’m rather impressed actually! The pizza wasn’t greasy at all, no orange grossness dripping off. Could have used a bit more sauce, but the taste was great and no nasty feeling afterwards. The cinnamon sticks were so good… I may have eaten 5… don’t judge. And the selection of dipping sauces is ridiculous. My only tiny suggestion would be to have the cheese sauce warm, it was a bit funky cold. Other than that, we will definitely order again!

Every time we come home to Carmel we make sure to get some Toppers! It’s the BEST pizza by far that offers delivery and take out as well as some fun topping combo ideas. Keep it up!

Since Toppers is near my office, when we decided to order lunch in a few days ago, I decided to try a new pizza place. We settled on a thin crust veggie pizza, cheesy stix, and hot wings for three of us (plus extra to share). They delivered exactly at their estimated time. We all liked it — nothing too exciting, but definitely good. My one coworker found a few hairs on one of his slices that didn’t appear to be any of ours, so that was kind of gross, but it happens, I suppose. Since everything else was otherwise good, I’d go back.

Quickie Review: They put the ZING in amaZING!
Eating their pizza for the first time made me question what I had been eating during the rest of my life. Totally turned me off of eating Pizza Hut. Best Pizza I’ve ever had and the manager will go out of his way to make sure you leave happy.

9″ sausage pepperoni for lunch. Pretty damn delicious. Nacho cheese sauce actually has a little bit of heat to it instead of the yellow sauce that other places serve.
Chic working right now is pretty hot too.

Ate here last night before heading off. Nice crust, good sauce, and REAL CHEESE! YES, REAL CHEESE!
Next time I’m down in Indy and feel like pizza, Toppers it is!

Amazing pizza. AMAZING! After my first bite, I felt like that Oprah Winfrey meme, where her head is thrown back, her mouth is agape and her arms are open wide, and she’s screaming, «You get a car!» Except it’s not Oprah, it’s me. And I don’t get a car — I get a pizza. But I felt that excited.
This is basically the pizza I have been looking for since moving to the Indianapolis area. It’s a whole lot of nothing: It’s not cut into square pieces. It’s not crispy and thin. It’s not redolent of oregano. It’s thick and chewy, cheesy, greasy, wonderful — it tastes the way pizza is supposed to taste! I have found my new pizza home.

Very good pizza. The delivery was so so quick but the quality is excellent and the price was good. To make this review longer I will post Go Colts! 25 times. Go Colts! Go Colts! Go Colts! Go Colts! Go Colts! Go Colts! Go Colts! Go Colts! Go Colts! Go Colts! Go Colts! Go Colts! Go Colts! Go Colts! Go Colts! Go Colts! Go Colts! Go Colts! Go Colts! Go Colts! Go Colts! Go Colts! Go Colts! Go Colts! Go Colts!

I ordered Toppers pizza when staying n Carmel and was really impressed. I had a sausage and thick cut pepperoni pizza and garlic cheesy bread. It was fresh and hot when delivered. They also have tasty dipping sauces and 1 sauce comes included with each pizza order.

Yum. Tater tots on pizza. Late night delivery that came faster than promised. Friendly staff taking the order, and a delivery guy who made me smile. Can’t ask for much more. Thanks! We wish we lived closer…

I’m normally not one to complain, especially not on social media. However, since there are so few «late night» pizza delivery places in this town (aka a place that delivers after 9pm), options are limited. I placed my delivery order at 11:54pm this evening. I was told my delivery time frame was 1:15 to 1:45 minutes. I called back at 2:00am and was immediately put on hold, and then told that my order was on its way. It is now 2:45am and I still have not received my order. Feel free to draw your own conclusions because mine are currently laced with expletives and I don’t want to sound ignorant.
And now it is 3:07am, your location is closed and I still have not received my order. I will be telling everyone I know about this terrible, terrible experience. Thanks.

Not only was the pizza EXCELLENT a the customer service was amazing. We were in town for an event that ran late and were turned away by two major franchises and found Toppers. Lucky us! Great pizza, made fresh. Highly recommend.

I’m a big fan of Toppers. Most pizza joints have specialty pizzas, but at Toppers, they actually matter and are quite delicious and inventive. They make their own sauce and dough in house and prepare the veggies fresh in house. I know this because I worked at a Toppers in West Lafayette while attending Purdue and it was great. The toasted sandwiches and quesadillas are pretty fire, as well. I suggest trying the specialty pizzas. You’ll find one to fall for.

I’ve been here a couple times now and it’s not bad. But it’s nothing special. I’d say this is your average pizza chain pizza. Not sure what the excitement is over the Topperstix, though. It’s cheese on pizza dough. So technically it’s a step down from cheese pizza. It’s almost like deconstructed cheese pizza. But then you get marinara to dip your sauceless cheese pizza in. So basically you’re eating… reconstructed cheese pizza? (Shrug)
The customer service is pretty good here. They’re always friendly and upbeat. I haven’t had any issues with long wait times or rude employees like others have reported.
Overall, if you don’t want to spend too much or there isn’t anything else open this isn’t a bad choice. But with sooooooo many other pizza joints around you’re probably better off going elsewhere.

I ordered pizza for my department today because, well, the people in my department are awesome. I opted for Toppers at the request of some dedicated fans and I’m glad I listened to their suggestion! We tried almost all of the specialty pizzas, but the favorites from the house menu were the Loaded Tot-​zza and the Three Little Pigs. The real star of the show ended up being the Topperstix, however.
I was very impressed by the service as well. I placed a very large order online before they opened that day and they not only delivered, they delivered early! I look forward to using Toppers services again in the future!

We had great service, very friendly. Pizza crust and sauce very much like Papa John’s. Papa John’s is not one of my favorites. Topping were good, pepperoni sticks were very good. They do not have fountain drinks, that’s a point off to me. They have some seating to eat in, but I think they are mostly carryout and delivery. In all it was ok pizza. Not great, not bad. It will not be on my list of OMG we have to go back.

Toppers is absolutely amazing. I put pizza joints into two major categories: special pizzas, where the flavors are complex and the pizzas are expensive, and everyday pizza. After trying almost every pizza place north of I-​465, I can say that Toppers is absolutely the best place in Carmel for everyday pizza.
The pizzas are exactly what you’d expect with no frills. The crust is very flavorful and the hand-​tossed crust is fluffy and tender. The thin crust is just as flavorful, although they have perfected the texture needed for the cracker-​like crust. The ingredients are ridiculously awesome, and totally unexpected including bacon strips, thick cut pepperoni, gyro meat, tater tots, nacho cheese. It’s a place where you can really feel that they make pizzas that they crave. The topper’s stix (cheese sticks) and buffalo wings are some of the best that I have had from a pizza place.
In addition to the great pizza, the service is absolutely outstanding. The guys behind the counter are hilarious and always happy to serve. They make every time I go to pick up pizza a treat. Be sure to ask about their current deals, as there will always be some discount scheme that you can benefit from.

This is our favorite pizza in Carmel. And that is saying something because there are many, many pizza places in the Carmel/​Westfield area.
The pizza is excellent with many topping choices and specialty pizzas to choose from. The Topperstix are simply addictive.
Late night delivery is available, and that is a very good thing.
We have ordered pizza here for carryout several times. While there were service issues the first few times it has greatly improved, and I am pleased to report that the past few times service has been excellent.
Employees are super friendly and helpful.
We are looking forward to trying more menu items in the future.