Magnotta’s Pizzeria & Restaurant

Outstanding oldtime thin crust pizza. Really a throwback to the way pizza is supposed to be!

Simply the best pizzeria in White Plains. My fiancé loves the white pizza from here and I’m a big fan of the garlic knots. The only thing I don’t like about this place is sometimes the staff comes off as rude, but other than that it’s a great local restaurant.

Friendly, but pricey !!

By far my favorite pizza place. Not only is the pizza delicious but the pasta dishes are great too (penne alla vodka)… Would highly recommend

Great place! The owner and staff are extremely friendly. They truly make me feel welcome every time I visit. The pizza and sandwiches are excellent. Must try the grandma pizza. Hands down the best I’ve ever had.

It was a cold night out and my co worker and I had a couple hours to kill before we had to go back to the hospital. We came in to the restaurant in a fluke and were happy we did. The staff was very helpful and nice. We each ordered a slice of pizza and it was very tasty. Thick yummy crust with a good tomato base sauce. We will be coming back for sure.

I was seated by one of the guys behind the pizza counter immediately. First off, let me say that I dont know if the waitress was high or had a disability, but the sniffing and slurred speech can be anything, right? So, I apologize if Im wrong. Ok, I didnt feel like walking far from the hospital, but I was lazy so a few people suggeste this place and said it was ok. Its a pizzeria, but I ordered the Deluxe Cheesburger and it was fuckin delicous!!. The burger had a nice charred flavor, cooked exactly how I wanted it and my fries were cooked exactly how I had asked, which was on the well done side. My waitress was very attentive without being annoying. The Pinot Grigio was nicely chilled, too. Overall, I was pleasantly surprised. I guess next time I should try the pizza, but that cheeseburger was the shit!!!

The pizzas and salads iare great. I’ve been going to Magnotta’s a long time. Service is great and so is delivery.

Used to order a few times a week until one time received a completely wrong order. Called to see if they would correct it and the old guy that is the owner was the biggest prick… haven’t ordered since, place is a hole in the wall anyway with food that really isn’t any better than any other pizza places nearby… oh and I forgot how EXPENSIVE THEY ARE

Five stars for great pizza and fast delivery, 1 star off for being cash-​only and fairly pricey. That said, I’ve tried the cheaper pizza places around here (Famous Famiglia, eww), and they just don’t compare.

Im here when I need a pizza break while at work… everything else in the area just doesn’t do pizza justice… trust me… some of the other shops may offer you free pies but hands down you will want to hand it back… Magnotta’s has that family appeal and makes a real good slice…

Good sicilians and focaccia slices

Decent Pasta, very large potions. Hole in the wall but good. Worth checking out.

I tried this pizza out and it’s your basic good slice. good amount of sauce to cheese ratio. Dough is thin and crispy. But the crust is too crispy… not doughy/​chewy/​flavorful enough for me. Good though.
UPDATE:
I recently had pizza at Mamma Mia’s, Magnotta’s and Italian Pavilion all in a couple days. I’d have to say that the 3 are VERY similar! Italian Pavilion is the most floppy of the slices. The other two are more crispy.