Jamestown Pie Company

The chocolate pecan pie and the peanut pie are the best I’ve ever had anywhere. They also have delicious authentic Turkish baklava and rice pudding. A great place for take out.

I’ve been driving by this place for the last 4 – 5 years and have never had a chance to stop by, I finally did and was not disappointed.
Ordered a 11inch cheese pizza for 11.98. More then enough for for lunch for 2 – 3 people. Definitely check out

Hi,
I am from New England and grew up close to NYC so unfortunately I am very biased as well as my husband on pizza. Well we have been trying to find a decent pizza place in the Hampton Roads area and this place has come pretty close to our standards (which you can take or leave dependent on how well you understand the NYC pizza cult). We have had the Artichoke pizza which includes spinach and garlic on there. The sauce was great and they put a great amount of veggies and cheese on top. We have also tried the Tuscan which has Feta, Roma tomatoes and spinach, this was also a great pizza. The crust is thin but not too thin and crispy and doughy at the same time, a good consistency.
One time while we were waiting for a in house takeout order, the guys working there gave us a free slice of pecan pie while we were waiting. It was delicious. We’ve also had their chicken pot pie in the past which reminds me of home. Good quality ingredients and well worth the price. Please check them out!

Love love all the pies! Fruit pies and chicken pot pies!!! Delicious!!! The person that assisted me was the owner. Very very nice and helpful!!!

Stopped in for lunch. I quickly devoured my roast beef sandwich and fries– eyeing the slices of pie sitting patiently on the table. Strawberry rhubarb pie was a little tangy and blackberry peach was sweet. The pie crust was buttery and flaky.
No seating inside, but there are a couple of picnic tables with umbrellas outside.

This is a perfect local spot to try out. We had a gourmet pizza pie (The a River Crab Pizza), the Philly Cheese Steak & a chicken pot pie. Everything was amazing! The owner was very hospitable and went out of his way to make sure everything was to our liking. There is no seating inside, as most people order to carry out or to have delivered, but they do have a few picnic tables with umbrellas right outside the restaurant for you to sit and enjoy the food. This is definitely a great place to pick when you’re in town!

Let me begin by saying that I have three daughters who rarely agree about an establishment. If one of them loves it, another hates it and the third is indifferent, you know? The Jamestown Pie Company ended that for a night.
Our family of five ordered a chicken and veggie pot pie and a blueberry peach pie, and we feasted. The crust on the pot pie was flaky and buttery. Perfect. This pie was extremely fresh. It was different from other pot pies I’ve had because it had mashed potatoes rather than a bunch of gravy inside. Delicious.
The blueberry peach pie was also fantastic. The crust on this one was a little bit dense and had been glazed somehow. It wasn’t the same as the crust on the pot pie, but it was still good. The filling was the perfect mixture of sweet and tart.
The gentleman behind the counter was great. He was friendly and helpful. He came outside to make sure we enjoyed our food later in the meal.
This is only a four-​star review for a couple reasons. One, the building exterior makes the place look a bit jenky. It’s important to note that the interior was cramped but pleasant and, most importantly, CLEAN. Two, we had to resort to our fifth or sixth choice on the blueberry peach pie in order to avoid a wait of almost an hour in 90° weather. The only place to wait is on a couple of tiny benches inside near the hot kitchen or outside where it was actually cooler. Three, all they had were paper plates and plastic ware and even those were in short supply. I’m no snob. I eat on that at home frequently. Pot pies and dessert pies are hard to be cut into and served with a crappy plastic fork and knife though. Four, it was a bit pricy. For two pies and nothing else, I spent $ 42 before I tipped for the excellent service I received despite the fact that the gentleman was extremely busy.
Most importantly, the food was great. Everyone agreed that it should be a regular stop in our rotation moving forward.

It was remarkable! The pizza had just the right texture. It’s innovative and creative. A very relaxed place to eat and they have great size pizza. The gentleman at the front was very welcoming and very informed on every meal on the menu. It’s a little shack on the side of the road but it’s a diamond in the rough.

I just happened to find this place because I searched the web. I am from buffalo New York and in the area for a week visiting family. I took my son and niece here. They have a very nice outdoor sitting area. I was very impressed with the pecan pie and pizza. The customer service was amazing, I will defiantly be back.

