Panatieri’s Pizza & Pasta

The food is good. Service is TERRIBLE. 3 times now they have forgotten something on my order. The staff is disorganized. I cringe every time I order that it will get messed up.

Great pizza! Tons of variety and place is usually packed! Awesome Brooklyn Grandma slice. Definitely best pizza in the Bedminster area– I highly recommend it. I also got salads, rolls, and subs from there and they are top notch. Nothing better than pizza and a relaxing football Sunday. This place is high quality and you need to try it. Clean, great service and overall tasty food.

Best pizza around! We have tried all the places near our house and always drive the 20 mins to get pizza! Love it!

Man, I’ve missed New Jersey. The bar for pizza in this state is high. Even though the locals may not find this place to be all that exciting, they do really good work.
Pizza’s are hand formed. The pies are cooked directly on the oven floor. The sauce has character. The cheese has actual flavor. And toppings are delicious.
Now, I know what you may be saying to yourself if you’re from Jersey. That’s just the definition of pizza. What else would it be? But in most of the country, pizzas don’t even begin to measure up to the minimum criteria of the form. It’s a tragedy. And yet, somehow, pizza is one of America’s favorite foods.
I was into the rosemary added to the sauce, and I loved the bottom crust. I did wish for more end crust, and more lift. But a slice at Panatieri’s really hit the spot.

Been here twice got regular pizza once and a stuffed slice the next time. Was not impressed either time. Food tasted very generic and recycled. Not fresh or homemade at all.

Best pizza place in Bedminster. Their pizza selection is awesome and their entrees surprisingly are great. Not just for pizza, cool atmosphere, but not too many places to sit. Also a BYOB. We pay this place a weekly visit now.

We’ve only ever had the pizza — slices usually. Maybe not the best, but much better than average. The standards are good, but their specialty pizzas are hit-​or-​miss. All in all, I’d say a B+ to an A-.
The selection pizzas is OUTSTANDING and happily are available all the way to closing. The staff is very friendly and the dining room is pleasant — especially for what is primarily a pizza joint.

Chicken dishes are disgusting. They put so much salt in the sauce it tastes like you’re eating in the ocean. Servers are rude and are on the phone the whole time

Having never been to a Panatieri’s before, I was a little worried that a «chain» pizza place was opening up. Upon first slice, I was clearly mistaken. Definitely my favorite pizza in the area. Bedminster Pizza was the previous winner, but even their slices can get a bit soggy at times. Panatieri’s uses the right amount of (delicious) sauce, throwing on a heap of cheese, and always cooks it to the right texture. I’m not really worried about any of the odd pizza slices they sell (another reviewer gave them a poor review due to this selection) as I tend to keep it pretty standard and always order a full pie at a time.
Now I want pizza. Thanks.

Been here a few times for pizza and once for dinner entrée. Huge variety of slice pizza selections as soon as you enter. They have all your standard toppings and quite a few gourmet flavors like chicken masala, cheesesteak and chicken Caesar salad pizza. The spinach gourmet has fresh vegetable toppings with tomato, mozzarella cheese and spinach. I especially like their deep dish pizza with the crispy crust. They have Sicilian pizza too. They run half price entrée specials on Mondays with the purchase of any drink which is not bad at all. The staff here are pretty friendly. Definitely going to give Rocco’s some competition.

I’m a huge Panatier’s fan (see my other reviews for the Warren, Flemington, Martinsville and Bound Brook locations). I was excited this one coming up in Bedminster as we could work another Panatieri’s into our rotation. This one is about 5 – 6 miles away from the Martinsville location on the same road. I frequent the Warren location most often.
I like Panatieri’s because they have a great slice pie selection. I’ve grown to love the Cheesesteak, Chicken Parm and Buffalo Chicken slices. During lunch time, they usually have at least 25 – 30 different pies to choose from. I’ve only been to this location once and it was pretty late (past dinner time and probably around 8 or 9pm), so I may have to give them a little bit of a pass there.
When I entered, the slice selection was pretty much nonexistent. It was very few specialty slices and mainly regular pies. The cheesesteak slice is excellent at other locations but wasn’t very good here. There was barely any meat and cheese. The other slices were just OK, as well.
I’m chalking the miss here up to this place just opening and being a little later in the day. I’ll definitely be giving this place another shot, and if they get back on track, I’ll gladly update my review. As an FYI, this place is in the same shopping complex as the Fresh Market so there’s plenty of parking.