Yarmouth Pizza By Evan

Got the three cheese spaghetti it was just cooked spaghetti with cheese piled on top and sauce plopped over it. It was a little over rated.

Great pizza! ! I had Vegetable pizza today and it is so good! Also, great service!

Used to order here all the time but began going elsewhere after a few orders came out wrong; over cooked, missing dips, etc… Last time we ordered we were ordering for a small gathering. When I got to the 4^th pizza the man on the phone said «THERES MORE!» very rudely as if he just wanted to get off the phone asap then passed me over to another person. (What kind of food establishment doesn’t want to take your order?)
About a half hour later I received a call to go over the order. The man apparently missed an item on the order so the entire thing was late, the food that had been ordered had clearly sat too long while they made the item they forgot. There was no apology given. Very disappointing.

Very good pizza. The pizza had nice thick crust, I like that. People were friendly, it was a very relaxed eating conditions.
I like it allot.
Thank you!

Love this place. Their pizza is very good. Their crust is light, almost a pan pizza style vs the New York style I typically get. Plus they did a great job accommodating our gluten /​dairy allergies. We were on the Cape a week and ate there twice.

Good pan pizza and salads and YES they deliver!

Love their food. If you are looking for a quick bit their pizza and salads are my fav. Plus they deliver.

The food is sometimes OK, sometimes not. Counter supervisor is abrasive, rude, and controlling. So many other places are good.
We had unpleasant experiences there and can relate to Puzzled L.‘s experience, below. It seems their current policy is: We’re proud of being rigid and rude and we don’t care if we lose longtime, year-​round customers. Well, you lost more than that, honey. We’ve sent at least 10 friends elsewhere for pizza. And there are several better places on the Cape.
Here is Puzzled L.‘s review, which was deleted for some reason by Unilocal.
Puzzled L.
Northborough, MA
0 friends
1 review
1.0 star rating 7÷10÷2015
First let me start by saying the Pizza is good here. That is why we have been long standing loyal customers we have referred many people to this establishment and have spend a great deal of money over the years.
I ordered lunch today and it was a small pizza and small grinder. I headed back to work and stopped at the park to eat my grinder. When I opened the grinder and picked it up my fingers went right through the soggy bread and the filling fell on lap all over my dress pants and naturally I stood up and brushed it of my clothes. Back to work with no lunch.
It seems they put all veggies on including the lettuce and put in the oven. Oddly enough the bread was black around all the edges the inside was a sloppy HOT MESS. NOT EDIBLE. Soggy inside and out. I asked them to go light on the lettuce and seemed all that was on there was lettuce which I think is what made the bread soggy in the oven.
The pizza we had ordered had no cheese… well I think a saw three little strands on there.
Granted we order our pizza light sauce and a little lighter on the cheese due the person eating it can not handle a lot of sauce at one time. (this one loaded with sauce) an no cheese to be had on this pizza. Strange thing was it was not ready when we got there.
We have been ordering the same thing for years in fact when we call they know who we are and actually know our order and when we eat in they come over and say hello. It was not until today after I called which promoted me to write this review.
I called and informed them of the sloppy grinder with wet bread and the soggy no cheese pizza and she said «oh just bring the food back and we will see what we can do». I informed her that the filling of my grinder was on the ground and the most of the sauce had been scrapped of the pizza which took most of the mushrooms off and ended up tossing in the garbage at the gas station as I only had an hour for lunch.
I said «I would greatly appreciated if you could provide a small pizza and grinder at some time due to these were not correct or even edible» She said NO our policy is you have to bring the food back. I explained again and she said ok let me talk to the owner and I said great due to the owner knows what loyal customers and nice customers we have been over many years.
I did not hear back from them so when I got home from work with my soggy bread still I the grinder bag I called and asked her if she spoke to the owner and she said yes and told me again «you need to bring the food back»
I said «would you be so kind as to tell her who is calling» not that I am special but I thought if she knew it was a long standing good customer they would accommodate a replacement another time as are regulars.
She came back on the phone and said she is busy and said sorry that is our policy we need the food back. I then informed her to let the owner know that if that is her decision that we would not be coming back anymore. AND without putting me on hold she yelled across the room and said «they said if we do not assist they said they are not coming back» she comes back to the phone and said «she said she is sorry to hear that and hung up on me»
I was so SHOCKED by the response I got in my car and drove the soggy bread still in the bag and asked for the lady on the phone and put the grinder down on the counter in front of her. Her response was oh you have it let me see what we can do and I said NO THANK YOU.
Please tell the owner we will never come back to this establishment. Now she wanted to apologize due to other customers were there.
When they opened did anyone learn the benefit of a loyal customer who refers people and the negative impact of bad customer service to any customer. Word of mouth goes a long way.
SHOCKED AND PUZZLED… they sent away long time customer who never complained over a small pizza and small grinder… really…WOW

Good pizza and subs. Place is Very noisy! You can’t have a conversation. The hard wood floors and bare walks reflect everything. Service beer and wine, couple TV’s.

