Liberty Pizzeria

A gluten free friend of mine loves their gf pizza, and as a gluten-​eater I don’t mind it, though I do prefer the regular pizza. Good prices, and the staff is so friendly, we went in so much last semester they actually gave us free garlic knots once. Great for a quick pizza fix

This place has been a late night go-​to when I was living in the Pratt dorms. Here are my thoughts:
Pros: It isn’t a bad slice of pizza. I can’t speak for the rest of the menu but the pizza is what I expect typical NY pizza should be. Also, the people who work there are really nice. Liberty is also open two hours later than Luigi’s; and for my fellow pratt colleagues, it is also closer to the Willoughby dorms. I also find most of the time the pizza itself is a little less greasy than Luigi’s but they each have just about the same amount. (Side-​by-​side comparison of fresh pepperoni slices) This place also does a good gluten free pizza, which my girlfriend with celiacs can eat without harm.
Cons: I find the pizza not to be as good as Luigi’s. The fact that I am comparing Liberty to a competing place down the street isn’t lookin too good. The interior of the place has no thrills. Personally, it doesn’t feel too welcoming.
Conclusion: The pizza is good pizza. It isn’t great pizza but it isn’t bad. I give this 4 stars; 3 for the review and a bonus star for having a decent gluten-​free pizza that my girlfriend with celiacs disease can eat!

Five stars just for the Buffalo chicken pizza.
Best slice ever.
italian ices are cheap and perfect for the summer.
Gyros are also pretty good.
did i mention the buffalo pizza?

My family (3 and 5 y.o.) and I popped by while walking through the neighborhood, and looking for a place we could SIT and eat. It seems tougher to find places that look like families can sit and not annoy students, singles, trendy persons without kids– we hate feeling as if we’re an annoyance and most places have fairly tight seating. This all being said Liberty doesn’t have tons of seating, but for it’s size it’s got plenty. On top of that we felt pretty at ease there and the owner (I assume, but maybe manager– probably owner) was so kind to our kids. He brought our pizza and offered to cut the slices in small cubes for our kids. The pizza was good– but we’re not super picky about our pizza (apparently Luigi’s is the go to spot here?). Either way we thought it was great pizza and one pizza for $ 18.00 makes 2 meals for us– not a bad deal. We’ll be customers as long as we live in Clinton Hill. Check em out if you’d like some great pizza and great service!

Ordered from here a couple nights ago-​just a small cheese pizza with ranch on the side. It was fast delivery, under 30 minutes. The pizza was delicious. Huge side of ranch on the side.

Pretty standard pizza. I ordered a large mushroom pie from Liberty Pizzeria for dinner on Sunday since my usual delivery place closes early on Sundays. The ingredients weren’t particularly unique, but there also wasn’t anything wrong with it — just the right amount of cheese and sauce and the mushrooms didn’t taste over– or under-​cooked. It did come a little bit less crispy than I usually like, but in Liberty Pizzeria’s defense, I forgot to ask for it to be cooked Well Done. Another good point is the prices are pretty cheap compared to some of the other areas near me. A lot of the similarly priced places come out far worse than here, so that’s always a nice bonus.
Something interesting I noticed the next day — reheating the pizza was pretty great. I think since it wasn’t cooked as crispy as I liked it, when I reheated it with my usual strategy (putting it in the oven on some parchment paper on 375 for 10 minutes), it came out even better than the first time. My girlfriend and I were both really surprised, but also really happy about the revelation. Next time I decide to order pizza when I know I’ll have leftovers, I’m going to order from here again for sure.

Great Italian ices on a hot day.

One time, I was being robbed in an especially humiliating way by some twelve year old. I smirked as he finished fishing around in my pockets for piddling sums.
«Congratulations, two twenty-​five. You can’t even buy a slice of pizza for that these days.»
You’re right, Two Teef. It does show what I know.
And yes, the slice at Liberty is perfectly serviceable as you said. Glad we can still be pen pals.
The moral is: A criminal with class is rare. Don’t be getting robbed for cheap pizza.

One of the lowest end pizza I’ve ever had

This pizza is decent. Super mediocre, just keep your expectations at nothing and you will be satisfied that yes, they do indeed serve food. Albeit cheaper than Luigi’s by like, a few cents, you’re going to wish you had walked your behind over to Dekalb. They have seats, so that’s a plus…

Best falafel I’ve ever had for under 5 bucks. Very friendly service, too. Thanks, Liberty!

I’ve had delivery from Liberty Pizzeria about thrice now. Everything so far has been quite delicious and adequately cheesy. I’m not too sure why everyone else’s review was so poor. Perhaps their readily available pizza slices aren’t that fresh? I’ve tried the lasagna twice and the pepper steak hero once. I’ve yet to try out the pizza but will update you folks if I do!

Fast and friendly service, not the largest selection, but for okay pricing in the big city i’ll give it a three. its open on a sunday, works for me.

So, the pedestrian slice here can usually use some doctoring… I tend to give it a good shakedown of oregano, chili flakes and garlic salt. That said: the price is right, I could eat the garlic knots here every day of my life, and I lovelovelove the guys that work the counter. They couldn’t be friendlier, have my order memorized and always lend me a pen so I can do my crossword puzzle while I eat.

Ok, not the greatest pizza, but the people working here are the nicest in the neighborhood. And the Gyro isn’t half bad!

Serves a pretty mediocre Pizza, especially in comparison to Luigi’s which is only a few blocks away. Their pizza is slightly more bearable without pepperoni but honestly its not a far cry away from the meal plan pizza served in the Pie Shop at Pratt. They literally microwaved the lasagna on their menu.
The food’s certainly edible, but honestly, you can probably go to any random restaurant on Myrtle Avenue and get a better meal.

The first time I came to pratt, my friends suggested to go here. it was a scarring moment of overly greased pizza and a strawberry ice cream with an inch half long strand of (what looks to be like) p**** hair at the bottom of the cup.
And then I told myself, NEVER AGAIN.