Schneider’s Bakery

This is a great little bakery! The doughnuts were so fresh and light. Try the daily special for a deal to start your day off right! A cup of coffee and a doughnut for $ 1.25! I had the chocolate covered cream filled doughnut. One word-​yum! The raspberry and cream cheese danishes were being sampled and they are also delightful! The ladies working there are also super sweet! Love this little gem!

Best place for donuts! We go every Friday morning to try something new. The donuts are so warm and soft and tasty. The pastries are amazing! The cookies are so great! Best of all, the people who work there make you feel like family. Cash or check only so come prepared! But they’re the best on this side of Columbus!

Got 24 cupcakes for our daughters 4^th birthday. They were outstanding! Thank you very much for making them stand out at the birthday party. Everyone loved the scooby doo theme, and the cupcakes reminded me of the mystery machine with little dig bones on them. Your cake was very delish last year as wel… Thank you very much!

This place is AMAZING. Get here early enough and the donuts are still warm. It’s become a habit to grab donuts and milk once a week on our way taking my son to school. A nice treat and I would HIGHLY suggest everyone fix their sweet tooth here!

We ordered a «Celebration Donut» for our daughter’s 11^th birthday. This is basically a giant, old fashioned donut meant to serve 15 – 20 people. You can get it frosted, with sprinkles and a message for only $ 18! None of us knew what to expect when I ordered it, but my daughter remarked that visually, it exceeded her expectations! Later, at the party everyone was exceedingly pleased with how it tasted too! It was the perfect old fashioned donut. It wasn’t grossly over-​frosted so you could actually taste the donut and not just it’s accoutrements! As one of the 12 yr old guests critiqued, the texture was superb! Get one of these if the guest of honor in your life loves and appreciates a good donut! It’ll blow their minds and it’s a fun alternative to a cake!

I was a first-​time customer of this bakery. I ordered one pumpkin pie and one strawberry pie, as well as two dozen turkey cookies. Overall, we were pretty let down with the quality of the product. On the positive side, the staff was very friendly and polite. That is the main reason I am giving two stars.
The pumpkin pie was made with what really seemed to be a frozen pie shell. I asked when ordering if everything made by scratch, and was assured it was. However, the pumpkin pie had the same uniform crimped edge as every supermarket pie I have always seen. It just didnt look like it was done by hand. But, the flavor was good… but nothing remarkable.
The strawberry pie was much different. Its crust looked much more homemade, but when we sliced it, we were amazed with the lack of strawberries. Instead, it was filled with a super sugary glaze containing a few pieces of berry. My piece of pie had two half– berries and the rest was glaze filling.
I wish I could give them higher ratings, because the people are nice and I appreciate that it is family owned. But, unfortunately what they provided was really no better than grocery store quality.

Beautiful and delicious cakes at incredible prices. Staff is very friendly and helpful. FYI — cash and check only. I was caught off guard on my first pickup. :)

The donuts are pretty good not amazing. Their service on a busy Saturday morning was phenomenal. Will be going back again

Great place for doughnuts and a hidden gem of Columbus/​Westerville if you ask me. I’m unsure if this place has the best doughnuts in Columbus, but it should make the top 10 list. There’s always a line out the door on Saturday mornings even at 8 AM. The prices are low like everyone says. You’d spend more at Dunkins Donuts and not get as many as you would here plus they taste way better. Love this place and will be making more stops during the future here.

Ordered 9″ cake & a dozen cupcakes for daughter’s 16^th birthday. First, the price was outstanding, half the price as other specialty bakeries in the area.
Service was incredibly awesome! I had a specific idea for the cake & they were honest about what they could & could not do. I wanted mini donuts around the edge, they have one size fits all donut sizes so they suggested I drop off my own minis, totally ok w/​that since they were. Their donuts were a bit too big & heavy to stack on top so I just bought a few donuts from Krispy Kreme & decorated it.
I never got to try the cupcakes or take pics, damn kids ate them before I got a chance!
But the inside of the cake was exactly what I asked for & the taste & texture were perfect. I could tell they had fun making it & I enjoyed working with them.
I will definitely go back, but I really want to try their huge ass donut cake, maybe just for myself…

EMILY MAKES DELICIOUS WEDDING CAKES! I am
by no means a «cake person» and I could not get enough of the cake that Emily made for us. We had a three tier, almond and strawberry cake with cream cheese frosting. The cake was very affordable and it looked like a million bucks! I don’t have my professional pics back quite yet but I uploaded one that my friend snapped. It really was perfect. I had a lot of compliments from my guests on how creamy and moist the cake was. I’m already trying to think of the next possibly occasion that I could have her make me another cake!

