Casa Di Pizza

BLEACH WARNING: If I could, I would give this place ZERO stars. I ordered the chicken fingers, with fries and coleslaw. I tasted a little bit of a chlorine taste on a few of the fries. Then one ended up being soaked in whatever this was. I continued eating and a few more tasted normal. I then smell my hands and they smell like straight up BLEACH. The tin foil that they had put the fries on had been soaked in cleaning product. It smelt like Clorox. Ended up vomiting and calling poison control. I will never eat at this place again. And I suggest you don’t either.

Took a little study break from Sacred Grounds to stop in and grab something to eat. It’s a cute little corner pizza shop with good pies and numerous gluten free options. Aside from the usual fare of salads they also have gluten free pizza crusts, gluten free pasta and gluten free sub rolls! I ended up getting a gluten free pepperoni pizza sub and it was great. My boyfriend had some of their regular pizza and he said it was really good too! Good pizza with fair prices and gluten free options means I’ll be coming back multiple times!

Hailing from Buffalo, I’ve been desperate to find a Florida pizzeria that even comes close to what we offer in WNY. Thankfully, I discovered that one of my favorite Buffalo eateries had a location only 40 minutes away from me. Enjoy! You can thank me later!

This is a great mom & pop pizza joint, sports hangout and lunch spot for anyone, but it’s especially compelling for expatriate Buffalonians! I’m not one myself, but I’m married to one, so I’m somewhat familiar with Buffalo-​style food.
CdP has beef on weck (the classic beef and au jus sandwich on a salt and caraway-​encrusted roll), great pizza and generous subs. You can also get Buffalo faves like Genessee beer and Sahlen’s hot dogs. I haven’t personally tried the wings, but I’m told they’re authentic. The fries are crispy and delicious.
Travelers on I-​75 would do well to pass by the fast food places and give Casa di Pizza a try, and homesick Buffalonians will find it an Erie oasis in the Sunshine State.

I work right by Casa Di Pizza and have been there many times for lunch. I must say that I do not go there anymore and have not for a while. Honestly, the food is standard as far as quality and flavor goes. Their pizza is greasy and the burgers are bland. The workers’ are very nice and the owner is a swell guy also.
If you can, find somewhere else to grab a bite. Otherwise, stop in for some friendly service.

I ordered a Philly cheese steak and although it was good, it lacked onions and green peppers, didn’t have enough provolone either. Good pizza though… and they do deliver

Their pizza is GREAT. I have no issue with the pizza and the buffalo dip is awesome! However, the reason why I’m giving them just three stars is because of two gripes I have. First, the price is a little two high, I really think they should come down with the price. Second, is their supremes. What they consider a supreme and what a REAL supreme is are two vastly different things. You have to ask for the extra toppings that they for whatever reason don’t put on the supreme automatically. If it weren’t for these two things, I would of given them five stars.

I’m giving 5 stars for the phenom wings (BBQ). Unbelievably delicious. I saw a lot of unhappy pizza reviews but try ½ baked, takes it up a notch, fresh out of your oven. The fried fish is good and the cheesesteak… so try som other stuff. This is a really good place, straight from Buffalo NY. They also have the classic beef on weck.

Very very expensive pizza. For a large one topping pizza expect about $ 20 – 25 for a grease bucket. It’s only saving grace is to pat it off a little and put it in the oven for a tad longer.

Our favorite pizza place was closed sunday so we thought we’d give this place a shot. Pizza was just ok, wifes strombolli was burned. The girl taking the orders was rude but the bellyaches we got shortly after and still have a day later make me say, do yourself a favor and pass on this place!!. There are plenty of much better pizza joints around.

Bad experience on 3÷29÷12. They were not operating at their best and after eating told the waitress what wasn’t quite right. A manager argued with me. I wrote the owners, in case the manager wasn’t an owner. He was an owner and he wrote back arguing that I was wrong and rude to him. I won’t go back there, and I live around the corner, and I suggest you don’t either unless you want attitude if you don’t think they are perfect.

The char-​grilled wings are the best I’ve ever had. The pizza’s OK, the rest of the good’s pretty good though. But the wings, NO comparison! INCREDIABLE

This pizza gave me a stomach ache! However if you like greasy pizza with an overly oily crust then be my guest… It is like a lesser pizza hut without the thickness. I was not a fan!

The pizza’s ok. I’ve had better.
But the wings, oh the crispy, saucy wings are worth the trip every time. You can’t go wrong with the bar b que or hot & spicy.
Great staff!

Typical pizza for this area. Crust too thick. Sauce just not great. Although they claim it’s New York pizza — it isn’t even close.
However, the folks running it were friendly & helpful. It’s too bad the pizza didn’t cut it.

Dislike thick pizza.

Good food and diverse menu. Nice staff too.

We love the Casa! Great food and wonderful staff. They have the best pizza and buffalo wings in town.

Possibly the worst pizza i have ever had in my life while visiting family.
Sauce is terrible.
Owners are from buffalo which is not considered NYC.
But what can i expect its not New york City.

Good food the way you rememebr it from up North!
Based in Buffalo, NY. this is some great New York style pizza and pastas!
They call themselves «Casual Dining Italian American Sports Bar Restaurant. Family restaurant with a sports bar and reasonably priced food.»
They have flat screen TVs and love to feed you while you watch the Buffalo Bills football games!
Awesome deep dish pizza too — our favorite! Want something real? Skip the chain pizza and try Casa Di Pizza! Yumm…
Website: