Bedminster Pizza

Pretty good Pizza, would like a little more crunch to the crust but was good!

Best pizza around! Absolutely delicious!!! Not to doughy and not to thin, it is just right. Can’t wait to go back.

Average pizza. I ordered a half cheese half pepperoni pie to go. It was ready nice and quick which was good. As for the actual pizza, nothing special. I was excited to try it due to the high rating and good reviews on Unilocal,alas, I was let down. The crust was too thick throughout the pizza, cheese and sauce not flavorful.
I’ll try it one more time to give it another chance but as for being great at a regular plain cheese pie… fail.

This is my favorite pizza place around here. Their cheese pizza is amazing, delicious sauce, awesome cheese. I normally can only eat 2 slices of pizza but here I can eat half the pie and still crave more. SO GOOD!

They passed the phone to two guys and neither spoke English well enough to take my order. Very unprofessional and should get that worked out. I don’t care how good the food is if you can’t take my order it does me no good!!!

BEST PIZZA! I love this pizza so much I even bring some with me when I’m not visiting. The pasta options are delicious too.

I showed up a half hour before they were closing asked for a slice and they said «no.» I know the guy wanted to leave on time, but when I go to a pizza place a half hour before they close, they should be able to accommodate a slice of their main product.

I moved to the area over a year ago and it’s easy to say that Bedminster Pizza is my favorite pizza joint. My husband and I try to eat at home or carb free most of the time. So Bedminster Pizza is actually our cheat meal go to each week!
The pies have the perfect amount of tangy sauce and just enough cheese that a slice can hold itself up. It’s remarkable how every plain pie I have ordered tastes just as good as the last. I haven’t had any toppings, like other reviewers, I believe true pizza is a good plain pie. However, the guys have been kind enough to add pepperoni on two slices just for my husband. They are the best!
I haven’t ran into The Donald or any football players yet but it’s usually filled with friendly locals like myself and that’ll do fine for me.

Bedminster Pizza passes the real test. That test is a plain pizza. The plain pie is the only benchmark that matters to a pizza purest. There is good pizza all over central Jersey but this place has the best plain pie.
Of course they, like most pizzeria’s now, also offer all of the optional goodies. They have a great Margarita and they do many exotic combinations.
Donald Trump endorsing their pizza means a lot since he is a veteran New Yorker, I’m not sure Mark Sanchez has the same street cred. In fairness he was probably exposed to some of the best pizza in the NY /​NJ area too.
I found this place on Unilocal. Already I can vouch for the pizza, an awesome garden salad, the fresh mozzarella and prosciutto wrap and the chicken Cesar wrap as well. When you see the effort that goes into their garden salad you know it will all be great.
My perception of the plain pie is that most pizza places want to make a serviceable quality pizza but few are trying to make the best. I know two places in NJ that you will be eating truly great pizza when you go there: Star Tavern in Orange, and Bedminster Pizza.

Best pizza in the area by far. Order here whenever I’m in the area, and it’s always fantastic. Greasy, limp, and fantastic, just the way pizza is supposed to be. No delivery, but pick up is super quick. They also have a nice Italian restaurant next door.

Ordered cheese pizza when i brought it home the pizza looked as if it were sitting around OLD. Dough WASNOT freshly made! Disappointing

We get our pizza from here whenever we order, and while it might not be the BEST pizza on the East Coast, it is DEFINITELY the best in the area. The sauce is good. The prices are fair. The staff is very nice. On top of the pizza, a lot of their other entrees are surprisingly delicious. Definitely a neighborhood staple.

Pizza isn’t bad, but leaves some room to be desired. Limited menu, and pricing isn’t very competitive in comparison to other pizza places in town. Convenient location, but I would go other places first.

Always know I can get a nice quality pizza without any hassle here. They are friendly and make a good pie for the price. I have only purchased pizza here.

Definitely best pizza around. My 4 year old eats 2 slices of regular. Not the best diet, but she loves it and does not want to get any other.

With Sanchez and Trump endorsing this great little eatery, do you really need mine?
But this review goes beyond just pizza (which is fantastic in the fundamentals of what make a right pizza), but the eggplant. Eggplant that isn’t too thick, isn’t too fried, is a hidden luxury. You wouldn’t expect a little pizzeria to have some of the best eggplant in town, but it really does.
It also helps that the people that work here are really nice and that the prices are fair. It’s not only a Bedminster-​staple, but it’s a haven from the me-​too overpriced restaurants that are way too common in upper Somerset County.
And just a final word on the pizza — get the white cheese topped with broccoli, chicken, and eggplant. You won’t regret it.

Quite possibly the best pizza I have ever had (then again, when Donald Trump declares this place as his favorite pizza, it has to be pretty good!)
The pizzas have the perfect combination of cheese, sauce, and breading.
What more can I say other than this is a must-​try for anybody who appreciates pizza.

I have only had the pizza here and nothing more. For that, however, they are one of – if not thee — best in the local area. Coming from the south end I usually take either 202N or 206N and never find myself on the short stretch between where this place is. If it was not for Unilocal I would have never known it was there.

We decided to give Bedminster Pizza a try from rumors. Mark Sanchez gets his pizza here. If you follow sports, you know how vocal he gets about his pizza.
They have good pizza. The sauce is delicious, cheese coverage was good, and the crust has a good texture. It’s a thinner crust that’s crispy instead of a lot of the soft doughy crusts in the area. However, as good as the crust is, it’s missing something texture wise that’s keeping it from getting the «As good as it gets» rating and placing it into contention with NYC pizza.

Probably the best pizza I have had this year. I was surprised when my brother picked this particular pizzeria to meet at for lunch, because, in my memory, the food was only average. He assured me that «they don’t have the best selection of specialty slices, but if you just want a cheese slice, it’s definitely the best in the area.» So I tried it again. WOW. I was blown away. I order 1 slice to start with because I knew I had leftovers back at the office. But after one slice I said «F the leftovers, this is too good» and ordered two more.
Seriously, this was fantastic cheese pizza. I can’t speak to their other food (though the lady next to us had an intriguing looking meatloaf parm sandwich on her plate), but, coming from this pizza snob, I’m def. going to be going back.