I was really hoping to love this place but it wasn’t meant to be. The BBQ pork sandwich was overwhelmed with a huge bread roll. The pizza was just ok. I had high hopes for the pie — but it was just ok.
You only get one chance for a good impression. This place was really cute but it took a long time to get our food. The employees were arguing about something. Theres no indoor seating. The picnic tables were in full sun but at the end of our meal the umbrellas were brought out. I feel they were trying but just didn’t make a good impression with me.
Good luck.

Visiting from CT and found this awesome pizza joint… seafood one yummy. Tasty crust

This some good ass pie! Why did no one tell me how good this pie was?!
Chocolate pecan is dank AF.

This little place sits off the highway between Williamsburg and the Jamestown Settlement. My boyfriend loves pie while I’m not a fan, so we stopped in while leaving Jamestown on the way to the Outerbanks. They were baking the pies fresh, so we waited about 15 minutes for he Cherry Berry to come out of the oven. Hey, if waiting 15 minutes gets me out of learning to bake pies, I’ll take it! We also picked up a Chocolate Pecan pie. Not only did my boyfriend love the pies, so did my sister, mom and nephew! My 18 month old nephew devoured the small slice of berry pie we fed him and proceeded to climb into everyone else’s lap to eat theirs! I even enjoyed the sliver of Chocolate Pecan pie I tried! If you’re passing through, definitely stop at this shop. The pies held up really well in the two hour drive we had.

We tried chocolate pecan, coconut, Apple and strawberry peach. All delicious but the coconut was by far the best! The crust of the pies were all flaky and tasty. The fruit filling tasted fresh. The coconut though was so good! Definitely worth the money. I’d highly recommend stopping in for a slice or whole pie (we did both!!). We will absolutely visit again!

My family has been buying pies from here for 6 years. Now that we no longer live in the area we travel during the holiday season just for these pies. I love the coconut custard and blueberry peach pies. The crusts on the crust pies is so buttery and light. I cannot say enough great things about the flavor of these pies. Once you try them you will not want a pie from anywhere else.

My husband and I decided to try this popular Jamestown Pie Co while on vacation. We got the Bumbleberry, Strawberry rhubarb, chocolate pecan and Blueberry peach. They are all amazing pies! I was surprised because I wasn’t into fruit pies but everything was delicious! My favorite was the chocolate pecan. The staff was also really nice to us and very friendly. We will definitely come back to try out their other pies.

I’ve been here twice in the last 3 years I have lived here. Both times the staff was friendly and informative. I most recently had rhubarb pie and it was excellent. Reminded me of being a little girl, messing around in my grandmas garden, and helping her harvest rhubarb for us to make pie with. I loved that they had such an extensive menu for being a pie place. It’s a nice treat to come here after visiting Colonial Williamsburg, Jamestown settlement, or BG.

I’d been meaning to try out Jamestown Pie Company for quite some time, as I’d heard about their sweet and savory pies. They offer nuts and fruit pies, as well as deep dish pot pies, pizza pies, and sandwiches. When we went earlier in the day, I was disappointed that they had no savory pies available, but only a limited selection of sweet pies. I got to try out their chocolate pecan pie (it was more chocolate than pecan, but had a good amount of pecans on top) and the key lime pie (we actually came back later for this, as it was stated that it was going to be baked later in the day; it was more sweet than tart, which I was not a fan of). Volcan was the friendly employee that helped us, and even though we weren’t a fan of their pies, I’m glad I was still able to check them out. I hope to try out their deep dish pot pies one day, when available!
+limited selection in pies
+savory pies’ availability is extremely rare
+ask for Volcan: D

NOMNOMNOMNOM
That is all that needs to be said. Everything that comes out of this tiny kitchen will feel like a warm embrace for your tastebuds. Jeezum there are no words for how wonderful this place is.
Get the key lime pie. It’s the best thing I’ve ever tasted. Ever. Ever.

I love tiny no frill places like this. It tells you they’re serious business about the product. We stopped here and bought a pecan pie and blueberry peach pie. When you walk in, it’s a very narrow waiting area with pies cooling on large racks nearby, making it smell wonderful. The blueberry peach pie had just come out of the oven, and made my car smell wonderful on the drive back.
Two pies for $ 30 after a coupon in one of the tourist guides. In DC, you’d pay about $ 20 – 25 just for ONE pie, so to us city people, that was a pretty good deal. I liked the pecan pie more than the blueberry peach, but both were tasty. It makes sense, since pecan seems to be their signature.