Wow! Great pizza but the wings were Amazing!!! We just moved to west Dennis today and this is the place we chose off of Unilocal.And we were so rewarded! The crust on the pizza was crispy and flavorful! We thought the wings were missing sauce but then we realized the spice was baked in. And realized they were the best wings ever! We will most definitely be ordering again!

Incredible! I had the Greek salad with baklava for «dessert». Great baklava… Would definitely recommend.

Excellent Greek style pizza. It’s our «go too» pizza joint and is always fresh and tasty. My favorite is the Special which is delicious with lots mushrooms and black olives. We normally get take out (not a big fan of TVs in restaurants). Establishment is very clean and staff friendly.

Ordered subs, eggplant was not great at all. I think it might have been frozen eggplant; it was mushy, sliced very thick and skin was on the eggplant. This was my first time stopping here and not sure I would stop again. The place seemed very busy; so not sure what the fuss about this place is.

Had pizza and salad delivered to the beach so we could take in the sunset. Dinner was delivered in about 30 mins, pizza was cooked crispy as requested and Greek salad was great as well.

my family had the spaghetti and meatballs, a large pepperoni pizza and a lg toasted roast beef grinder. loved them! mother-​in-​law had the chili but was not impressed. we noticed some baklava but didn’t try it. hot coffee is green mountain and donut house k cups. good selection of bottled beers, flavored waters, juices and coke products. We will come back for more.

My fiancé and I drove out here after staying in Hyannis because it’s rave reviews. Sadly we weren’t terribly impressed. It was tasty but nothing special. I wouldn’t go out of my way to come back. Prices are fair.

Stopped in mid-​afternoon for a quick bite. Ordered a small pizza, which undoubtedly was made fresh, as it took 23 minutes and came out «burn the roof of your mouth» hot. It was fine for a passing-​thru lunch. Not a place I’d seek out or be a regular if I lived in the area, but wouldn’t go out of my way to avoid it, either.

Extremely disappointed after bringing my family here. Was really looking forward to a nice pizza, Unilocal reviews suggested we would find that here. What we got was an over-​cooked crust, bad toppings, and very bland pizza. The most tasteless pizza in recent memory. Pepperoni was pretty sparse, and the green pepper and onion were thin sliced rather than chopped. Whole rings of stringy cooked onion are not fun to eat, and my daughter literally gagged on one.
I also ordered a side of buffalo chicken tenders. These were one step up from disgusting. Microwaved frozen chicken strips with buffalo sauce dumped on them as an after thought. Pretty terrible. Too bad I paid up front with tip before we got our meal. Wish we had skipped this place. A pizza place that can’t get pizza right, who would have thought?

With a name like «Yarmouth Pizza by Evan» one would think they are not getting the same old same olé.
And one would be right.
We ordered the usual pizza fare (grilled chicken and mushroom). We received a most interesting interpretation of pizza that was most certainly outside the usual.
Thin crust, thick crust, cracker crust, deep dish. There are many ways to get a pizza. As a consummate New Yorker, thin crust, extra sauce, a little light on the cheese, and whatever toppings, is the how I roll. Who needs a bread log, or a cheesy gut bomb?
OK, back to the point. This was a mezze deep dish, half cheese, pepper chicken, fresh mushroom, disk of mass culinary perfection.
Or, in plain English: if you want something a little different, yet delicious – get a pizza from Evan.

We’ve been going to this place for years now, through several changes of management (we sort of miss the lady who went back to Iceland who ran the place for a while), since it’s the closest (good) pizza place near the Homestead, and there’s a sort of winter Evan’s and a summer Evan’s change in vibes.
The summer Evan’s has a crazy parking lot, a ton of traffic in and out, lots of delays in orders and slow delivery. Summer Evan’s also requires a ton of bravery to make the turn off 6A; I strongly recommend entering and exiting via the back entrance on Weir Rd., and not even thinking about parking out front.
The winter Evan’s has a regular clientele, is an affable place to have a beer, is prompt and cheerful, and rarely if ever gets orders wrong.
In general the pizza is quite decent at both summer and winter Evan’s — slightly thicker neapolitan style with generous toppings (the Evan’s Special is like getting a refrigerator on top of your pizza) with decent if not spectacular crust, cheese, and sauce. And the other dishes are Evan’s are sort of hit or miss; expensive and unremarkable wings, dangerously weird subs, salads that have varied between inedible iceberg to decent Greek salad.
The décor and layout inside are deeply odd — the booths don’t fit the spaces well, the one TV is oriented so you an see it well from about three seats in the whole place, the bar is lined up without stools taking up more space than the busy ordering counter, and the best tables are the little ones tucked away in the corner.
If this seems like a tepid review for a four-​star, it’s because the sum of Evan’s is way more than just its constituent parts. Despite its drawbacks there’s nearly always a decent vibe there and the pizza is very good by Cape standards.