The Sweet Tooth Fairy

I bought a bakers dozen and another half dozen cupcakes today from the Sweet Tooth Fairy in West Valley City, located at Valley Fair Mall, thinking that this would be a fantastic treat for my team meeting tomorrow morning. After I arrived at home, I sampled one of the cupcakes and seriously wanted to throw-​up. I paid over $ 50 for 18 cupcakes (this amount includes a 15% tip) for something that tastes so awful that I find a place on the internet to write a review (and I do NOT write reviews) just to save some other poor soul from wasting money on this horrible dessert. The cupcake that I sampled was called Mint Chocolate. The cupcake itself was DRY and tasteless and the color of the cupcake was a washed out brown color. The frosting was so horribly sweet and sugary I thought my teeth were going to go into sugar shock! I am so upset with myself for spending all of this money on something that I should have baked myself for less that $ 8.00 and would have tasted 100 times better and not throw my body into sugar shock. I cannot imagine taking these cupcakes to work tomorrow and actually serving them to people that I like and respect. The only reason I am giving my rating three stars is because the server was friendly and the store décor is super cute! Oh, and by the way, I bought these same cupcakes about 6 months ago and did not experience the poor quality of product nor the extreme sugary overload on the frosting that is another reason I though I would give these cupcakes another try. Believe me when I say this, «I won’t be back!»

Beautiful place, nice music, great service and delicious cupcakes, I went there to buy some cupcakes to celebrate my baby girl’s birthday… I got a dozen of vanilla and another dozen of red velvet with cream cheese frosting and were amazing too sweet for me but my friends love them!
Thank you!

Okay, okay, hear me out. I rarely give out a solid 5 stars, but these homies definitely earned it.
Their décor is sweet (ha, get it?) and simple. The employee was so helpful and cute. For example, when I asked «what is your favorite treat?» She replied not with «all of them» or «hmm I don’t know» but with «I love the Chocolate Oreo cupcake and the homemade Oreo cookie.»
I appreciate people like that.
And although both Oreo treats looked incredible, it was another cookie that caught my eye and stopped me in my tracks. Brace yourself: a CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIE WITH COOKIE DOUGH ON TOP DIPPED IN CHOCOLATE AND SPRINKLED WITH CHOCOLATE CHIPS.
What.
Seeing as it was perfectly baked and reasonably priced, I had not other option but to purchase it. And boy oh boy, it was one of the greatest decisions I have ever made.
TIPS & TRICKS:
* Get the cookie. Just do it.

The cake bites are delicious. Need I say more? I think not. I love ordering a dozen different cake bites and enjoying all of the many favors, including the seasonal offerings they routinely make. Oreo Cookie and Lemon are two of my favorites. If you have a sweet tooth, do yourself a favor and go visit The Sweet Tooth Fairy.

I learned my lesson and I will only go to The Sweet Tooth Fairy. I stopped by today to get the sweet treats that are guaranteed yummy goodness. Over the weekend I tried a place in Orem, eventually giving those gross items to some cows. The lovely sweet fairy had compassion on me and my plight. I begged for forgiveness and swore I will ONLY go to The Sweet Tooth Fairy. I love everything at TSTF!!!

Love this place! The cupcakes are so moist, and the cake bites are to die for! The service is always so friendly at everyone location I have been to. A few of my favorites are Chocolate Chip Cookies Dough, Cookies and Cream, and Red Velvet. They always have seasonal cupcakes which are great! I tried the cupashake and it was too much for me, very sweet.

I love this place!!! I live out of state, but when I’m in town I frequent the Sweet Tooth Fairy as much as possible. On my most recent trip I fell in love with their Peppermint Deluxe Bars (Oreo bottom, peppermint frosting middle, chocolate top). They didn’t seem to make them as often after Christmas. After inquiring if they had any a few days in a row, they offered me a custom order. The service has been extremely helpful and they seem more than happy to accommodate special requests. I’ll be bringing a suitcase full of Cake Bites and Peppermint Deluxe Bars back to Oregon with me to share with friends! Watch out, yum yum!

The name of the place really does say it all. If you’re suffering with a sweet tooth, this little shop will cure you with their abundance of super sweet treats. They have a large variety of cupcakes in many flavors that I’ve never tried, and apparently the creator is a past winner of the show Cupcake Wars. I did try some cake bites in peanut butter pretzel, grasshopper and red velvet flavor. My favorite was the grasshopper which is like a mint chocolate. The others looked tasty, but were way too sweet for me to order again.

So yummy! Their Mango Raspberry cupcake was amazing! As well as their sugar cookies! I had the strawberry cupcake shaped cookie and the strawberry frosting had such a great strawberry flavor!

Awesome bakery. Pastries Never disappoints! However, there needs to be some sort of sensor at the door because on many occasions I’ve stood there waiting for more than 2 minutes contemplating on leaving as I listen to the girls in the back chat their life away in the back. It’s not enough to stop me from going there because I love it there… But it’s definitely something I’ll take to management if it continues to happen.

My Sweet Tooth Fairy has some of the best cupcakes I have ever had. I have had their double chocolate, peanut butter cup, key lime, strawberry shortcake, and churro cupcakes. Each one is unique and tasty. The key lime gave me a pleasant surprise when I bit in and discovered the graham cracker crust on the bottom. The frosting is not as sweet as some have reported — particularly on the peanut butter cup where the frosting is nice and peanut buttery. The staff is always nice and patient even with my indecisive kids.

I think Is good, i think the cake bites are nothing special but I love sweets so is good, I like all sugar stuff… I can make very good cakes too.

One cupcake: Toasted Coconut… absolutely moist, fresh, salivating-​ly delish! And that was mid-​week, late at night. Place was hopping for a reason. They are soooooo yum. Not from a box and icing def NOT from a big white tub !!

Okay, they are called «Sweet Tooth Fairy» for a reason: it’s SWEET! (literally sweet as in sugary)
After seeing this store, I asked aloud to the people I was with what this store is about. One of the customers heard me and that stranger just said, «their cupcakes are amazing!»
Well, considering the stranger was bold enough to speak aloud to me, I decided to check them out. I ordered the strawberry shortcake cupcake since this was supposed to be one of their best sellers. It had the pink icing with some additional sauce (forgive me, I can’t think of the word now). Anyway, this was way sweet… like WAY sweet. So, if you’re into sweet sweet foods, this may be for you, but it was a little much for me. =)
***DISCLAIMER: This is based off of ONE cupcake, so take this comment or leave it!

My first time here and I loved the cupcake shake that I got. My sisters got shakes, cookies & a cupcake and they enjoyed theirs as well. We came in 10 minutes before closing and they still welcomed us politely. That’s always a plus for me because sometimes cravings start late! lol! The cupcakes were low though, but them again it was about to close. I’m glad we popped in while visiting Utah!