Great thin crust pizza. I wish I lived closer I’d get it more often. A small pie is a good size for two people. The pepperoni is really good. The sauce was well seasoned and not too sweet. It has a nice crispy thin crust and perfect amounts of melty hot cheese!!!
Jonathon M.
Classificação do local: 5 San Francisco, CA
One of the best thin crust pies in NEPA. my girlfriend and I stopped in for a small pie, had a beer or two and by the time we got home we realize we were still laundry and end up ordering a second pie and picking it up now or later. Bottom line the pizza is awesome!
Cynthia B.
Classificação do local: 5 Nanticoke, PA
OMG!!! my Fav ! You must get this .! Extra cheese and Mushroom! I can eat this every day !
Geno P.
Classificação do local: 2 San Diego, CA
Shelley’s sells New York style pizza for $ 10 for a large. It is bar pizza at best, and brings new meaning to «thin crust.» It is so thin it looks like they made the pizza and then ran over it with an elephant or tow truck. If you are buying for multiple people, buy multiple pizzas. It’s so thin you can eat an entire large and still be hungry. We’ve had this pizza twice now at people’s parties, and the pies were unimpressive on each occasion. Also, Shelley’s does not accept credit/debit cards as payment. It is cash only. In 2014, you can decide for yourself if you trust any restaurant that isn’t even capable of handling credit card transactions. Personally, it’s a no-go for me.
Bob B.
Classificação do local: 4 Easton, PA
Great thin crust pizza at a decent price. The place is something of a dive; we get it to go. You can also get beer here. Honestly, I like Shelley’s more than any Old Forge style — shhhh! My main complaint is that calling in to order — often times they will not pick up the phone, so we end up spending money at Classic in Plymouth(and they also deliver).