These are supposed to be some of the best donuts in Columbus.
They were good, but I don’t know about the best. Granted I bought them in the middle of the afternoon, so maybe they’re better first thing in the morning.
Overall though, not bad. They had a good variety and the staff was really friendly. I thought the prices were pretty nice too.

for my taste they use way too much sugar in both the cake and frosting. If you like the feeling of crunching on granulated sugar while eating a piece of fairly dry cake then this is your spot!

I bought assorted donuts to bring to work. They were so good and so reasonably priced. I definitely will be back. They also make this adorable huge cake sized donut for birthdays that would be so fun for kids or extreme donut lovers alike!

I had heard tons of great things about this bakery from my wife and her friends. They told stories of donut runs during their college years at Otterbein where they would go get a warm donut and a carton of milk for $ 1. My wife, in particular, raved about the Davy Crocket donut. It’s a braided donut with maple frosting on top.
I finally got an opportunity to go in last Saturday. Stepping in the front door, I breathed in deeply and smelled donut heaven. There’s nothing like walking into a bakery and smelling freshly baked donuts. My wife and I both bought a Davy Crocket donut and a carton of chocolate milk. We warmed up the donut in the microwave when we got home. The donut pretty much melted in my mouth, leaving me with a huge smile on my face. I just wish I had bought another one (or two more)!

Schneider’s is my go to local donut place. It has been a part of Westerville for as long as I can remember.
The donuts are good but not my favorite style. They are too bready for me. I am more of a Krispy Cream sugar fanatic. Everyone in my family disagrees with me on this but hey I’ve got to be me. There are a ton of other fresh baked goods to try but I wish there was a better donut selection.

Great bakery for old fashion donuts. Donuts here are so much better than any from chain donut shops. Cute shop located on the main street of Westerville. Only tried the donuts.

Schneider’s Bakery is a Westerville institution. It opens at 1:00 AM (yes — that’s 1 AM). I usually visit between 6:30 and 7:00 AM and there’s always a line for their fresh donuts. The team in my office always look forward to those occasions when I bring donuts because they know I always go to Schneider’s for my donuts.
This is a fantastic old fashioned bakery that is sticking to the basics.

Schneider’s doesn’t disappoint me every time! Last week, I got 2 dozens for a birthday potluck at work. not only are they affordable, they have the best doughnuts in town! Everyone loved it at work and it turns out most of them grew up going to Schneider’s! my favorites are the Bostom cream, glazed chocolate cake, raspberry filled, and lemon filled doughnut. I just can’t have enough of it!
Oh, just in case it’s your (whoever’s reading this) first time, they only accept cash. A dozen doughnuts is just under $ 8.

Wow. old school bakeries still exist!
Forget the multitudes of cupcakeries, cake popperies, and cutesy bakeries smothered in princess colors and think about the last time you actually had a really good pastry without the frill of pastel colored icing.
Think about the last time you actually had A REAL doughnut NOT from a chain or grocery store.
We were on this side of town on a Saturday morning and decided to give it a shot and apparently so did everyone else. Man, this place is hopping on a Saturday morning. and as it should be. We got in the tiny one room establishment filled with cases of sweet treats and delicious breakfast pastries and before we blinked the two of us ended up turning into 15 of us. all packed in like sardines.
Clearly. people love their doughnuts here.
Schneider’s isn’t just doughnuts either… Again, back to the old school bakery thing. there are no cake gimicks like magic sparklers, fancy fondants, or topsy turvy cakes… it’s all just simple. maybe some roses here and there, but just a simple wording on top. I can appreciate the simplicity. it cuts out the DIVA-​ness when it comes to buying cakes. Perhaps I will get a chance to try theirs someday.
Now. back to the doughnuts.
They have quite an array here, so get an assorted dozen, because all were pretty darn yummy and blood sugar crashing perfection.
Also, if you’re a cinnamon roll freak, then you might want to try the orange frosted ones they have. Just sayin’
I can definitely bookmark this as a place to visit come late night for sweet munchies.
Count me in! I’ll be bah-​ck!