Wild West Pizzeria & Saloon

Really good food here if you’re looking for pizza. Staff was prompt and attentive. I would eat here again.

Decent pizza is sometimes hard to find. But this place was a nice surprise. The crust was good, the cheese and toppings were generous. The pizza sauce was a little more spicy than I care for, but overall, we did serious damage to an 12inch, 8 pc. pizza. There are a few other foods on the menu, like spaghetti, some hot sandwiches, calzone, chicken wings, salad, and a nice list of beers and wines. Nothing too fancy.
This is a large place in comparison to what we have experienced so far in this tourist town. There is a large bar area with pool table, and there is a family friendly dining area in the back with an open kitchen. If you are in a hurry, better call in your order. Pizza takes time.

Food — 4
Service — 4
Value — 4
The best pizza place in West Yellowstone and also a surprisingly good pizza place overall regardless of location. I got the supreme pizza and the 8″ was just about right for my dinner (we had a light lunch that day) and the ingredients were fresh. My wife had the spaghetti and meatballs and she enjoyed them as well — really tender meatballs. We decided to sit at the bar rather than wait 30 minutes for a table since this place is popular. This was a great place to finish off a day where we did a lot of driving and hiking.

We were hankering for some pizza while on vacation in West Yellowstone. We were expecting a less than perfect pie, but instead got pizza perfection.
Also, this place is owned by a Steelers fan. So it is adorned with lotsa Steeler stuff displayed throughout the premises. Big thumbs up! Fabulous football and precious pepperoni pie!

I haven’t had pizza in a long time and we had a long day of driving into West Yellowstone — the reviews here said Best Pizza — they were right! We ordered a Italian sausages pizza and it was the best pizza I’ve had in a long time! A medium plus cheese sticks was plenty to fill 3 adults.
The staff wasn’t very friendly unfortunately –I ran out of water & I had to get up to ask for more. It was super busy but I was told that’s how it always is. I still rated it on the pizza as that was very good.
If you want pizza — Wild West Pizza is your place in west Yellowstone!

Great little saloon & pizzeria in West Yellowstone. We had the Wild West Supreme, Butch Cassidy and a plain pie. All were great, as are the local beers.
The Butch Cassidy sounds strange but try it … It’s delicious! We also split a chicken parmigiana which was OK. I’d recommend the pizzas here and the local beers. Give it a try, you won’t be disappointed!

I’ve been here three different times in 3 years, so I figured it was finally time to review!
Firstly, the food is good. On my visit this time around we ordered pizza, breadsticks, and mac’n’cheese. Everything was good and served hot. While not my favorite pizza, I still liked it and have to give it extra props for the fact that it reheated well in our hotel microwave.
We interacted with 3 different servers and all of them were attentive and nice. We even received great beer recommendations from one of them. Overall it’s always been a great experience. I think the «coke zero guy» should go hurl himself into a geyser for his petty review.

After a long day exploring Yellowstone, we headed back to town to find some grub. With its remote location, there aren’t terribly many options in West Yellowstone. After browsing the local grocery store and being sticker shocked by the prices, we decided to eat out. Wild West Pizzeria & Saloon just so happened to be right next door. Hesitant, but hungry and increasingly grumpy, we headed in.
When you enter the front door, you step into a dark saloon with live music playing. You don’t immediately notice the bright and notably quieter sit-​down pizzeria in the back. We ordered a variation of the Sitting Bull, with pepperoni, italian sausage, canadian bacon, genoa salami, and banana peppers, and it did not disappoint. Born and raised in western New York, it’s rare that we’ve found a memorably good pizza on our travels, but we still talk about this pizza. Never underestimate a place based on appearance or location — It’s always the restaurants that you least expect that end up pleasantly surprising you.

I will say this. The Pizza here is awesome it’s better than some of the Pizza place’s where I live in Florida. We ordered a large Pepperoni pizza with light sauce it took about 20 minutes to be delivered and we opened the Pizza box and was really impressed how the Pizza was made and cooked The Pizza didn’t have the sauce dripping off like some Pizza places make their pizza made.
The staff are very friendly and understanding what their customers want on a pizza when they are ordering one. We are really impressed with this place.
A+++